4 ms·
SAT Scores and Family Income: The least surprising correlation of all time
- eli 17y agoIt'd be much more interesting if they tried to tackle which specific factors made the most difference. (Based on my own anecdotal experience, rich people are not especially smarter than the poor or middle-class) Perhaps a better question is which school did you attend? Or, did you take a prep course?
- _h4xr 17y ago(Based on my own anecdotal experience, rich people are not especially smarter than the poor or middle-class) IQ correlates better that parental socio-economic standing. But there are lots of factors that make this appear false -- the people you spend time with might be mostly of a certain class, or in a particular IQ stratum.
- hughprime 17y agoBased on my experience that's half true: rich kids aren't noticeably smarter than middle-class kids, but middle-class kids are noticeably smarter than the truly poor kids. This is about what we'd expect, assuming a society which is reasonably meritocratic and intelligence which is at least partly inheiritable.
- scott_s 17y agoIt's easy to explain that phenomenon without calling upon meritocracy or inherited traits: people with more resources (human and material) have more opportunity to become smarter.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sp332 17y agoOr maybe poor people value something other than intelligence. This argument works for both heritable and learned attributes.
- tokenadult 17y agoIt's too bad these data aren't reported each year by the College Board as a scatterplot, to show the large variance in SAT scores at all self-reported income levels. See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:1995-SAT-Income2.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:1995-SAT-Income2.png (which appears to be based on genuine data from the College Board, the one year it released such data) for another view of what might be going on. After edit: See the other thread just opened here on HN also: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=791381 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=791381
- byoung2 17y agoWhen I taught SAT at Kaplan I participated in a program called SAT Advantage where we offered SAT prep for free at high schools in low-income areas. I had several students score in the 95th percentile (Kaplan hires teachers who score 90th percentile or higher), and one got a perfect score in math. It is possible with a little effort to beat the odds. The wealthy kids I usually taught had parents who could afford $1000 for an SAT class or $3000 for private tutoring. An idea I have for an educational technology startup would level this playing field using the web.
- _h4xr 17y agoMy impression was that it's pretty rare to move more than half a standard deviation by using test prep. And that median is skewed by the fact that scores fluctuate from one session to another, but the lower scores are discarded.
- byoung2 17y agoI went from a 1340 to a 1520 after a Kaplan course when I was in high school. On the average, massive score improvements are rare, but there are definitely some test prep teachers who can consistently get better score improvements from students. The secret is tailoring your approach to different students' needs. I always looked at the types of questions my students got wrong to identify patterns. If you can fix a bad habit you can get bigger score gains with less effort. My best success story was a student who went from a 980 to a 1420 (out of 1600). That's about 50th percentile to 95th percentile. Another student went from hoping to meet the NCAA minimum for a baseball scholarship to getting an academic full ride. The last student I taught almost beat my score...I took the new SAT in 2005 along with him and he got a 2180 out of 2400 (I got a 2280...99th percentile).
- gwern 17y ago> It is possible with a little effort to beat the odds. The wealthy kids I usually taught had parents who could afford $1000 for an SAT class or $3000 for private tutoring. An idea I have for an educational technology startup would level this playing field using the web. I once took an SAT prep class; it wasn't one of the 3k private tutoring classes, but I remember thinking, as I finished the last class, 'I learned and did nothing here that wasn't already in this mammoth SAT prep book'. Libraries around here have tons of these SAT prep books, even for the newer SATs. I suspect that libraries (school and otherwise) even in your low-income areas have at least 1 or 2 decent SAT prep books. What could your startup do for the kids in these low-income areas that they can't already do for themselves with the prep books available to them? If it is a lack of motivation or awareness, how would your startup motivate them to actually do the studying or get them more aware of the startup's resources than of the books?
- tvaughan 17y agohttp://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/least-surprising-correlation-of-all.html http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/08/least-surprising-corr...
- padmanabhan01 17y agowth. If I read that right, he just stated that intelligence is something inherited.
- smanek 17y agoAll the existing data says it is largely inherited
- gabrielroth 17y agoBoy is that false. http://bit.ly/2RzLIp http://bit.ly/2RzLIp Edit: full URL is http://books.google.com/books?id=YdnK_PLtDVQC&pg=PA33&lpg=PA33&dq=adopted+children+socioeconomic+achievement&source=bl&ots=_PwZXj_1H9&sig=eDYHYqSCheN5yAyKHJMaMeMeXw4&hl=en&ei=bu2XSu2lK4mXlAe6-onKBQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1#v=onepage&q=adopted%20children%20socioeconomic%20achievement&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=YdnK_PLtDVQC&pg=PA33...
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoFirst, please don't use shortened URLs. Second, here's a few counterpoints: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090317142841.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090317142841.ht... http://www.nytimes.com/1990/10/12/us/study-raises-the-estimate-of-inherited-intelligence.html http://www.nytimes.com/1990/10/12/us/study-raises-the-estima...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- padmanabhan01 17y ago
- grandalf 17y agoThe scores are mostly all in the average range. I'd be curious to see the income graph for scores at -2, -1, +1, +2, and +3 standard deviations from the mean.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe graph shows the central tendency of scores (the median score) for each self-reported income range. As I posted in my first reply here, it is regrettable that College Board doesn't simply report a scatter plot of all score levels found in all self-reported income ranges.
- ShabbyDoo 17y agoWhat surprises me most about these graphs is how relatively flat they are! Let's pretend for a moment that the distribution of SAT scores across income strata would be identical if all kids were forced to take the test. Given that a much greater percentage of wealthy kids take the SAT and the probability one takes it likely increases along with his expected score, you would think the correlation would be the inverse of the NYT graph. If a wealthy child is an idiot, his parents will encourage him to take the test in hope that some college somewhere will accept him. But, a dumb poor kid probably dropped out of school before he had a chance to even take the SAT. So, the positive correlation in the NYT article suggests a much greater disparity of test taking ability (and all that it might imply) than just the slope of the graph naively implies.
- gjm11 17y agoThere's one thing about it that surprises me a little: the comparatively big jump moving between the $180k-$200k and the $200k+ categories. Sure, that last category includes the veryveryvery rich as well as the merely quite rich, but I'd have expected -- wrongly, perhaps -- that both the link between (parents') intelligence and wealth, and the ability of wealth to purchase better education (in a broad sense). would be showing diminishing returns by that point. Perhaps it's just a statistical artefact: the last category is relatively small. On the other hand, the absolute numbers are pretty big.
- MaysonL 17y agoAnd here's an example pointing to how this correlation can be broken: http://www.hcz.org/our-results http://www.hcz.org/our-results