3 ms·
This is a very interesting topic, but unfortunately the information is marred by a very poor presentation. Is that really the best way he could think of to pre
by ars 12y ago
This is a very interesting topic, but unfortunately the information is marred by a very poor presentation.
Is that really the best way he could think of to present that data?
Both the chart and the map are virtually unreadable if you want to get an idea of the movement patterns in relation to education.
And it doesn't help that it's not scaled by the size of the cities, instead showing the absolute number of the change.
- drewblaisdell 12y ago> Both the chart and the map are virtually unreadable if you want to get an idea of the movement patterns in relation to education. I think this map does a fine job of showing movement patterns in relation to education: http://cdn.theatlantic.com/newsroom/img/posts/2014/06/Migration_by_Education_Metro_Chart/c908bc7ed.jpg http://cdn.theatlantic.com/newsroom/img/posts/2014/06/Migrat...
- ars 12y ago> I think this map does a fine job of showing movement patterns in relation to education It most definitely does not. It does a mediocre job of showing movement patterns, and a terrible job of relating them to education. To show movement patterns it needs to show relative change, not absolute change. To show education changes it needs a completely different format. (And that's not a map.)
- nilkn 12y agoWouldn't scaling by the size of the cities make it even harder to judge where people are actually going or moving away from? Maybe you're looking for something different in the data than I am, but it seems like that would obscure the most important numbers.
- ars 12y agoIt depends on what you do. If you are coloring the whole US by movement then use the absolute values. But if you are making a chart, or making circles then you have to. To see this, look at a large-circle city. Now imagine that same city has two neighborhoods, and you list them separately, now suddenly your large circle becomes two small circles, or the top-ranking city on your chart is suddenly a middling city Yet nothing actually changed in how people move!