6 ms·
This is interesting I think... iPad: Kindle Fire, Nexus 7 Apple TV: Kindle Fire TV, Chromecast iTunes: Amazon Prime Streaming TV + now music, Google Play iP
by Consultant32452 12y ago
This is interesting I think...
iPad: Kindle Fire, Nexus 7
Apple TV: Kindle Fire TV, Chromecast
iTunes: Amazon Prime Streaming TV + now music, Google Play
iPhone: Kindle Fire Phone, Nexus 4
I think they're all playing for the same territory. The big difference seems to be that Apple really only sells the technology. Google sells the technology so that they can sell advertising for third party products. Amazon has the only complete end to end solution where they sell you the products and advertise for their own "other stuff" they sell. IMHO Amazon is going to be the big winner in the long run. Whether or not that's good for all of us is yet to be determined.
- drcode 12y agoYou make a good point: Apple: Sell at high price, modest tie-in revenue. Google: Sell at low price, modest tie-in revenue. Amazon: Sell at low price, high tie-in revenue. It does seem like Amazon is bound to win in the long run, based on pure economics, if this trend continues.
- IBM 12y agoExcept it isn't being sold at a low price, and doesn't really offer anything valuable to the customer that differentiates it from the competition. The implicit deal was always the product is sold at cost so they can encourage sales on the store, why would anyone pay full price for this?
- drcode 12y agoFair enough, but I suspect the profit margins on this phone are pretty slim, given the hardware features. I think Bezos figured the high end hardware was necessary to initially break into the market.
- evanmoran 12y agoAgreed. If they initially brand the Fire phone as a high-end device it will seem more valuable when they ruthlessly cut its price=).
- endergen 12y agoIt's likely subsidized by the AT&T exclusive. I believe it's $200/month plus some contract. Which means they may be getting kickbacks totaling more than $200/device which would improve their margins. Or more interestingly, mean the device can be higher end and impress people more while at least not being a loss for Amazon. It's basically a store interface, leading to increased sales. Firefly is like Shazam for products, people will likely buy way more from Amazon.
- endergen 12y agoIt's likely subsidized by the AT&T exclusive. I believe it's $200/month plus some contract. Which means they may be getting kickbacks totaling more than $200/device which would improve their margins. Or more interestingly, mean the device can be higher end and impress people more while at least not being a loss for Amazon. It's basically a store interface, leading to increased sales. Firefly is like Shazam for products, people will likely buy way more from Amazon.
- spankalee 12y agoI don't get this assumption. All three same basically the same content at presumably roughly the same margins.
- autokad 12y agono, Appple margins- HUGE, Amazon margins - small (like a few hundred million on 50 billion top line). Google is somewhere in between. On content, they deliver content very differently. delivery is important
- liricooli 12y agoI don't think this perspective is correct regarding to the current different business models these companies have. Apple: We sell an experience of software and hardware. Google: We sell ads, based on data we gather from our users. Amazon: We sell commodities\services as close as possible to the marginal utility, so we're very competitive. Altough each of these tech giants are competing, each has quite a different strategy. As for the Fire phone, I think that Amazon realized that they could deliver an excellent shopping experience from the mobile phone. This would enable massive future growth: Think about going home in the train and buying groceries instead of driving to your nearest Wallmart.
- liricooli 12y agoI don't think this perspective is correct regarding to the current different business models these companies have. Apple: We sell an experience of software and hardware. Google: We sell ads, based on data we gather from our users. Amazon: We sell commodities\services as close as possible to the marginal utility, so we're very competitive. Altough each of these tech giants are competing, each has quite a different strategy. As for the Fire phone, I think that Amazon realized that they could deliver an excellent shopping experience from the mobile phone. This would enable massive future growth: Think about going home in the train and buying groceries instead of driving to your nearest Wallmart.
- glesica 12y agoI wonder how this relates to IBM of old which had a business model that amounted to "Sell at high price, high tie-in revenue." It didn't work out so well for them (at least for their PC business), turned out that people didn't really want to be "tied"-in.
- r00fus 12y agoGiven the PC business was already commoditizing (because of IBM's insane reliance on Microsoft without the proper contract to prevent what happened), the high price sale couldn't compete as well against lower priced products. Plus most of their sales were B2B where brand loyalty means little for commodity products, esp. given the high tie-in strategy.
- Steko 12y agoWhat trend, the trend where Amazon is an also ran in tablets, set top boxes and soon to be phones? Apple's hobby TV product which hasn't been updated in 18 months made about the same profits last quarter as Amazon's entire business. Let that statement sink in. Revenue =/= profits. Amazon is a middleman and are only successful at generating revenue growth because they don't make profits.
- jsight 12y agoWhere do you see a figure for Apple TV profits? I haven't seen where that is broken out.
- dkrich 12y agoYou're saying that Amazon will be the big winner in the long run because they can control the phone, and the products you buy on Amazon? If I'm interpreting that correctly, I don't see how that holds. People use smartphones/tablets/televisions to consume many things. Amazon products are just one of them. I don't think that just because controlling the entire product ecosystem would work to Amazon's advantage means that customers will want a phone that enables that end-to-end control. The end-to-end control works well for the Kindle, because eReaders are used really only for reading the books that are available only on Amazon's eReader marketplace. But I can shop Amazon from any device I want. So having a phone that owns that experience isn't a major value proposition for me. I'm much more interested in things like display, battery life, camera quality, sound quality, and the phone's popularity than which product ecosystem it taps into. To me Amazon is working from a major disadvantage here. The technology doesn't seem mind-blowing, the device at first blush doesn't look remarkably different from what's already available, and since phones are largely subsidized by carriers, most customers aren't going to be hugely price-sensitive. If anything, people opt for the most expensive, newest phones. If Amazon is looking for the people who will spend the most money, they certainly won't be interested in customers who think $199 is too much to spend for a new phone that they will use every day for at least two years (which is a moot point since the phone is priced at $199).
- Consultant32452 12y agoGoogle sells you a device so they can show you an ad encouraging you to buy a rake. In turn Google gets a sliver of the profits from selling a rake in the form of ad revenue. Amazon sells you a device so they can show you an ad encouraging you to buy a rake. Amazon sells you the rake, has it delivered in 2 days, and makes 100% of the profit. It's not that people will actively look for that integration, but that it exists gives Amazon a significant advantage imho.
- nijiko 12y agofalse, they buy through vendors so they don't make 100% of the profit.
- brianpgordon 12y ago
- jeroen 12y agoAmazon is the only one with a physical goods tie-in, but Apple also sells apps, songs, books and films. I think Tim Cook recently mentioned 75 billion app downloads.
- Consultant32452 12y agoAmazon and Google both also sell apps, songs, books, and films. Apple's selection is larger, but they're all somewhat equal in the sense that they have similar offerings.
- personZ 12y agoGoogle sells the technology so that they can sell advertising for third party products. I see this a lot of HN, and I wonder if people are just assuming? To put it into context, I see far more ads on my iPad and iPad Touch than I ever have on my Nexus 5. Outside of the money Google makes from their book, video, and apps stores, they sell the technology to ensure that their services remain viable, and cannot be cut out of the market. They make the platform so Google has less concern about being cut out of the ecosystem. I mean we see the paradox on here constantly where people will gloat about how much more valuable iOS users are to advertisers, but then that Android is a platform for ads.
- sosborn 12y ago>They make the platform so Google has less concern about being cut out of the ecosystem. True, but let's not ignore that their core business is selling advertising. Before Android came along that business was at the mercy of Apple (in the mobile space anyway). >I mean we see the paradox on here constantly where people will gloat about how much more valuable iOS users are to advertisers, but then that Android is a platform for ads. Android isn't specifically a platform for ads, but it was indeed built so that Google wouldn't lose the ability to serve ads on mobile hardware.
- personZ 12y agoGoogle's core business is making services that people like to use. That they monetize some of those services via advertisements is a function of the industry that they operate in: There was no market for a pay search engine, or even a pay consumer mail provider: Those genres had long been supported by ads, and users expected that. Anything else was a non-starter.
- mwfunk 12y agoTheir core business is that monetization, by definition. Making services that people like to use is what they do to feed that core business, not vice versa. They are constantly scrambling to find different ways to make money because they are a company run by extremely wealthy and intelligent people who would love for all of the great things they do to be in service of some core business other than selling targeted ads. So far they haven't had the same level of success in any of those other endeavors, but I completely understand why they keep trying.
- GoldenMonkey 12y agoAmazon has always been viewed in the long-term as the 'big winner'. But, Apple makes good money and is growing revenue, on the back-end with their 850 million iTunes users. Amazon's dominance is always a 'future certainty', meanwhile Apple eats it's lunch. i.e. "iTunes, Software and Services has been growing between 30% and 40% for four years and is on its way to $30 billion/yr in transactions and sales for 2014." http://www.asymco.com/2014/05/09/measuring-not-getting-the-cloud/ http://www.asymco.com/2014/05/09/measuring-not-getting-the-c...
- thoughtsimple 12y agoAs the saying goes: Google wants to sell you, Amazon wants to sell you stuff, and Apple just wants your money.
- ryanSrich 12y agoBut Apple's products are so far superior it's almost comical to say they compete. Quality of construction and UX are what make amazing products. Not overhyped hardware specs that the average user doesn't even take advantage of. Until Google or Amazon comes out with a truly gorgeous easy to use interface and a metal/glass phone I don't see them competing with Apple. EDIT: Apparently the Fire Phone has a glass back, but it looks like plastic bevels. No thanks.
- Sxw1212 12y agoYou can't forget Firefox OS phones. I see those as Amazons main competitor for cheap smartphones.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shykes 12y ago> Amazon has the only complete end to end solution where they sell you the products and advertise for their own "other stuff" they sell. IMHO Amazon is going to be the big winner in the long run. I think you are vastly under-estimating Apple's dominant position in the fastest-growing and most profitable category of "selling other stuff": digital content. Itunes is on track to $30 billion revenue this year with huge yearly growth several years in a row. That is almost half of all Amazon revenue combined! And presumably with vastly better margins, too. In the next decades people will spend more and more on digital goods (Apple's turf), at the expense of physical goods (Amazon's turf). Amazon will do anything to avoid being leapfrogged that way. They have a very strong cloud infrastructure story, obviously, and are playing decent catch-up in many other areas, but in the grand scheme of things they are very far from the guaranteed winners.