4 ms·
Any company that acts like a phone company (e.g. providing real phone numbers) is regulated and taxed like a phone company. The fact that some of them run part
by wmf 12y ago
Any company that acts like a phone company (e.g. providing real phone numbers) is regulated and taxed like a phone company. The fact that some of them run part of the call over the Internet isn't why they're being regulated, but it doesn't magically exempt them from regulation either.
The same thinking applies to all companies. If you're doing something regulated, then doing it over the Internet will still be regulated. If you're doing something unregulated then doing it over the Internet will still be unregulated. Title II shouldn't make any difference.
- rayiner 12y agoSo Google Voice and Skype should be taxed? Beyond that, isn't "real phone numbers" a totally arbitrary distinction when everything is running on the internet? Just a different sort of endpoint identifier. What you're really trying to tax is "real time voice communications." So shouldn't Facetime be taxed too?
- wmf 12y agoEverything isn't running on the Internet. When you use Google Voice to call a number that isn't part of GV (which is probably the majority of calls), your call is going over the PSTN. And touching the PSTN is what gets you regulated. Facetime is a good example of a system that isn't and shouldn't be regulated because AFAIK it doesn't touch the PSTN.
- rayiner 12y agoBut touching the PSTN isn't where VOIP gets regulated under the FCC rules. If you have Vonage and only make VOIP to VOIP calls, you still pay the tax. That's the whole point of bringing up USF: one can imagine ways to limit the USF fees to the PSTN network, but the FCC has used its regulatory authority to reach a broader set of service providers. Also: the PSTN angle is a red herring anyway. Now that USF is used to fund broadband, its arbitrary to limit USF taxes to something that touches the PSTN network.