5 ms·
As the article says, the routine use of hormones and antibiotics for livestock has been banned for almost a decade in Europe. What scares me is that with the n
by alkonaut 12y ago
As the article says, the routine use of hormones and antibiotics for livestock has been banned for almost a decade in Europe.
What scares me is that with the new trade deal currently being hammered out between the EU and the US, there is a lot of pressure to "harmonize" the regulations, meaning the US will demand their chlorine-rinsed chicken, and hormone/antibiotics filled beef be allowed in the european markets.
- koyote 12y ago>meaning the US will demand their chlorine-rinsed chicken, and hormone/antibiotics filled beef be allowed in the european markets. Is there no chance of it being the other way around?
- alkonaut 12y agoThere is a possibility that some authority in the US will (be lobbied to) require hormones/chlorine-rinsing/antibiotics in order for the food to be deemed safe for American consumers, yes. So sadly, there needs to be some "harmonization" meaning turning the clock back a couple of decades in Europe.
- RyanMcGreal 12y agoFunny how these trade agreements always "harmonize" downwards.
- relampago 12y agoOnly way to stop that is for the consumer to not allow it to happen.
- ep103 12y agoPoor people have to buy cheap food. So that is not a real option.
- Mz 12y agoI am currently poor (for an American). I do not really buy cheap food. Good quality food is my single biggest expense. It keeps me out of the ER (where I am supposed to practically live, given my medical condition). I do this even though I routinely run short on funds at the end of the month and this sometimes means fasting for a day or so or simply being short-rationed the last week. Going hungry part of the time harms my health less than eating crap all of the time. People are people first and foremost and their current economic/social class is not the only determiner of their lifestyle choices.
- albemuth 12y ago>I am currently poor >I do not really buy cheap food
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Mz 12y agoEating well is far cheaper than the medical bills I am supposed to have. My health problems are the root cause of my poverty. Resolving my health problems is my only hope of escaping poverty. Your snark is not appreciated.
- alkonaut 12y agoYour healthcare system (which allows a tie betwen health and poverty) is the root problem of your poverty. Your statement about health problems leading to poverty means a guess of your home country would be "Third world country, or the US". How screwed up is that? I hope your health improves.
- Mz 12y agoIn my case, that is an inaccurate assumption. My father was career military and so was my ex husband, thus most of my medical care has been free or damn cheap. I was married to my ex long enough while he was in the military that I still qualify for free medical treatment on the federal dime. My poverty is rooted in a) being unable to work a normal job and b) using alternative treatments to effectively treat what conventional medicine does not currently know how to effectively treat. I was trying to avoid addressing what is a complex situation that has a history of getting me in social hot water. I do understand why, based on my earlier comment, you would draw this conclusion but that isn't really the case for me personally. Granted, I think America should go to government paid healthcare for all citizens. I think the current system sucks tremendously. My health is improving. Thanks for your well wishes.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoYou realize that beef, being a large mammal and all, already has hormones in it regardless of whether they're artificial or not?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoWow, my most downvoted comment yet, and for pointing out that cows have hormones in them. I guess the downvoters believe that the artificial variety are magically different from the natural sort, despite being chemically and biologically indistinguishable.
- jodrellblank 12y agoRoutine use of antibiotics to promote growth encourages antibiotic resistance, if nothing else. The down voters believe your characterisation of them as utterly stupid is misplaced and adds nothing to the thread.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoPlease read my comment and point out where I typed "antibiotics" or any other term commonly understood to mean that class of drugs. I'm slightly dyslexic, and my brain must be scrambling the word, because when I read through it again, I don't see it. > The down voters believe your characterisation of them as utterly stupid Then they've proved me right. The correct way to show me wrong is to actually compose a salient rebuttal, which would by its nature show me to be a fool. Hell, I might even end up so shamed I'd apologize. The only conclusion possible though is that they knew they could not do this and did not make the attempt like the cowards that they are. > and adds nothing to the thread. How can it not add to the thread? Well, unless you want the thread to be an echo chamber and demand conformity of opinion.
- jodrellblank 12y agoPlease read my comment and point out where I said that you typed "antibiotics" or any other term commonly understood to mean that class of drugs. Or don't, because I didn't and you didn't and that's irrelevant. The original post implies that American beef has added hormones and antibiotics compared to European beef, and the person posting considers that to be worse quality. A common concern is the addition of growth hormones and growth promoting antibiotics and the effect that might have in the food chain and the people eating it and so on. Your statement that cows are animals with hormones doesn't touch on any of that, and your implication that people are only downvoting you because they think cows do not have hormones and refusing to prove you wrong because they're cowards is ridiculous trolling.
- snake_plissken 12y agoWait, what, chlorine-rinsed chicken?
- pcrh 12y agoThis refers to the practice of dipping freshly butchered chickens in chlorine to kill salmonella bacteria. In Europe they vaccinate the chickens instead.
- alkonaut 12y agoIn a few countries (e.g. Sweden) there is neither vaccination nor any antibacterial treatment of the meat. And salmonella is nearly a non-issue. Climate may be a factor, but probably not the only factor. imho if we allow "cheap" treatments such as vaccination or preventive antibiotics, that also means we allow a cheaper way of keeping your animals healthy (cheaper than rigorous routines for hygiene/disease control/animal separation). if it's allowed to do so, it's a competitive edge, so it becomes standard practice.
- pinaceae 12y agoUse of anti-biotics for livestock has not been banned in Europe, where exactly do you get this info from? The article talks about the Dutch stopping the use of anti-biotics as preventive measures, a practice where you feed animals antibiotics so that they cannot get sick in the first place. Once the animal is sick, they can still be treated with AB. And to clear something up: Organic-labeled beef in the US is AB free, you can only label beef organic if no antibiotics were used full stop. Germany? Organic beef is allowed to have been treated with AB. The world of food and animal safety is not as black and white as you might think. The FDA has instilled some pretty harsh rules that have not been adopted in the EU. Same goes with cars btw, the rules on Diesel emissions are ways stricter in the US, etc. Different safety standards as well.
- alkonaut 12y ago> Use of anti-biotics for livestock has not been banned in Europe, where exactly do you get this info from? http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock#European_Union http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibiotic_use_in_livestock#E... (And by Europe I meant the EU) Sadly, not all countries seem to respect the ban.