9 ms·
The Abstinence Method – Dutch farmers say no to antibiotics for livestock
- Mz 12y agoI upvoted a different story from this site and somehow found myself reading this (no doubt an oopsy of mousing) and trying to figure out the tie-in to the title I thought I was reading. :-P Having figured out my error, I think this is a far more fascinating piece about one country deciding to drastically reduce its use of antibiotics in meat production. Excerpts: There are points of tension. Disease-prevention dosing can be a hedge against sloppy practices: With the drugs no longer available, farmers have to pay close attention to hygiene, diet and stress. Not all are willing to do so. And: Oosterlaken also revels in the challenge of farming without the crutch of antibiotics, and proudly shows off the changes he has made on his farm. He is obsessive about biosecurity, requiring visitors to shower and shampoo, change into fresh clothes and underwear that he supplies and then don scrubbed boots color-keyed to different areas.
- Retric 12y agoI think the most shocking point is To this day, when members of Dutch farm families go into hospitals, they are put into isolation rooms until lab tests show they are clear of the germ. That has got to change peoples mindsets and could easily end up happening in the US.
- Mz 12y agoTo me, the most shocking (and also encouraging) point is that before they made this decision: ... farms in the Netherlands were European leaders in antibiotic use. They seem to have done an about face. This gives me hope that minds can be changed elsewhere.
- camillomiller 12y agoThe lobbying power in the U.S. Is far more powerful, though
- Someone 12y agoIs it? Looking at http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_sector_composition http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_sect..., the USA's agricultiral sector is 1.12% of GDP, while the Dutch one is 2.8%. One could argue that relative size buys lobbying power.
- camillomiller 12y agoI think you're arguing wrong. First: there's not so much lobbying in Northern Europe countries. Second: you should look at the size of the food and distribution industries, more than the agricultural sector
- mcv 12y agoThere's plenty of lobbying in northern Europe, but in the US, there's even more.
- Someone 12y agoThe power you get for lobbying is not directly proportional to the amount of money you spend on it; if there is less competition, lobbying will be more efficient. That's why I question the claim that the lobbying is more powerful in the USA, compared to that in the Netherlands. Second: the Dutch food and distribution industries are quite sizable. Looking at http://www.iamexpat.nl/read-and-discuss/expat-page/news/dutch-agricultural-sector-worlds-second-largest http://www.iamexpat.nl/read-and-discuss/expat-page/news/dutc...: "The agricultural sector in the Netherlands constitutes around 10 per cent of the Dutch economy and employs more than 660.000 people, 50.000 of which are farmers."
- speleding 12y agoActually, it is not entirely impossible that with the prevalence of MRSA bacteria in the US there will come a point when US visitors to Dutch hospitals will need to be quarantined as a precaution. The resulting headlines would make a powerful agent for change indeed.
- DanBC 12y agoAny body admitted to a UK hospital is swabbed (nose and groin) for MRSA. I would be interested to see what the ratios are split by where the person was recently living.
- arethuza 12y agoInteresting, I had no idea they were doing that: http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/MRSA/Pages/MRSAscreeningwhattoexpect.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/MRSA/Pages/MRSAscreeningwhattoe...
- Mvandenbergh 12y agoAll Americans admitted to Icelandic hospitals are in fact immediately isolated until they can be tested for MRSA. It wouldn't surprise me if they did the same for British patients given the prevalence of MRSA in the UK.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoSuch precautions remind me of the 'mad cow disease' outbreak some years ago in the UK and Netherlands; not a bad approach, really. You're trying to chuck tens of thousands of animals on as small an area as possible (NL isn't too large after all), just like people that's a huge hygiene and potential disease outbreak risk. It's one way to deal with overpopulation.
- w0utert 12y agoMad cow disease (BSE) was not related to hygiene or how many animals were crammed into how little space. It was caused by mixing their food with the ground-down remains of other cows, especially their brain parts.
- bra-ket 12y agorelated: The global threat of antibiotic resistance https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7674550 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7674550
- anigbrowl 12y agoWhat an inspiring story. The dutch seem to be particularly good at quantifying externalities and negotiating change, which may be due to their 'Polder model' of governance. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polder_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polder_model
- nasmorn 12y agoI just saw a documentary on German tv showimg mich the Same thing for Danish pig farmers so it is not an isolated example. It is a simple issue of incentives. Even more impressive was that zero anti biotics use in pig farming practiced by a farmer who had his pigs in stables with free range access was only 40% more expensive. Just think about it. We endanger the most important scientific advancement in human health for cheaper bacon.
- rejschaap 12y agoIt is not that simple though. It is rational to not eat meat that contains antibiotics or fruit and vegetables that contain pesticides. But you need the time, money, resources, knowledge and organisation to actually pull it off. I don't know there is some sort of Maslow pyramid for countries, but a lot of countries might just not be ready to face this problem just yet. For instance, China wasn't too bothered about pollution until recently, they were (and still are) busy raising the general standard of living. Similarly, the United States might not be ready to attack this problem just yet because they are busy attacking... other things.
- Cthulhu_ 12y ago> Just think about it. We endanger the most important scientific advancement in human health for cheaper bacon. Because that's what the consumer wants. Apparently. Supermarkets have been competing with each other on prices for ages, a well-known example is chicken fillet. The price has gone down to just E3 per kilo at one point, which caused a bit of a riot because those were the famous 'plofkip' (exploding chicken), or chickens that were forced to grow as large as possible in as little time as possible. But there's the other side, too; farms like the one described in the opening post can thank their existence over an increase in demand for 'organic' meat, or meat that gets a label indicating it was grown in an animal-friendly fashion without use of antibiotics and growth hormone. Conscious consumers with a decent income will be more inclined to pay a premium for that kind of meat.
- gregpilling 12y agoInteresting article. The farmer that requires visitors to shampoo, probably has very few visitors.
- vanderZwan 12y agoI dunno, if it's a pig farmer I'd take that as a signal it will be a cleaner place than expected.
- ht_th 12y agoIt is about visiting the inner farm, so to speak. You can visit farms all you like, but once you come in close contact with animals, i.e., go into the animal barn, you're supposed to clean. The inner farms never had much visitors, especially in the industrial scale farming. Those who would visit anyway, vets, workers, maybe colleagues or students, will not have a problem with thorough cleaning, I suppose.
- rurounijones 12y agoOne of the things that stood out for me was the emphasis on transparency when comparing farms and vets together based on their use of antibiotics. Without that transparency I think it would fail.
- Qantourisc 12y agoI'm from Belgium, and I didn't see this article anywhere in my newspapers :/ Keep up the good work HN :)
- dwightgunning 12y agoIn my experience living here, it's not only the farmers. Dutch doctors typically avoid prescribing general antibiotics (or advising anything stronger than paracetamol) to people.
- rejschaap 12y agoThe article mentions this. There was this twisted situation in Netherlands where doctors avoided antibiotics as much as possible. At the same time farmers were using more antibiotics than necessary. The latter effectively undoes the effort of Dutch doctors to keep resistance to antibiotics low.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoYeah, definite cultural difference from, for example, the US. But I'm pretty sure doctors there get money and gifts and whatnot from the pharmaceutical industry to supply large quantities of heavy pain killers.
- junto 12y agoMy wife's cousin owns a dairy farm in Germany and only uses homeopathic medicines on the cows. When I stifled a chuckle, he indignantly pointed out that not only does it appear to work for his cows, it isn't as if the cows can understand him, nor know that they are being treated. However much I have my doubts about homeopathy, his cows seemed healthy and weren't being pumped full of antibiotics; hence I saw it as a good thing.
- RyanMcGreal 12y agoHomeopathy "works" because most illnesses are self-limiting. For example, homeopathics appear to treat the common cold successfully, with the caveat that they take about a week or two to take effect.
- zellyn 12y agoMy understanding is that for the common cold, that's how "real" medicine works too. :-)
- mverwijs 12y agoThe thing that jumps out at me from the article is the sheer size of 'the broiler farm that 160.000 chickens call home.' If anything this article makes me feel ashamed for being Dutch.
- tirant 12y agoWhy? Those chickens are living in much better conditions that others in chicken farms all around the world.
- mverwijs 12y agoThe fact that others are worse off does not in any way help the horrible predicament these chickens are in.
- Synaesthesia 12y agoIt's not ideal, but if you look at how chickens are usually farmed, it's in the dark, in wire cages stacked on top of each other this is much better! Battery cages are completely unsanitary, the birds are covered in shit the whole time and can easily get injured, and much more stressful than this.
- rejschaap 12y agoYeah, these chickens are healthy, they might even be happy there. They could do a lot worse. If someone really doesn't like the idea of broiler farm chickens, they can pay a little extra for free range chickens. Or pay even more to buy them off a local farmer. Or just switch to something else entirely, there are plenty of alternatives available today.
- riffraff 12y agohow do you see that those chicken are healthy? I ask honestly because my first thought at the picture was that, If anything, it shows that the chickens have bad plumage[0] and are mostly sitting down[1]. For [1] my guess is either the animals pick on each other too much, or they are actually chicks that have grown in size faster than they should. For [2] it may mean that they have weak bones/muscles (due to bad feeding, inflated growth and no movement) and that they are actually laying in their own filth. It may still be better than cages, of course.
- txutxu 12y agoNice to read this. Now. There is no enough meat farmers in the Netherlands, to produce all the meat consumed _daily_ in the Netherlands. I´ve been living and working there. I'm a meat lover. The Netherlands is the Hell for a person with the same tastes than me (many years of high quality meat and vegetables and cooking practices). Meat in the Netherlands is of very bad quality and very high price (I will avoid more colloquial expressions of my basic english). In those countries that dutch people call "monkeys" or "Moroccans" (this is, portugal, spain, italy and greece) the meat is much better in quality and price... but... we don't have the "autosuggestion" of "we are the best" than dutch people have (even with their street reality). I don't trust news years ago, but I trust my experience. The pseudo-nazi dutch people (the first place in the world where I did meet black-skin-nazis, gay-nazis, jew-nazis, etc), are very prone to believe, say and sell, that they are the best, this news are very well crafted for their mind, I don't want to live on a country with the meat quality and price of the Netherlands streets. I know the reality there. I prefer to be a "Moroccan monkey discriminated european" for them, and take meat and tomatoes of the mountains of my not so auto-suggested, auto-inclined, people. And live with the bad reality (and crafted news) of my country. Enjoy the meal, and sleep on ignorance and discriminatory abundance, and justify yourself your incoherent reality, dear dutch people.
- wobbleblob 12y agoThis post is actually one of the most positive reviews of Dutch food I have ever seen =)
- txutxu 12y agoWell, it may seem positive, but here in the inferior south, that photos could destroy the day of many (sub)people. We prefer animals and tomatoes not grow in those conditions shown in the photos (we get them, at the same prices, but grow with space and natural food). I don't know why the article does not talk about the technologies used to modify vegetables and animals. I don't care if they don't get antibiotics, while they are transgenics, clones, or grow with irradiation and other technologies. Also sorry and excuses to those offended downvoters, I can probe each word, I said them with care of not let me go, but I could go on, if somebody clarify the disagreement
- otec 12y agoThe most common meats (chicken, beef, pork) in the Netherlands that can be bought in supermarkets (AH, C1000 and etc) is indeed of low quality. It's still better than in the US, but if you compare it to meat from Italy, Spain, France it's extremely bad.
- alkonaut 12y agoAs the article says, the routine use of hormones and antibiotics for livestock has been banned for almost a decade in Europe. What scares me is that with the new trade deal currently being hammered out between the EU and the US, there is a lot of pressure to "harmonize" the regulations, meaning the US will demand their chlorine-rinsed chicken, and hormone/antibiotics filled beef be allowed in the european markets.
- koyote 12y ago>meaning the US will demand their chlorine-rinsed chicken, and hormone/antibiotics filled beef be allowed in the european markets. Is there no chance of it being the other way around?
- alkonaut 12y agoThere is a possibility that some authority in the US will (be lobbied to) require hormones/chlorine-rinsing/antibiotics in order for the food to be deemed safe for American consumers, yes. So sadly, there needs to be some "harmonization" meaning turning the clock back a couple of decades in Europe.
- RyanMcGreal 12y agoFunny how these trade agreements always "harmonize" downwards.
- relampago 12y agoOnly way to stop that is for the consumer to not allow it to happen.
- rollthehard6 12y agoIn a potentially related story, BBC News reports a 300% increase in 10 years of younger prople being admitted with Crohn's Disease. Got it at 38 myself and, like others I suspect my exposure to large doses of antiobiotics may have contributed (For adult acne in my case - it's thought antibiotics deplete bacteria in the digestive tract which can lead to IBD following an infection, mine kicked off after food poisoning) http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/27810066 http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/27810066
- jp555 12y agoYou could just as likely be looking at it backwards. Could it just be a 300% increase due to 1000% increase in testing? It's not really surprising; our brains are profoundly good at finding patterns, even when there are none.
- rollthehard6 12y agoIt's quite possible IBD is just better diagnosed and patients are more aware of it yes. Myself I've been on Low Dose Naltrexone, more accurately, a low dose of Naltreone for 4 years and am asymptomatic, though I still have mildly active disease. The whole topic of OGF/Met-enkephalin is a fascinating one. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Met-enkephalin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Met-enkephalin And I agree, yes, there are many factors that contribute to auto-immune disease development both genetic and environmental.
- junto 12y agoCurious. I have a related disease (Ulcerative Colitis) and I believe that the straw that broke the camel's back for me was also a course of antibiotics. I got ill also about the same age as you. In retrospect, the initial "change" for me came years beforehand after a case of severe food poisoning. After that I struggled with certain foods; seafood for example made me instantly ill, whereas previous to the food poisoning incident I could handle almost any kind of food without issue. I have recently seen an improvement in my UC after being prescribed with large doses of Vitamin D. I was suffering badly from exhaustion and fatigue, related to the side effects of UC and the medication I have to take against it. In combination with lots of foods that help with the intestinal flora, such as yogurts and pro-biotics (Yakult) I'm feeling much more healthy. I don't think that one single thing causes these kinds of illnesses. I think it is a combination of factors that come together in a perfect storm. Genetics, stress, tiredness, diet and then damage to the intestinal flora (processed food / antibiotics) I think are all factors.
- ugk 12y agoGreat idea until people start going hungry.
- pmr_ 12y agoApparently those measures have not had an negative effect on productivity in the Netherlands, so I do not see where you are coming from. And you are also forgetting that this is done to prevent the spread of life-threatening diseases for which we do not have a working treatment yet and the emergence of new diseases of that kind. Those are hard problems. Hunger in the first world is not (we already overproduce any kind of food) and even if meat would become scarce we could just use a fraction of the resources which are now used to raise livestock to feed ourselves.