3 ms·
I don't know about Joomla but Wordpress and Drupal are hardly falling out of favor; they're actually both growing quite rapidly. Developing a custom CMS makes
by snowwrestler 12y ago
I don't know about Joomla but Wordpress and Drupal are hardly falling out of favor; they're actually both growing quite rapidly.
Developing a custom CMS makes sense for exactly one type of company: a publisher whose entire business depends on their CMS. For companies in that situation, developing a custom CMS is a capital investment in their core product.
Everyone else will save time, money, and security headaches by building on a popular open source platform. Heck even Twitter uses Drupal to power their developer site.
- BrandonSmith 12y agoIronically, I've heard the argument that, for the malleable website case, most people will save time, money, and security headaches by avoiding the traditional CMS. My point is that the traditional CMS is falling out of favor as the default solution for content on the Web. Need a blog? Wordpress is increasingly NOT the solution. As developers, we are trending away from the one-size-fits-all CMS and into specialized categories of CMS. The CMS renaissance is due to two factors: 1) A proliferation of great tools emerging into a toolchain ecosystems. Node's Grunt and Gulp are fine examples. This is largely different than the traditional CMS because... 2) Developers are increasingly wanting to gain more control over our craft.
- gexla 12y agoNo way, building a custom CMS for a site which would have always been a good candidate for an off-the-shelf CMS is just as bad of an idea today as it ever has been. > As developers, we are trending away from the one-size-fits-all CMS and into specialized categories of CMS. Most of the sites which would typically get built on Drupal (and especially Wordpress) aren't owned by developers. Further, these owners probably don't even have a developer on staff or even on a maintenance retainer. Many of these sites are setup by relatively non-technical users. Many of these sites are setup by a developer the owner has paid and then that developer is out of the picture to be run by the owner. Even if you are a start-up building your own web app, it still often doesn't make sense to build your own blogging system. Rather, you would get your first version out the door ASAP, throw your blog up on a sub-domain running Wordpress and then maybe down the road figure out something different. Do what you want for your own site. But when you are doing something for clients who don't have a tech staff, it's not about what the developer wants.
- BrandonSmith 12y agoI agree that building a custom CMS is not the right answer in most circumstances. I'm not advocating building custom CMS. My position is that what has "always been a good candidate for an off-the-shelf CMS" is evolving. The traditional CMS will be losing ground at the high and low ends. On the high-end, long-form content organizations striving to differentiate are building their own systems focused on collaboration and content lifecycle features and, on the low-end, static site generators for custom websites. There is a middle, but the middle, over time, appears to be shrinking.
- knieveltech 12y agoNone of the metrics I've seen outside of Acquia marketing materials suggest Drupal is growing. Developer engagement plateaued a couple years ago if Google keyword searches and module issue queues are anything to go by. The number of purely Drupal dev shops have plummeted over the last few years. Job postings (locally and elsewhere) appear to be limited to well-established large enterprise and .edu, and regional shops that service these markets. Wordpress, on the other hand, appears to be on fire.
- snowwrestler 12y agoDrupal and Wordpress are growing in different ways. Drupal is growing into more complex, higher-cost-per-project jobs that would have gone to big ticket closed source CMS platforms a few years ago. And Wordpress is growing into the mid-size jobs that Drupal and Joomla used to be the only option for. By any metric of public popularity, Wordpress is growing a lot faster than Drupal. Drupal's growth is into the enterprise arena which is not as public. The number of purely Drupal shops is dropping because pretty much every agency of note had added Drupal to their stable of solutions. It's not an esoteric differentiator anymore--which is actually a form of growth for the platform.
- dreamfactory2 12y agoThe number of Drupal core contributors has shot up from the hundreds to the thousands over the past couple of years