33 ms·
This technology is not interesting to me. The efficiency is too low, the coils are too big, the distances are too short, and too much alignment is required. T
by modeless 17y ago
This technology is not interesting to me. The efficiency is too low, the coils are too big, the distances are too short, and too much alignment is required. The talk of replacing batteries is just hype.
But the real reason I'm not excited is I don't believe this technology is going to improve much. People look at this and think that it's just like computers, so in 10 years these things will be 10 times smaller with 10 times the range. That's simply not true; there's no Moore's law for wireless power. We've known how to do this for over 100 years and the basic physics aren't changing. In 10 years the coils will still be that big, with the same range and the same alignment issues.
Batteries, on the other hand, have plenty of room to improve. In 10 years batteries will definitely be storing more energy with less mass at lower cost with faster charging and longer lifetimes. That's a technology I can get excited about.
- Locke1689 17y agoI can't tell you how happy I am that this didn't descend into a Nikola Tesla circle-jerk as it always does on reddit. I've tried to make your points before but it seems that many people on reddit can't accept that while Tesla may have been misunderstood in his time, we have come very far in our understanding of physics and, despite claims to the contrary, have produced at least a couple very bright and creative electrical engineers in the past 100 years.
- JacobAldridge 17y agothere's no Moore's law for wireless power. This is so true of many industries, but we are easily blinded by so much rapid change that we assume it must be possible always and everywhere. I have no credibility to agree or disagree with the case in point, I just think it's an excellent point one to make.
- schammy 17y agoWhat, do you work for Duracell or something? :P
- dejb 17y agoI can see what you are saying in terms of the fundamental forces. However I wonder if it is possible to dynamically 'focus' the power. That would make things possible with microprocessors that would have been too tedious to perform manually. Even then it isn't that great if you need to install some massive device.
- ankeshk 17y agoThere is no Moore's law for the DNA sequencing either. But yet, DNA sequencing saw an exponential growth as time went on. I read somewhere (forgot the source) that 20% of the genome sequencing was done in the first 10 years. 80% was done in the next 5 years. HIV took 15 years to be sequenced. SARS took 31 days. So - even though Moore's law isn't valid, no industry stays stagnant. Exponential optimization will occur - even with wireless electricity. At least with the size and the range issues. The alignment issues - I don't know how they'll deal with that.
- jacquesm 17y agoI disagree with you. Moores law applies to DNA sequencing very much because it is subject to the same kind of improvements that have benefited the semiconductor industry to date. Some of these benefits are direct (such as analyzers on a chip), some of them are indirect (such as using more powerful computers to do the analysis faster).
- sp332 17y agoWireless doesn't necessarily mean remote. There are already power mats that charge a cell phone that's resting on it, without having to plug in the phone. I've even seen a prototype kitchen counter with a wireless blender - just set the blender on the counter and it gets power.
- stcredzero 17y agoCountertops and appliances with this technology would be genuinely useful. Wires and plugs are only a hinderance on a kitchen countertop. I can see this introduced as a high-end luxury, then have it filter down into the mainstream. Tables and other furniture with this tech would be great. Step in the door and set your smartphone down on the stand, and it charges. Desks would be awesome. Laptop stands would be great too.
- biohacker42 17y agoIn that scenario wouldn't induction heating ovens qualify as remote transmissions of power?
- allenp 17y agoWhile this might be true for larger everyday objects, I think there are some real advantages in extremely small scale technologies that may not even be able to carry a battery.