4 ms·
I don't disagree that the F-35 is poor in every respect (read up on the South Korean procurement vs the F-18), but I am a little puzzled at one part of the vide
by protomyth 12y ago
I don't disagree that the F-35 is poor in every respect (read up on the South Korean procurement vs the F-18), but I am a little puzzled at one part of the video. Is there an actual source that current stealth is easily beatable by long wave radar? I acknowledge the expertise of Pierre Sprey, but I have my doubts on how easy it is to beat.
- greedo 12y agoLong wave radar can reportedly "see" some stealth aircraft. But there's a big gap between being able to detect an aircraft, and being able to target it with a missile to destroy the aircraft.
- stcredzero 12y agoWasn't there a shoot-down of an F-117 over the Balkans enabled by long wave radar?
- greedo 12y agoThe reports I've read seem to indicate that the F-117 used the same ingress and egress routes, it was flying in daylight, and that it was shot down by an SA6 operating in electro-optical mode. Not very good mission planning.
- stcredzero 12y agoGood information! Links?
- nisa 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zolt%C3%A1n_Dani https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zolt%C3%A1n_Dani
- neurotech1 12y agoIt was at night. Poor planning was definitely a factor.
- greedo 12y agoTeach me to post based on my memory. Not only was it at night, but an SA-3 not an SA-6.
- hga 12y agoSimilar sorts of "not very good mission planning" occurred at the beginning of Linebacker II (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Linebacker_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Linebacker_II Nixon bombing Hanoi etc.). It was initially run from SAC HQ in Omaha.... I wouldn't be surprised by equivalent micromanagement a few decades later, and the North Vietnamese also achieved some B-52 hits with salvo techniques.
- Timmmmbob 12y agoYeah it actually makes sense from a physics point of view. All the fancy reflective angles on the stealth plane won't do anything if the wave is longer than they are. "Small" things all look the same in terms of wave reflections. The radar-absorbing paint may do something (or at least it could in theory). And long-wave radars are naturally going to bigger and more inconvenient than short-wave. I've never really thought about it, but I think he might be right!
- azth 12y ago> read up on the South Korean procurement vs the F-18 Do you mean the F-15? If not, do you have any sources for this? Sounds interesting.
- protomyth 12y agoSorry, yep it was the F-15 Silent Eagle. The F-18 was Canada.
- groovylick 12y agoA quick searched turned up a popular mechanics[1] article about Russian radar and US stealth aircraft, that reinforces what Sprey said. [1] http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/military/planes-uavs/russian-made-tech-vs-americas-stealth-warplanes-13506974-2 http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/military/planes-u...
- rehevkor5 12y agoThis article talks about it: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/04/28/new-u-s-stealth-jet-can-t-hide-from-russian-radar.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/04/28/new-u-s-ste...
- discardorama 12y agoApparently, Australias JORN (Jindalee Operational Radar Network)[1], a long-wave installation, is able to detect stealth aircraft[2] (sorry, that's the best link I could find) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jindalee_Operational_Radar_Network http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jindalee_Operational_Radar_Netw... [2] http://web.archive.org/web/20071116065249/http://defence-data.com/features/fpage37.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20071116065249/http://defence-dat...
- opendais 12y agohttp://news.usni.org/2014/05/14/can-chinas-new-destroyer-find-u-s-stealth-fighters http://news.usni.org/2014/05/14/can-chinas-new-destroyer-fin... http://www.wired.com/2011/06/stealth-tech-obsolete/ http://www.wired.com/2011/06/stealth-tech-obsolete/ It is more complicated than "LOL LONG WAVE RADAR I WIN". "The other problem that the defender must contend with is the fact that the L-band and most parts of the S-band have radar resolution cells that are too large to provide a weapons quality track. Effectively, even if a defender can detect and track an attacking stealthy fighter, that defender may not be able to guide a missile onto that target. That being said, both the SPY-1 and the forthcoming Raytheon Air and Missile Defense Radar (AMDR) operate in higher frequency portions of the S-band and are able to generate weapons quality tracks. If the Chinese system is similar—and there are indications that it is—it could generate fire-control quality guidance for the HQ-9B missiles." Stealth provides some ability to evade however the most modern systems that are getting rolled out in the next 5 years are going to able to track a F-35 and engage it without significant hardship. Stealth at this point is really just another layer of defense, like decoys. It'll decrease the distance at which you can truly kill a F-35. However, at 200 million each, you can afford to build a large number of missiles & mobile SAMs to take out a F-35.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoSomething people apparently generally don't realize is that the stealth claim has only ever been about the front profile of the aircraft. Nobody is claiming the F-22 is invisible, just that it's rather hard to see from a distance if it's coming straight at you. And going straight at enemy fighters and air defense radars is the role of the F-22. Radar onboard an enemy fighter is not going to be long wave. So I don't really get Sprey's claim that stealth is a scam. The stealth claims are modest and accurate as best I can tell.
- Bluestrike2 12y agoThe biggest problem is that stealth has always been surrounded by political demands all the way back to the first stealth aircraft. Given Sprey's target audience with the interview and the way he chose his words (particularly at first), I think it's likely that he was addressing the prevailing belief that stealth aircraft are invisible aircraft. That said, you've hit the nail on the head in terms of the difference between being stealth (re: invisible, such as what Sprey's railing against) and being low-observable. Public comments about the JSF program by Lockheed, military spokespersons, and congressional supporters alike have all touted the plane's stealth capabilities to an extent that makes me wonder how many actually understand the difference between the two. Given the likelihood that operational demands (particularly close air support for the Marines with the F-35B... not that CAS missions could every be very stealthy) will make the entire point moot, I really don't understand all the emphasis on it.
- johngalt 12y agoIt's pretty widely known that stealth doesn't make radar useless. The focus is to reduce the accuracy of radar and the response time of opposition.
- hackuser 12y ago> Is there an actual source that current stealth is easily beatable by long wave radar? Like any security measure (think of IT security), there are counter-measures. The value of security is that it raises the cost of defeating you.
- xenophonf 12y agoI had the same question and found the following after a short search: http://aircraft.wikia.com/wiki/Counter_Stealth_Radar http://aircraft.wikia.com/wiki/Counter_Stealth_Radar