11 ms·
When you need the absolute best for something, you need to specialize. That's why there have historically been so many different kinds of aircraft, each with re
by bane 12y ago
When you need the absolute best for something, you need to specialize. That's why there have historically been so many different kinds of aircraft, each with relatively discrete missions.
The F-35 is a terrible aircraft, and the procurement is deeply suspect. The South Korean acquisition process leaked some surprising information about the acquisition process and the F-35 failed the relatively modest criteria the Koreans had set and an older aircraft (F-15) to be purchased. At the time there was loads of news about the F-35 failing the acquisition and it even made it into Aviation week. Doing a google search now, it looks like it was a smooth process from RFP to acquisition and I can't find many of the older articles [1]
The rumor is that Lockheed bribed the hell out of the Korean National Assembly and "won" the initial round of acquisition, but the agency in Korea responsible for the acquisition (DAPA) saw right through it and awarded the final contract to Boeing.
The National Assembly got upset, Lockheed got upset and probably some U.S. congressmen got upset and the entire acquisition was tossed out "recompeted" and of course the F-35 won the second time. It's a sad joke and I can't even begin to guess at the acquisition shenanigans that happened in the U.S.
1 - http://www.defensenews.com/article/20130928/DEFREG/309280008/F-35-Back-S-Korea-Fighter-Contest http://www.defensenews.com/article/20130928/DEFREG/309280008...
edit a great movie about this is the movie "Pentagon Wars" which includes this great scene.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA
- noir_lord 12y agoThe F35 is a dog and I suspect as a Brit we are going to get stuck with the thing when everyone else pulls out.
- XorNot 12y agoNo don't worry. Australia is cutting every single welfare, education and science funding program but by golly are we going to buy us some F-35s so Tony Abbott can have more photo ops in them!
- noir_lord 12y agoConsidering how lethal that thing is to it's own side that might be a good thing, $200 million dollars to get rid of Abbott sounds like a reasonable RoI (this is a joke, I don't want the man to die in a horrible fireball...merely to go away).
- lafar6502 12y agoI don't think your lousy explanation will fool anyone. The alarm bells in these concrete buildings are already ringing
- arethuza 12y agoIt is rather reminiscent of the Skybolt affair from the 1960s: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAM-87_Skybolt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAM-87_Skybolt Edit: Even more like the fantastic idea to cancel the wonderful TSR-2 in favour of the F-111 - a decision which was then cancelled later on: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2 ""All modern aircraft have four dimensions: span, length, height and politics. TSR-2 simply got the first three right."
- noir_lord 12y agoAlso the Black Arrow http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Arrow http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Arrow Still the only sovereign nation to give up satellite launching capability after acquiring it... "Prior to the cancellation of Black Arrow, NASA had offered to launch British payloads for free; however, this offer was withdrawn following the decision to cancel Black Arrow." Always liked that little bit of history :).
- hga 12y agoIronically, the F-111 was the only model/mission of the TFX development effort to survive. The TFX was the '60s version of the F-35, except it also tried for the air superiority role the F-22 now fills. Nominal peacetime is when the bureaucrats try to save money with a single weapon system that "can do everything" ... but it seldom does more than one thing well. The M14 rifle is another '50s example.
- arethuza 12y agoAnd meanwhile a few miles up the road from here the UK is building huge aircraft carriers (at least by UK standards) specifically to carry the F35.
- stcredzero 12y agoNominal peacetime is when the bureaucrats try to save money with a single weapon system that can do everything ... but it seldom does more than one thing well. Clueless German higher-ups were asking that every aircraft also be able to dive-bomb, causing design compromises and delays. Yes, they even did that with their revolutionary jet aircraft! (The fighter and the high speed bomber!)
- Pxtl 12y agoDon't worry, as long as the Conservatives have control here in Canada, we'll be stuck right alongside you.
- dwd 12y agoIs Garth Turner likely to get back into parliament?
- personZ 12y agoThe Liberals are actually the ones who got us into the JSF program. Every opposition government ever opposes whatever large military procurement is proposed: It's easy to find negatives, and there is no real downside to be negative. Occasionally the rhetoric can get so over the top that it needs action (see the Liberals cancelling the EH-101, and then having to effective re-order it at a much higher price tag for less hardware), but generally it just quietly continues. And the overwhelming reason Canada wants the F-35 has little to do with the aircraft, and everything to do with manufacturing partnership agreements that would see many billions of that order going to facilities in Canada, invigorating the aerospace industry. Not saying it's a good purchase, because it isn't, but I wouldn't pin it on the Conservatives.
- rst 12y agoYou think the US won't buy them? Our military bought and paid for hundreds of F-111s, the last plane we designed to do everything for everyone, with the result that it wasn't useful anyplace. (Yes, we've tried this trick before.) And that was in the 1960s and '70s; if anything, the military procurement process has gotten a whole lot more corrupt.
- dwd 12y agoAustralia is replacing its retired F-111 fleet with the F-35 so we may end up sole user in end...again. The F-111 at least had use in a long-range anti-shipping role once it was upgraded for the Harpoon.
- andrewkreid 12y agoBeing cynical here, but maybe we have to consider whether alienating the US military-industrial complex (and their coterie of owned congresspersons) by purchasing a non-US warplane would be _worse_ for Australia's long-term security than sucking it up and overspending on the F-35.
- justatdotin 12y agoI certainly believe we'd be far more secure, with greater chances of a peaceful future, if Australia determined we needed an independent strategy, without USA war bases and without tagging along to whatever big dumb war the emperor might dream up next. Our own analysts say there is no credible threat; we're not at war now; so why aid the military empire in their unnecessary and unhelpful expansion in our region?
- gaius 12y agoAustralia's defence needs are the same as the UKs - you must absolutely be able to secure your shipping lanes, first and foremost. Anything else is the icing on the cake. This is something the UK has lost sight of. We need SSNs and destroyers, not white elephant aircraft carriers. And certainly not Eurofighters or F35s.
- fafner 12y agoI think you Brits are stuck with the F-35 because of the new carriers. Both are designed for VTOL aircraft. There were plans to build at least the second one with a CATOBAR configuration. But this was turned down due to the high costs. So if the F-35 fails the two new carriers wouldn't have any fixed wing aircraft and require expensive changes. (Not a weapons expert by any means. So please correct me if I'm wrong)
- rbanffy 12y agoIt should be possible to update the harriers. While they are as un-stealth as a plane can be, they still could still be a viable option.
- at-fates-hands 12y agoI remember reading something along the lines that several models were being discontinued (the first ones that come to mind are the A-10 and the F117) in favor of this plane since it was going to be able to do everything. However, he loses a lot of respectability when he says that stealth is a scam. All you have to do is ask the multitude of the F117 pilots who flew over Baghdad during the invasion, if stealth technology helped them avoid Iraqi radar.
- rst 12y agoHis claim is that stealth only works against radars in a particular frequency band, and that long-wave radars designed to defeat it can do so easily. Saddam Hussein didn't have those; the point is that the F-35's adversaries (anyone with an air defense system designed after the F-117 went public) likely do.
- tomwhipple 12y agoLong wave radars are fine for early warning. (e.g. HEY! There's some thing out there!) But they can't help you figure out where it is exactly. (e.g. guide an anti-aircraft missile to intercept).
- sharpneli 12y agoDisclaimer: I think the F-35 is total scam. But this is about stealth You can also reduce your effective cross section to long-wave radars by splitting the hull into non electrically connected areas. If there is no electrical contact there is no resonance effect for that particular frequency. Who knows, maybe some aircraft eventually will use it. Stealth as a generic concept is not ruined by long wave radars, the current designs might be. It's traditional arms race.
- msandford 12y agoYou've just fallen prey to a logical fallacy. Just because SOME radars cannot detect stealth aircraft it does not immediately follow that NO radars can detect stealth aircraft. http://aviationweek.com/defense/commentary-do-russian-radar-developments-challenge-stealth http://aviationweek.com/defense/commentary-do-russian-radar-... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_aircraft#Limitations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_aircraft#Limitations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bistatic_radar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bistatic_radar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multistatic_radar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multistatic_radar Provided that you're willing to invest a minute or so (I spent 5 min finding links) you can discover that in fact he does know what he's talking about. This is established science and not at all contentious.
- javert 12y agoThat clip from Pentagon Wars is amazing. Having seen it, is there still any reason to see the movie? Or is that the gist of it? Because from looking at Wikipedia, that looks like the gist of it.
- bithive123 12y agoAbsolutely; this montage captures the essence of the plot, but watching it unfold is still quite entertaining. Edit: The clip is really more of a flashback -- the rest of the film deals with the young officer trying to ensure the vehicle receives a live fire test.
- Ygg2 12y agoYou'll miss the goats, the burning mannequins, rockets being thrown of a lift onto a crane on a tank, the toaster bolted onto a tank and the grand finale. Also you'll miss the fact that everyone except the guy that said what would happen got promoted and he retired prematurely.
- Ygg2 12y agoLATE EDIT: It's sheeps not goats, rockets being thrown off a crane onto a tank.
- maxxxxx 12y agoThey certainly have a lot of experience with bribes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_bribery_scandals#West_Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_bribery_scandals#West_...
- notastartup 12y agoI think Japan's decision to buy F-35s triggered this as well. South Korea needs more airplanes that's capable of air to ground roles, that's able to penetrate deep into North Korea and drop bunker busters. I still don't get why they have not bothered buying bombers, it would be a strong deterrent against North Korea's backdrop of empty threats.
- willvarfar 12y agoSurely South Korea ought to by cruise missiles?
- danudey 12y ago$1.4m per strike probably isn't really cost-effective for smaller countries that aren't spending trillions on their military.
- willvarfar 12y agoActually, its way cheaper than sending a jet to fly overtop to deliver the 'bunker buster'. And you can hit as many targets as you have missiles.
- notastartup 12y agoUS doesn't want an arms race in the region so they limited South Korea to 800km range ballistic missiles with a limited payload. So they started developing the Hyunmoo series. The Hyunmoo-3c has a range of 1500km, it is domestically built unlike the previous Hyunmoo missiles which were actually old Nike missiles from 1950s. It's interesting that South Korean engineers added a slot for carrying nuclear warheads (possibly had plans to develop nuclear weapons at some point in the 1970s). Cruise missiles don't give the same power projection like a ballistic missile tipped with nuclear warhead. It can be intercepted which limits it's reach.
- willvarfar 12y agoThis doesn't gel with my understanding of the subject. NK is predominantly rocket salvo and shell artillery. This may be basic tech, but its very effective militarily. Cruise missiles are damn difficult to intercept. And for each plane with "bunker buster" dumb bombs, you can buy a salvo of very clever bunker-busting cruise missiles which don't have to bring their pilot home after.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoThe worst of it is, the F-35 is a lie. It's not one aircraft with 3 different roles. It's 3 entirely different aircraft sharing some elements. There is only 30% commonality between the different F-35 models. Also, the F-35 was sold as being worthwhile because it was cheaper and easier. In reality it has been vastly more expensive and vastly less capable than alternatives, with far more maintenance per hour spent flying than most other aircraft. If there was a hint of sanity in the USAF they'd shit-can the F-35 program and start a new round of competitive procurement for separate fighters for each role. It's worth remembering that some of the best aircraft in history have come about as responses to failed development programs. The F-14 grew out of the failed F-111B program, for example.
- mcv 12y ago> It's not one aircraft with 3 different roles. It's 3 entirely different aircraft sharing some elements. And yet each design is to some extent compromised by the needs of the other two. I totally understand that VTOL is cool, but why does a VTOL fighter have to have anything at all in common with two non-VTOL planes? Make it a separate program.
- phaus 12y ago>When you need the absolute best for something, you need to specialize. It would be interesting to hear the thoughts of the engineer in the video on the F/A-18. From what I've read about the Joint Strike Fighter project, from which the F-35 was borne, it seems like they were trying to recreate and expand upon the success and versatility of the F/A-18. I've always heard that the F/A-18 is one of the most useful planes in our arsenal, but it isn't highly specialized to one specific purpose. As far as the F-35 goes, it seems like its yet another example where America is perfectly capable of building something better* than the rest of the world has, if it weren't for all of the corrupt politicians that are willing to trade real progress for personal gain. *not that we are inherently better than everyone, its just that we poured an enormous amount of resources into this project
- Tloewald 12y agoAgreed. He was pretty down on the F15, which has proved pretty effective (if expensive). The F18 isn't VTOL, or "stealth", and isn't touted as an A10 replacement, so it's not completely insane. That said, it's hard to measure the effectiveness of most US aircraft because they've never been operated in truly competitive conditions (the best measure is of aircraft which the israeli's use, since israel has often fought russian proxies such as Syria with late model aircraft and "advisors". By that measure, the F15 and F16 are unparalelled. The israelis don't use the F18 iirc, which says something.
- Retric 12y agoThe F16 cost about 1/2 what an F15 cost. In the end the F16 allowed the F15 to be more focused which was a huge net win. The crazy thing is the close air support and bomber roles are much better suited for drone aircraft so at least one of it's missions is pure BS from the start.
- pandemicsyn 12y agoI don't think CAS stuff is well suited for drones (at least not the current stuff). You want lots of ordnance and you want the forward observer on the ground to not have to talk to someone possibly 100's of miles away right? Also, I don't know that I buy that the drone pilot has the same local/situational awareness that a pilot sitting in an A-10/Apache does.
- kalleboo 12y agoThe US also rigged the Norwegian selection of the F-35. It was was pretty much pre-decided that Norway had to go for the F35 for political reasons, even though all the committees preferred the Swedish JAS Gripen. The US gave them a great excuse by denying the export by Raytheon of an important upgrade. All this was revealed by Wikileaks. http://www.flightglobal.com/blogs/the-dewline/2010/12/wikileaks-shows-us-played-aesa/ http://www.flightglobal.com/blogs/the-dewline/2010/12/wikile... The US doesn't want it's allies to get the best equipment for their usage - they want their allies to send them money. With allies like that, who needs enemies?
- dsl 12y agoThere is not a single country that exports its latest and greatest technology. Even if an ally can be trusted with modern aircraft, often their pilots cannot be. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Cold_War_pilot_defections http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Cold_War_pilot_defectio...
- darkmighty 12y agoThis is all very old. I don't think modern top aircraft can defect so easily.
- pjc50 12y agoThere's no real means to stop them defecting, surely? All the pilot has to do is fly over the border and land, while not getting shot down by the country he's defecting to. Iran got hold of a drone. It's not quite the drone "defecting" but it's somewhat similar.
- gatehouse 12y agoThis is a high end weapon, heavily computerized, loaded with explosives ... I'm not saying there is definitely a self-destruct command, but if I were landing one in China I'd be sweating.
- ssdfsdf 12y agoThe "Pentagon Wars" scene reminds me strongly of software development in many companies I have worked for.