14 ms·
We live in the age of wonders. The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact. And at Facebook, a co
by jameshart 12y ago
We live in the age of wonders. The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact. And at Facebook, a company which can, if it chooses, pick from among the brightest engineering minds and focus their efforts on any problem it chooses, the power to concentrate years of programming knowledge on the capabilities afforded to us by this astonishing bounty of personal technology has produced:
"A new way to share photos and videos"
And they don't even seem to have a monetization strategy for it.
- cliveowen 12y agoI'm happy to see someone who shares my exact same sentiment. I mean, when I read "but there's a catch, they have to send something first" I thought it was a joke. First of all, the fact that they made another snapchat with just a little spin on it says to me that they don't really know what they're doing; they're just after money, there's no vision behind it. Secondly, with all the useful products and services they could be developing for the betterment of society, they decided it would be a good idea to sink money in yet another pics sharing app. I fear the future will be just this: a selected few engineers making toys for the entertainment of the masses living on minimum wage. Bleak times indeed.
- tothepixel 12y agoI think it's more indicative of the way applications are being used these days. Create a gimmick -> gain incredible popularity -> try to monetize your product -> users switch to the next gimmick -> create a new gimmick.
- XorNot 12y agoWhich does rather imply there's a big crash coming. That's not a zero-sum nor value-creating cycle: everyone will slowly haemorrhage users, at the risk that the next "thing" isn't something that easily centralizes to a corporation - i.e. a generation of school kids who get big into some type of mesh-networked thing which solely goes device to device. It would only have to be created once.
- thibauts 12y agoIf it's created as a platform (hear, a protocol) it may effectively need to be created only once. The whole online world is unknowingly waiting for it, and I feel it coming our way like, at raging speed.
- devindotcom 12y agoI'm with you to a point, but this objection is a close relative of the "we can put a man on the moon, but we can't ______?" argument. There are other companies, not focused from the beginning on advancing social connection in the Internet age, that are spending billions of dollars and millions of man-hours on improving the world in other ways.
- downandout 12y ago> improving the world in other ways Are you implying that Slingshot has improved the world?
- devindotcom 12y agonope
- loumf 12y ago> And they don't even seem to have a monetization strategy for it. Not yet, but mature messaging services seem to have reasonable monetization that isn't primarily display-ad-based. I understand "stickers" to be one of the main ones.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- downandout 12y agoLike others that have responded to this, I agree with you on principle. However, this kind of "innovation" is what they need to serve the simplistic minds that form the core user base of Facebook. New ways to share photos and videos are exactly what the kinds of people that use Facebook want from Facebook - nothing more, nothing less. Quite simply, Zuckerberg knows his audience. Remember, these are people that vote for President of the United States based upon what their favorite rapper says about the candidates in 140 characters on Twitter. In that context, a new sharing app is revolutionary.
- ed209 12y agoDid you know there are over 150 varieties of Finches? Each slightly different, maybe color difference or a larger beak or bigger wingspan. They came about by iterating on the Finches that came before. In fact, that's how most advancements come about in nature, poetry, art, and yes, even technology. We take what came before an iterate on it. I'm trying to think of a giant leap that came out of nowhere, but I can't. Photos and videos are important to me. Really important. It's how I see my family 1000's of miles away or my daughter 5 miles away when I'm at work. And just like in nature, either this iteration will thrive or die out eventually.
- jameshart 12y agoI like this analogy. Silicon valley generates random mutations of existing ideas, without thought or direction, and occasionally lands, by pure chance, on something slightly better, which survives at the expense of other inferior mutations. I guess that maybe the developers working on "a new way to share photos and video" kid themselves that they're making something different; something that really is revolutionary. But no, what they're really doing is tweaking the shape of a beak thinking it'll make a better finch. So I do kind of have to ask: is making random tweaks to the genome of the photo sharing application in the hope they'll be successful really the best use of the talents of all those developers?
- general_failure 12y agoI think this is basically what scott adams pivot article said.
- tomphoolery 12y ago> So I do kind of have to ask: is making random tweaks to the genome of the photo sharing application in the hope they'll be successful really the best use of the talents of all those developers? These developers CHOOSE to work at Facebook. If they don't feel as though re-inventing the slide show would be the best use of their time, there are thousands of companies which do cooler stuff that would GLADLY have them. Maybe the people who work for Facebook aren't as smart as you think they are. Actually, what's far more likely is that MAYBE JUST MAYBE not every one of the tens of thousands of people working at Facebook is a genius...
- state 12y agoThe monetization strategy is to pump ads in to it.
- nakedrobot2 12y agoSo don't work for Facebook. Build something that matters, or work for someone who is. Simple as that.
- interg12 12y agoYou don't think they're building things that matter? have you seen their app install ad network?
- edmack 12y agoPeople want to spend lots of time sharing photos of themselves and cats. Blame humans not Facebook.
- resu_nimda 12y agoExactly. The parent of your comment says "The internet and mobile devices create endless possibilities for people to communicate, learn and interact." How are people going to communicate and interact? Probably by sending text, images, and videos to each other...I'd love to hear some proposals for alternatives but I'm kind of tired of the "cat photo sharing" pejorative, because that's what people want, that's how they connect with each other, and if you can actually come up with a better idea you'll be very wealthy.
- mcfunley 12y agoSharing photos and videos is an activity that brings meaning to billions of lives, and it's not unreasonable to try to improve upon it. Facebook is a large company with a number of revenue streams. Every single feature they undertake does not need to individually earn its keep. (And I'm not sure why that aspect would concern you in any case.)
- unclebucknasty 12y ago>Sharing photos and videos is an activity that brings meaning to billions of lives, and it's not unreasonable to try to improve upon it. On the other hand, the "meaning" that people derive from sharing can be defined in some basic terms (e.g. interaction, connection, etc.). At what point does the incremental "improvement" in sharing mechanics no longer justify the resources required to produce that improvement? First, we share it. Then, we share it and it disappears. Next, we can't see what's shared until we share something back. Is this really improving on the basic "meaning"? Sure, Facebook gets to decide how their resources are applied. But, I don't think we should pretend that there's some great and noble effort to bring still more meaning to billions of lives. Facebook wants a novel way to keep you on Facebook where you can bring more meaning to their bottom line. Period. And, you know what else has meaning? Talking to people. Having lunch with people. Seeing people; not watching their latest "broadcast", but actually seeing them. I'm just over it, and I'm guessing others are as well. There's just this constant, vapid, soul-sucking effort to endlessly distract people with some novel piece of nothingness as a means of generating still more revenue. Gets a little old.
- npizzolato 12y agoIt's these comments that get a little old. Yes, obviously Facebook wants to make more money, and they do that by selling your information to advertisers. Thanks for the reminder. At the same time, I don't think it's a stretch to say that Facebook has enriched the lives of millions of people. I know it has allowed me to stay in touch with family and friends who I otherwise would probably speak to more rarely. That's meaningful to me. I'm also tired of the "why don't you go out and have a REAL conversation" comments. I would love to have lunch with the friends I keep in touch with primarily on Facebook. Unfortunately, they live halfway across the country, so it's not that easy. Just because the interactions happen online doesn't mean they're not real or meaningful. The fact that your comment on an online forum suggests otherwise is particularly rich.
- greggarious 12y agoIt's you. You are the monetization strategy.
- discardorama 12y ago> And they don't even seem to have a monetization strategy for it. They'll collect the location information, your circle of friends, etc. and enrich your profile (what they know about you). That helps them monetize better. FB is an ad network, basically (or will become one). They have data on ~1B users, and the value of this data goes up with the amount of interaction there is between users. Outside of Search, ads monetize pretty badly (what are Display ad CPMs now.. $0.50? ). That's because of extremely low engagement. The more data FB has about you, the more engaging ad it can pick for you; and thus they can charge a lot more. So this product by itself doesn't have to monetize at all, as long as the net effect of this product is higher value for FB.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zupa-hu 12y agowhile I have to agree, still, it has a psychological experiment side which is quite interesting. You don't see the picture, you have to be active to reveal it. Will this pull you into being active? So, it might as well be the virus being tested, not the photo-sharing-app that is infected.
- aye 12y agoThis is more about about promoting sharing as a cultural behavior than making money on this particular product. By incentivizing sharing, companies end up with more personal information. It forces lurkers to participate (some might argue that's a good thing). The service forces you to pay for content with your own content, whereas before the payment was implicit, or at least invisible -- as long as you were in the store, you consented to being monitored.
- gavinpc 12y ago> It forces lurkers to participate This line of iambic pentameter is the first one that gets to the point of the OP.
- encoderer 12y agoYes. As it turns out, people really like other people.
- unclebucknasty 12y ago>the capabilities afforded to us by this astonishing bounty of personal technology has produced: "A new way to share photos and videos" Where's the double upvote link? And, it's not just the waste of resources/developer talent. It's also the complete dumbing down of everyone consuming this stuff. If this "succeeds", then we now have yet another novel way to waste our precious time replacing real relationships with superficial interactions, and otherwise doing very little of actual consequence. We are iterating on superficiality, distraction, and nothingness. I suppose one fine day, we'll perfect it.
- throwaway_2084 12y agocynical piece of shit. you don't understand how innovation works. the world is full of people like you and it is quite sad. more sad to see this as the top comment on hn
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fuire8 12y ago"We live in the age of wonders" is that so ?
- fuire8 12y ago"We live in the age of wonders" is that so ?