2 ms·
But to say that Rimuhosting broke into their own machine is ridiculous. I'm not sure about that. Since the VM is virtual, you could say that they don't own th
by mbreese 17y ago
But to say that Rimuhosting broke into their own machine is ridiculous.
I'm not sure about that. Since the VM is virtual, you could say that they don't own the VM, they own the machine the VM runs on. They can control and manipulate the VM via the container for running them (Xen in this case). But since the VM doesn't physically exist, it could be argued that they don't actually own it, they only rent server capacity to run the VM.
Now, I know that you could similarly argue that they were only reading/modifying a disk image that existed on their server, but that isn't as much fun to argue.
I think that everyone here can agree that this was a dumb move by Rimuhosting. And I'm not sure what the contractual arrangement is when you buy a VPS from them... but what they have posted online doesn't make this very clear.
The question of ownership is interesting in this era of cloud computing (and not at all clear). I think it's clear that they own the bare metal. I think it's also clear that you own your data. However, where those mix is an interesting question. At what point is their (uninvited) intervention in a customer's VM warranted outside of their normal management options in the VM container (Xen)? At what point is the intervention too much?
Does the company matter? I can imagine everyone being up in arms if Amazon tried the same thing with an EC2 instance.
Of course this could all be alleviated by using a dedicated server... but even then, if the hosting company owns the hardware, would it be okay for them to pull a hard drive, and add themselves as root? Never. Ever. But this is effectively what we're talking about. The only difference is that with a dedicated server your actions don't affect others. In a VPS environment, your actions can affect others. But I think that there are far better methods for controlling this than "breaking in" to a customer's VM.