4 ms·
What you're describing is QoS. Packet discrimination by kind. Bulk file transfer vs streaming video vs VoIP. Necessary because because the impact if your torren
by Karunamon 12y ago
What you're describing is QoS. Packet discrimination by kind. Bulk file transfer vs streaming video vs VoIP. Necessary because because the impact if your torrent downloads go a bit slow is your torrent downloads a bit slow. If video or VoIP get congested, the effect is the service becomes unusable.
Net Neutrality is about packet discrimination by source and destination.
It's not a problem if VoIP gets higher priority over web surfing and arbitrary file downloads. It's a huge problem if the ISP's VoIP service has higher priority than Skype, despite them being identical traffic.
- bitJericho 12y agoExcept how does one tell the difference between Skype and Voip? You don't without deep level packet inspection. Simple QoS based on port could easily piss off a customer, for example, if they want Skype traffic on port 80. The simplest way to deal with this is to treat all traffic equally but serve the bandwidth that you promise your customers.
- danielweber 12y agoThe customer's network should take that responsibility and pay accordingly. [ ] Whatever, normal traffic. [ ] Let this traffic be throttled at will (downloading latest Linux distro) [ ] I need low-latency or else throw it away (VoIP) [ ] I'd like low latency, but still do packets in order (SSH session) [ ] Please give me a channel of X quality for the next 2 hours, or don't provide it to me at all (Netflix)
- Karunamon 12y agoExactly. It's information that has to be provided in the IP header. A great description is here: http://packetpushers.net/how-does-qos-work/ http://packetpushers.net/how-does-qos-work/ If that information isn't there, then the packets are treated as "best effort" (or at least, they should be in a sane world).
- wmf 12y agoThe tricky part is how to handle incoming packets. Since you didn't send them you can't mark them.
- bitJericho 12y agoWTF? It's none of the ISPs business what I use their network for. If they don't like me using all the bandwidth up, they should either charge more or instill data caps.
- danielweber 12y agoNet Neutrality is about packet discrimination by source and destination. Net Neutrality seems to be a No True Scotsman where if you ask 10 people on HN what it really means, you get a dozen different answers. There are some kinds of NN I support, and some I don't. I would sign up for the definition in your comment.
- bitJericho 12y agoIt's not really confusing unless you ask the ISPs. NN is all about treating all traffic equally. No QoS on the ISP level.
- danielweber 12y agoThank you for the demonstration of "what NN really is".
- Karunamon 12y agoISP QoS is fine as long as it's by type and not by source/destination. It's perfectly reasonable to expect all those people torrenting the latest Game of Thrones shouldn't impact other people's Skype calls. This isn't a value judgement on anything, mind, it's all about what the application needs in order to work. A torrent can still download on a congested network. A VoIP call will have great difficulty on same.
- bitJericho 12y agoIf the ISP can't pipe the advertised bandwidth that's not the user's fault. The torrenter's absolutely should be allowed to fill up the pipes. As for torrenting, there's also a uTP which is supposed to help mitigate some issues at the ISP level. That all said, if you don't agree that QoS should not be allowed at the ISP level than you don't agree with NN. It's really not complicated.
- Karunamon 12y agoAdvertised bandwidth is always an "up to" number, not a dedicated pipe. If you want that, you want business class service at a significant price premium. >The torrenter's absolutely should be allowed to fill up the pipes. And the Skypers should absolutely be allowed to have their calls. QoS ensures that everyone has a minimum usable level of service. QoS and net neutrality are two different things, as previously mentioned. If you'd like to argue otherwise, you'll have to do better than simply gain-say my definition.