6 ms·
Oh wow. Minecraft. I have an 8yo boy, so I spend a lot more time thinking about this than I would like. I think Mojang has it's priorities slightly wrong here.
by nl 12y ago
Oh wow. Minecraft. I have an 8yo boy, so I spend a lot more time thinking about this than I would like.
I think Mojang has it's priorities slightly wrong here. At the moment much of the interesting stuff in Minecraft is done via mods. But the user experience for that is pretty close to pre-Google search: browse through random forums to find links to dodgy download sites that attempt to push malware or porn to you.
Then when you find a working download, you have to install. Inevitably that means clashes with existing mods, and hours trying different versions of things that some random person on a forum claims work.
FFS, I'm a Java programmer, and I can't work out how to make this shit work most of the time.
In my view Mojang should do the following:
Build a working, stable official Mod API, which at least attempts to make it possible to determine if different mods will work together
Implement an in-game app store, and let mod authors sell their mods.
I'd much prefer to spend a dollar on a new mod rather than the horrible, horrible experience it is now.
Rant over..
- arrrg 12y agoHuh? Again, this is the misconception that game developers can only ever do one thing at a time. True for one or two person developers, not true for Mojang. They can afford lawyers. Developers will have nothing to do with the implementation of this policy. They are working on the modding API, just as before. Also, this was triggered from the outside. Someone asked for clarification on the policy, Mojang looked over all the feedback and came back with this response. It’s purely reactive, not an initiative. You are talking nonsense. Plausible sounding nonsense, but still nonsense.
- nl 12y agoIt's good that they are (allegedly) working on a plugin API[1]. That is necessary but insufficient to fix the problems I outlined. Additionally, the plugin API is clearly a low priority: it was supposed to be released in 2010, then spoken about in 2012, and now the website and github page have been taken down (according to [1]). At the practical level "working on it for over 4 years with signs it might not be shipped" and "it doesn't exist" are pretty close to the same thing. But hopefully my pessimism in this is misplaced and it ships. I haven't heard anything about Mojang implementing an app store model. Unless I've missed something it seems to me you are talking past me, since that was basically the whole thrust of my comment. I didn't say anything at all about their statement - my post was an offtopic rant about other problems in the Mincraft ecosystem. Specific to the statement, I think it sounds good but shows misguided priorities: keep it cheap rather than fix problems. If you could point out specifically which parts of my post you believe are nonsense that might be useful. [1] http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Plugin_API http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Plugin_API
- Lrigikithumer 12y agoWhat does a mod API have to do with the monetisation of servers? Not saying you're incorrect but it doesn't really seem relevant to the story posted.
- baldfat 12y agothe server is modded and you don't have to install a mod client side.
- nl 12y agoOh, it's mostly just a rant! But I think Mojang's focus on keeping things cheap (whether it be with the problems monetisation servers - especially now with competition from Minecraft Realms - or the lack of an official way to download and install mods) shows a slight misalignment of priorities. They should be trying to make playing Minecraft as enjoyable as possible, not as cheap as possible.
- grrowl 12y agoI think the common theme is Minecraft's ecosystem. Mojang addresses a problem (EULA-breaking monetization within the ecosystem) by changing the rules to address the problem. What they should do is circumvent the immediate problem by redefining the ecosystem itself. Furnishing developers with a stable, predictable API redefines the ecosystem, and creating an "app store" for mods (et cetera...) could finance it, with ongoing revenue. With Mojang's current attitude I see it being more of a "google play", especially given the ease that mods could be repackaged. Still, better than having kids pull executable code off forums.
- touristtam 12y agoTry the resident-rise mod pack (or the yogcast one, based on it) on ATLauncher ( official website for the launcher: http://www.atlauncher.com/ http://www.atlauncher.com/)
- nl 12y agoYeah, ATLauncher is about the best thing around, since it lets you roll back to a working state. But really this could work so much better if Mojang implemented it.
- baldfat 12y agoModding API - (Community worked) There was work done since Alpha to implement this called "Plugin API." It had a github page and was eventually abandoned.
- altcognito 12y ago> FFS, I'm a Java programmer, and I can't work out how to make this shit work most of the time. One of the first instructions on how to make a mod was -- first, download this decompiler. Wat?
- elfcard 12y agoI'd much rather people pay for stability. Tricking people to pay for 64 bytes of code and a new color pallet for a diamond encrusted pixel sword in order to offer stability was a mistake. Education needed to happen, this shit is hard, and it's a lot of work. When I go to a store, I don't see a sign "Pizza is free" only to walk over and find that if I want to put toppings on the pizza, well those cost $0.99 per single slice of pepperoni on the pizza. In order to get a full pizza experience, including peppers, cheese, and sauce, I'm not paying $30 for the free pizza. It's dishonest, and we're the ones allowing it to happen.
- nl 12y agoI'm not sure I understand you. Firstly, Pay-to-play (which I think you are talking about?) isn't the same as an app store for mods. I'm not sure if you play Minecraft, but there is a very diverse range of mods available, of differing qualities and all hosted on malware infested download sites. That's a real problem that deserves to be looked at. I'd never advocate that core features of Minecraft be made pay-to-play. Instead, I'm advocating exactly the same model as we see in Android or iOS: the core system is free, and there is a simple way to get extra features onto it. Some of those maybe free, and some may not. Secondly, the number of bytes doesn't determine the value of anything. Thirdly, "It's dishonest, and we're the ones allowing it to happen" - who, specifically is the "we" you speak of here? I'm not doing anything to allow it to happen. (I'm not specifically doing anything to stop it, either: I'm simply not involved. I'm genuinely curious who you are talking about).
- elfcard 12y agoSell me a service, or a product, not a gimmick. That's what I'm saying. Im talking about IAP. The value is in scarcity, but it's artificially scarce. It's contrived. Seriously? On a forum dedicated to startups and development, many who like me do app and game development or lead app and game development teams; you can't figure out who I'm talking to? Seriously?
- nl 12y agoThe value is in scarcity, but it's artificially scarce. It's contrived. Couldn't this statement apply to gaming as a whole, too? Is it that being stopped half way through a game and forced to pay for some gizmo to keep playing is worse than having to pay up front for the whole game? Financially there may be no difference at all, right? (Not a gamer here) Seriously? On a forum dedicated to startups and development, many who like me do app and game development or lead app and game development teams; you can't figure out who I'm talking to? Seriously? HN is hardly a game focused forum. The vast majority of people on here don't have anything to do with games. It was difficult to tell if your "We" meant "game developers" in general or was somehow more specific to Minecraft mod developers (which is what I didn't understand).
- ripter 12y agoThey have been working on and off an official Mod API for a while. http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-02-29-mojang-hires-bukkit-server-mod-team-to-make-official-minecraft-api http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2012-02-29-mojang-hires-bu... But this has nothing to do with monetizing servers, which is the point of the post.
- MrZongle2 12y agoTrue, but OP is on-target here. I've got two boys who were rabid Minecraft players, and although I'm not a (current) Java developer I can confirm that the modding process is a horror. How does this relate to the monetization issue? Well, from a technical perspective Mojang seems to be phoning it in these days, in terms of Minecraft. The console and mobile versions seem to be getting regular love while the core PC version has been in near-limbo for most of 2014. The plugin API, promised for well over a year (and I suspect over two) is still nowhere to be seen. Notch, creator of the game, isn't even involved with it anymore beyond the occasional "voice from the mountain" posts such as this. While I'm sure they have some talented people touching the code (e.g. Jeb and Dinnerbone), the focus and drive appear to be missing. So when I hear about the EULA debacle and the half-assed cloud of confusion and conflicting messages coming from Mojang, I'm not surprised. I like the game, but have no idea if anybody's really steering that ship with a particular destination in mind.
- nl 12y agoInitally called the Modding API, it has been planned in some capacity since at least July 5, 2010, shortly after the release of Alpha 1.0.1_01. It was then stated to be released in Beta 1.8.[6] The Modding API was then rebranded as the Plugin API, with the release originally stated to be planned for 1.3, then for 1.4, and then it was accidentally stated by Curse that it would be implemented in 1.5, but has since been delayed...At MineCon 2012, Mojang shared their vision for the future of the plugin API....As of October 26, 2013, the Plugin API/Workbench cannot be found on its GitHub page. Furthermore, the developer website has also been taken offline[1] Draw your own conclusions. [1] http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Plugin_API http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Plugin_API
- 12y ago
- amaranth 12y agoBack in 2012 there was actually talk of them doing an app store like model to host mods/plugins when they got the API done. However, they were doing it for the opposite reason: to ensure no one was making money from the mods. The idea was without doing the crap you have to do now the only place to get mods would be from their "store" but they wouldn't charge any money. I don't know if that was ever a serious idea or if they're still going to do it but that should show how long they've been trying to avoid a microtransaction/DLC model.