40 ms·
Sherlock lives in public domain, US court rules
- seren 12y agoFortunately, the estate appeal was rejected. If adding any new (short) story can make a character "more rounded", it is basically a very cheap way to extend the copyrights ad vitam aeternam.
- vidarh 12y agoThe cynic in me things that this idea is probably the reason why Disney have been so aggressive about using their oldest characters in the last few years. E.g. Steamboat Willy in opening sequences, and the short film before Frozen. Even if they fail to extend the original copyrights, there are other potential "loopholes" to making it harder to reuse these characters: The more Disney uses variations of them, the bigger the minefield becomes in terms of sticking to the depictions that enters/have entered public domain. And they may also be going for making it harder to make any use of some of the imagery without running into trademark law as well. In this case, the author "only" had to deal with the threats and the small minefield of avoiding character aspects revealed in the last 10 Sherlock stories, and so presumably had a reasonably simple task. Perhaps the Arthur Conan Doyle estate now wishes they'd pursued a more aggressive licensing strategy aimed at creating a bigger minefield..
- seren 12y agoBut this ruling will create a precedent that will make it harder to justify, that Sherlock Holmes entered the domain public and Mickey Mouse should not, although I am pretty sure that Walt Disney's lawyers are already carefully preparing their argument for the next few hundred years of protection extension.
- Shivetya 12y agoI am actually not for Mickey entering public domain, he is still representative of a very active and well known company. There are certain characters in the Disney domain that would be wholly out of place anywhere else. Whereas book characters from long dead authors are a whole different matter. While I think estates should be able to protect the rights of the estate for a period of time the fact that no new content can be created by the author should discount extending the protection. Now interesting cases do arise where direct descendant or designated authors do keep stories and characters progressing, Dune and Pern come to mind. So where the association is very strong with an active entitle I say let them keep it, where there are degrees of separation, like book examples, then perhaps one generation?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoThe Matrix should be in the public domain. Copyright should last 5 years, plus another 5 years if it's made available to the public without DRM.
- mattmanser 12y agoThen you don't understand why copyright was created. It's not there to give forever and ever protection. It's there to allow you to get some money before society, which made your product worth something in the first place, can incorporate it into culture where it belonged in the first place. Disney themselves love using other people stories constantly, but no-one can use theirs for extreme amounts of time because they've distorted the meaning of copyright. There's no good reason for someone else's ideas to be protected, it doesn't benefit society at all. Copyright should be 10-15 years, not this ridiculous century. Apart from America as it exports the stuff, so, surprise, surprise, they've bullied the rest of the world into making stupidly long copyrights so that everything created in the last century is languishing in untouchable hell so a few big brands can continue making money off things that should be public domain.
- philh 12y ago> Then you don't understand why copyright was created. Just because someone disagrees with you, doesn't mean that they don't understand the issue. Your post would have worked just as well without this line.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- simonh 12y ago> The more Disney uses variations of them, the bigger the minefield becomes in terms of sticking to the depictions that enters/have entered public domain. That's a two-edged sword. If someone else produces material featuring Steamboat Willy which does not violate recent usage, it could seriously curtail Disney's future ability to use the character as well.
- jerf 12y agoCopyright law would not prevent us from creating derivatives of Steamboat Willie, but trademark law probably would. We could still sell Steamboat Willie on those dirt-cheap DVDs, though, as-is. For what that's worth... it's really of primarily historical interest, I doubt modern audiences will find that much to be terribly entertained by in it. I don't have a problem with this. While it's not likely to any of the tastes of anybody reading this sentence, since Mickey Mouse right now is mostly being used to entertain those too young to read, he's still actively producing things. (And while Mickey Mouse Clubhouse is hardly a masterpiece for adults.... there's much worse out there to have to listen to ad infinitum.) The offensive thing about infinite copyright extension is locking up things that the creators are done with, and have been for decades, but won't let anyone else do anything either, thus essentially killing the cultural artifact in question.
- aceperry 12y agoI guess it's not surprising that Sherlock Holmes couldn't pull a Mickey Mouse. The AC Doyle estate should've greased the wheels of commerce with some major dollars.
- BerislavLopac 12y agoThe problem with such cases is that -- as far as I'm aware (IANAL) -- concepts like characters, inventions (e.g. hyperdrive) etc are not covered by any of the existing laws that handle creative monopolies (i.e. what is generally known, incorrectly, as "intellectual property"). Copyright covers the specific fixed representations (e.g. words on paper) and not ideas and concepts, while other laws like patents or trademarks also seem unfit here.
- NickNameNick 12y agoCouldn't the estate trademark Sherlock Holmes' name? Didn't Disney eventually trademark Mickey Mouse?
- vidarh 12y agoNot a lawyer either. Characters may be protected by copyright, in as much as their manifestations in writing, or visual depictions etc. is protected by copyright, and copyright includes the right to control derivative works. So if I describe a young boy that goes to wizard school in a book, then that idea is not protected by copyright, but if the way I describe him makes him similar enough to Harry Potter, I would risk that a court would determine that the character is a derivative work and find copyright infringement. Trademark can also apply, if the characters have been used in association with products, but not generally for the work itself.
- ben0x539 12y agoI've googled this a bunch out of curiosity before and everybody, including a bunch of courts, seems to argue that fleshed-out fictional characters are in fact covered by copyright even with the serial numbers filed off. IANAL either, obviously. I mean, you'd be drowning in published, unauthorized fanfic of Batman and Harry Potter and whatnot otherwise.
- BerislavLopac 12y agoIn fact we do. E.g. 50 shades of grey started out as a fanfic of Twilight.
- 12y ago
- melling 12y agoIs this only the English version? I read somewhere that translations are derived works and hold a different status.
- jvreeland 12y agoIANAL (or that experience with copyright) but, it probably depends on the country and how it was translated. A translation of Clash of Kings to Spanish in the US for example would be considered a derivative work. A translator would have been hired by the publisher (or similar party) and created with permission from the original copyright holder who would then retain a copyright over the Spanish copy, although probably the same copyright. Translating without the permission of the copyright holder as far as I'm aware is against US copyright laws. I imagine it's different if you translate something without a current copyright, a translation of Beowulf for example may be eligible for copyright. This is just extrapolation from my limited knowledge on the subject.
- vidarh 12y agoYes, there is generally a separate copyright in the translation. I'm not aware whether/how common exceptions from that apply depending on jurisdiction. But most places you should be able to do a new translation from the original and be ok.
- danesparza 12y agoI'm curious... (and I'm only being a little flippant, I promise) Does this also mean that the new BBC series can be freely distributed on Bit torrent without fear of copyright infringement?
- tim333 12y agoSadly not. The BBC has copyright on the things they produce themselves if not on the Sherlock character.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoNo, each new work gets its own separate copyright period. Many individual elements of the BBC series are public domain, and as such could be used in other works, but the work as a whole is covered by copyright.
- jordigh 12y agoI find it cute that the British-born Holmes is in the public domain in the US, but the true-blooded American Mouse is not.
- TylerE 12y agoWhy is this shocking? Sherlock predates Mickey by 41 years.
- jordigh 12y agoNo, the Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes was published in 1927. Steamboat Willie is from 1928. Copyright law in the US is basically built around Mickey Mouse. Sherlock Holmes seems to barely make the cut into public domain.
- TylerE 12y agoThe first volume of Sherlock Holmes stories was published in 1887.
- bane 12y agoSome real absolutely timeless classic stories are available in the public domain right now. If I had more time, money and passion, I'd be the RMS of the public domain. In my mind it's the free-est a work can possibly be. Unencumbered by licensing or copyright (or copyleft) considerations. You like it? Use it for whatever you want in whatever way you want. One of my friends was looking for something to read, had an old kindle but didn't really have any money to pay for anything. I pointed her towards these absolute classics which kept her occupied for months, and then she passed them down to her kids. She now has a kindle full of more books than she can possibly read, all for free. And her children are now benefiting from this as well. The last time we spoke, her son was enjoying romping across Mars in the "Barsoom" series, a series of books I grew up enjoying immensely. Even while looking for these I was stunned how many freaking awesome works are out there in the PD. (most of these have ready-to-go kindle versions) All of the Oz books (yes, there is more than 1 as I was delighted to find out) - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/42 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/42 E.R. Burroughs, which gets you the Barsoom series, Tarzan and a handful of other fantastically great adventure reads http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/48 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/48 Even better, Verne, which gets you adventure, sci-fi and more - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/60 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/60 A huge collection of Doyle works, Sherlock is a big piece, but he wrote tons of others. http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/69 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/69 A collection of old Science Fiction monthlies - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/search/?query=astounding+stories+of+super+science http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/search/?query=astounding+sto... The indomitable works by Dumas - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/492 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/492 An entire classic bookshelf of Rudyard Kipling - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/132 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/132 Jack London, who I grew up reading as a child and loving - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/120 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/120 Stevenson - http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/35 http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/author/35 And that's just the Gutenberg project. You can dive into several Library of Congress's worth of books, magazine and other literature at archive.org, a well so deep, it's easy to get lost and never find your way back to the same place again. And also happens to have the best on-line e-reader ever made. (Note: not all of these have fallen into the PD, but Archive.org treats them like it's from a world where they are in the PD, demonstrating the power of the idea). https://archive.org/details/texts https://archive.org/details/texts but does have an almost 3,000 item Children's library https://archive.org/details/iacl https://archive.org/details/iacl, mostly of scans of original prints which are amazing on tablets. The Harvard Classics https://archive.org/details/harvardclassics https://archive.org/details/harvardclassics And these astonishing collections https://archive.org/details/comics https://archive.org/details/comics https://archive.org/details/imslp https://archive.org/details/imslp https://archive.org/details/magazine_rack https://archive.org/details/magazine_rack (which includes 196 issues of OMNI magazine https://archive.org/details/omni-magazine https://archive.org/details/omni-magazine and 103 issues of Galaxy https://archive.org/details/galaxymagazine https://archive.org/details/galaxymagazine, 300 issues of Starlog https://archive.org/details/starlogmagazine https://archive.org/details/starlogmagazine) And almost 1,500 scans of various Pulp Magazines https://archive.org/details/pulpmagazinearchive https://archive.org/details/pulpmagazinearchive Several libraries' worth of Computer Magazines (11,000 issues!) https://archive.org/details/computermagazines https://archive.org/details/computermagazines And finally https://archive.org/details/sciencefiction https://archive.org/details/sciencefiction
- nkurz 12y agoWow, I think this new decision cleans up a number of loose ends left by the district judge. It's not especially clear in the Guardian article, but this is the Circuit Court (one layer below the Supreme Court) decision of the appeal by the Conan Doyle Estate of a District Court decision made at the end of last year. The District Court decision by Ruben Castillo (http://freesherlock.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/klinger-order-on-motion-for-summary-judgment-c.pdf http://freesherlock.files.wordpress.com/2013/12/klinger-orde...) went largely in favor of Klinger, saying that the pre-1923 stories were public domain. But it left a lot of uncertainty about how incidental details ("increments of expression") from the later stories were to be treated. There's a good summary of the District decision here: http://tushnet.blogspot.com/2014/01/guest-post-betsy-rosenblatt-on-case-of.html http://tushnet.blogspot.com/2014/01/guest-post-betsy-rosenbl... In addition to affirming the earlier District decision (Klinger can publish without fear of being sued), this brand new Circuit decision by Richard Posner seems like it clears up a lot of the uncertainty and offers much clearer guidelines for future decisions. And it does it decisively and with considerable flair: http://freesherlock.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/klinger-7th-circuit-opinion-c.pdf http://freesherlock.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/klinger-7th-... We cannot find any basis in statute or case law for ex- tending a copyright beyond its expiration. When a story falls into the public domain, story elements—including characters covered by the expired copyright—become fair game for follow-on authors... The decision itself is worth reading, definitely clearer and more engaging than most of the newspaper coverage.
- kurren 12y agoof course. let's apply the same 'logic' with mickey f*ng mouse, now. please.