4 ms·
> but implicit in that statement is that regulation is never desirable. Not exactly. What's implicit in that statement is that a structure with the physical ab
by baddox 12y ago
> but implicit in that statement is that regulation is never desirable.
Not exactly. What's implicit in that statement is that a structure with the physical ability to create and enforce regulations will probably create some effective regulations, and some ineffective regulations. Just like how a market will probably lead to some efficient outcomes, and some inefficient outcomes (i.e. market failures).
So the question becomes which structure (government or markets) can do better overall, or if there's some way to combine the two such that you get "the best of both worlds" which is better than an all-or-nothing approach. My belief is that markets can do better overall than a pure command economy or a mixed economy, primarily because governments (at least modern republics) are, at the end of the day, somewhat subject to market forces in the form of elections, lobbying, personal incentives of government officials, etc., This makes the whole "let's use government to solve some common market failures" idea seem fairly silly to me. If we as a society can't aggregate our desires effectively enough to avoid a market failure (e.g. to fund a public good, like a highway system [0]), why should we expect to be able to aggregate our desires effectively enough to give legal authority to an organization to use violence to avoid a market failure?
[0] Using the broader definition of "public good" that includes club goods, and assuming the highway system isn't so congested that it can be considered rivalrous.
- warfangle 12y agoHow would a Free (as opposed to 'free' with regulations attached) market limit industrial pollution (some contaminations of which aren't discovered until almost a century after the original contamination[0])? In a Free market, how does an individual litigate against a multinational oil company that spills 17-30 million gallons of oil into a major metropolitan area[1]? (Very slowly: litigation has been ongoing with nearly no developments in the last 9 years except to drop Chevron) In a Free market, who sues the coal plants when entire uninhabited ecosystems are poisoned with lead, mercury, and sulfuric acid? In a Free market, who do you sue when global temperatures rise by 5C and flood major metropolitan areas? What market forces are at work when an entity will be defunct by the time the repercussions of its actions come to light? [0]. http://www.wnyc.org/story/most-radioactive-site-new-york/ http://www.wnyc.org/story/most-radioactive-site-new-york/ [1]. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenpoint_oil_spill http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenpoint_oil_spill
- nickff 12y agoIn a free market, property rights are more extensive than in a highly regulated market, so tort law serves many of the purposes that regulators and federal agencies currently do. When a multinational company causes damage to a harbor, beach, ecosystem or city, damaged parties can file suit for compensation. A harbor authority may have provided a guarantee to assume responsibility for environmental problems, in order to be granted the relevant rights of way, or it may be on the other side of the law, filing suit against a company which has damaged its income stream. Landowners or municipalities can file suit for damage caused to a beach, and fishermen, environmental tour companies, or governments can file suit for damage to ecosystems. In the United States, the EPA has absolved many companies of any responsibility, or at least greatly diminished the corporations' costs, by depriving damaged parties of a cause of action, as the EPA has the sole responsibility for many forms of pollution, and their regulation. Free markets are not very different from mixed systems in dealing with issues like climate change, but they do make it plain to each individual that they are directly responsible for the outcomes which come to pass. This responsibility is more effective in regulating action than one might think. In a market system, entities at fault may be defunct by the time the repercussions of their actions are apparent; on the other hand, politicians are rarely held to account on any single issue, and they are often more ephemeral than large corporations; the bureaucrats responsible for regulation are never held to account for any results at all.
- nitrogen 12y agoIn a free market, property rights are more extensive than in a highly regulated market, so tort law serves many of the purposes that regulators and federal agencies currently do. So how does a small property owner fund decade-long litigation against a giant corporation?
- nickff 12y agoI will assume that your question refers to damages caused to a "small property owner" by a multinational corporation. There are a few alternatives: 1) When large corporations do anything, it is usually on a grand scale, so it is likely that the "small property owner" can find a number of neighbours similarly affected, and join in a class-action lawsuit, to defray the costs. 2) If the "small property owner" is very sure of victory in the courts, they can take out a loan, to finance their legal costs, which they may be able to recover from the respondent at a later date. 3) The "small property owner" may find a lawyer willing to do the work pro-bono, or on a contingency basis. 4) Some "small property owner[s]" may represent themselves in court; this is not as uncommon as some think, and many people present their case well without a credential-ed lawyer. The most likely outcome is a settlement in any case, as no corporation wishes to gain a reputation that it is unwilling to clean up its own mess, and a drawn-out court battle would not be very productive.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> If we as a society can't aggregate our desires effectively enough to avoid a market failure (e.g. to fund a public good, like a highway system [0]), why should we expect to be able to aggregate our desires effectively enough to give legal authority to an organization to use violence to avoid a market failure? What if the problem isn't inability to effectively aggregate desires, its inability to redistribute externalized cost to reflect those aggregated desires absent an entity with the particular set of features to which we give the name "government"? It seems to me that you've constructed a false (and rather unusual) notion of the source of market failure designed specifically to rebut the argument that government can be a solution to market failure.
- baddox 12y agoInternalizing costs is certainly a part of what I meant by "effectively aggregate our desires."
- dragonwriter 12y agoRight, so you are using equivocation -- using the same term with two different meanings -- when you use "effectively aggregate our desires". In one use, it means "internalize externalities". In other, it means, well, its not really clear what it means specifically in terms of forming a government -- but its clear it doesn't mean internalize externalities since that's what the government is intended to do, not what is done to form it -- but you use the same term to misleading pretend its the same problem.
- baddox 12y agoThat's not even close to equivocation. It's not equivocation to use the term "animals" to refer to a set of things like cats, dogs, monkeys, etc.