3 ms·
It's crime to plan to do something, no?
by gadders 12y ago
It's crime to plan to do something, no?
- gambiting 12y agoRight, but it's a separate crime than actually doing it, and from what I understand, the law does not separate these two in this case. The law treats it as if they were chatting to an actual child, which they weren't.
- DanBC 12y agoBut they thought they were. If they thought they were selling illegal drugs but they were just selling sugar they would be convicted. (In England if you sell sugar as illegal drugs you will be convicted of a drugs offence even if you know you are selling pure sugar).
- danielweber 12y agoIANAL, and this depends on jurisdiction, but it generally requires planning plus an overt act towards the plan. If I plan to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces in triple-mylar garbage bags, when I go to the store to buy garbage bags I've crossed the legal threshold. In many states, if the prosecutor can prove to the jury 1) I planned to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces into garbage bags, and 2) bought garbage bags, I'm toast and will go away for several years. NB there is nothing wrong with just buying the garbage bags.
- gadders 12y agoOK, but if the "offender" in this case a) spoke inappropriately to someone they believed was underage and then b) arranged a time and place to meet them, that would count, no?
- danielweber 12y agoYep. Sounds like it should be easy to prove having a plan and the overt act towards the plan. Incidentally, this is why you should always get a lawyer before talking to the cops.