4 ms·
This is going to be an extremely unpopular opinion,but I would like to actually have some meaningful discussion about this - am I the only one to think that cha
by gambiting 12y ago
This is going to be an extremely unpopular opinion,but I would like to actually have some meaningful discussion about this - am I the only one to think that chatting/flirting/talking about sex with a generated avatar, no matter what is it of, should not be a crime?
- pitnips 12y agoIf you know it's an avatar, maybe not. But if you think it's a real girl, then yes, absolutely it should be.
- gambiting 12y agoSo...it's a crime to think about something? Is it a crime to think about murdering someone? Or about stealing a purse, but without actually doing any of these things?
- crusso 12y agoHaven't you done more than think by participating in the conversation? I'm all for discussing this and thinking about it, but actually chatting with the person on the other end demonstrates intent.
- gambiting 12y agoThen they should be tried for intent. And it is my understanding,that they are being accused of actually molesting a child,even though there was no child present on the other side.
- mcphage 12y ago> And it is my understanding,that they are being accused of actually molesting a child That would certainly change things—where did you get that data from?
- tinco 12y agoNo, you are twisting the accusation. It is not a crime to think, it is a crime to act. The law here is about the act of proposing sexual actions to a child over the internet, which has been made illegal by the UN. Under debate is whether it is still illegal when the victim of your action does not actually exist as a person.
- olog-hai 12y ago> made illegal by the UN The UN is not a government.
- rqebmm 12y agoThe crime isn't thinking about abusing a child, it's intending to abuse a child. It's still somewhat in a grey area since they haven't actually harmed anyone, but it's a lot darker grey than just the having the idea to do it.
- gadders 12y agoIt's crime to plan to do something, no?
- gambiting 12y agoRight, but it's a separate crime than actually doing it, and from what I understand, the law does not separate these two in this case. The law treats it as if they were chatting to an actual child, which they weren't.
- DanBC 12y agoBut they thought they were. If they thought they were selling illegal drugs but they were just selling sugar they would be convicted. (In England if you sell sugar as illegal drugs you will be convicted of a drugs offence even if you know you are selling pure sugar).
- danielweber 12y agoIANAL, and this depends on jurisdiction, but it generally requires planning plus an overt act towards the plan. If I plan to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces in triple-mylar garbage bags, when I go to the store to buy garbage bags I've crossed the legal threshold. In many states, if the prosecutor can prove to the jury 1) I planned to kill my boss, saw him into pieces with a chainsaw, and put the pieces into garbage bags, and 2) bought garbage bags, I'm toast and will go away for several years. NB there is nothing wrong with just buying the garbage bags.
- gadders 12y agoOK, but if the "offender" in this case a) spoke inappropriately to someone they believed was underage and then b) arranged a time and place to meet them, that would count, no?
- danielweber 12y agoYep. Sounds like it should be easy to prove having a plan and the overt act towards the plan. Incidentally, this is why you should always get a lawyer before talking to the cops.
- EpicEng 12y agoIs it a crime to think about murdering someone? It's certainly a crime to plan to murder someone. These guys have gone beyond thinking about it; they have actually planned and tried to execute on the idea. What about that is different than conspiracy to murder? Now,if these people are being accused of anything more than intent I think it is going too far.
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoNo, it's a crime to actually try to murder someone. It's a crime to grab your purse strap, try to yank it away, then give up and run. This isn't hard.
- rosser 12y agoNice false dilemma. Of course it's not a crime to think about something. But that's not what happened here. The alleged perps propositioned a child for sexual acts. That it happened not to have been an actual, breathing child in the specific instance involving Sweetie is incidental; I'll bet you real money it was every other time... EDIT: Or do you somehow actually think that for all 1000 people found via this "honeypot", it was the first time they ever thought, "I know what I'll do today! I'll pay a naked 8-year-old to touch herself over the internet!" and that they were just "lucky" enough to get a fake kid their first time out?
- gambiting 12y agoThis is not how any justice system ever works. And I bet that you do not want it to work that way.
- ScottBurson 12y agoYou're thoroughly mistaken. If you proposition a police officer masquerading as a prostitute, you will be arrested and successfully prosecuted.
- rosser 12y agoMeta: What's with the tendency on HN to downvote people saying demonstrably true things? Do you somehow think that your downvote will alter the parts of reality you don't like or something?
- gambiting 12y agoYes,but based on that one act,not on the "assumption" that you do it regularly and have done it a thousand times before,as the previous commenter was suggesting.
- rosser 12y agoYou seem to think we're advocating arresting and prosecuting people based solely on their interactions with Sweetie. That's patently untrue, and (in my case, at least) easily refuted by my reply to you else-thread, where I said: If you ask me, however, Bob's propositioning Sweetie creates sufficient Probable Cause to obtain a warrant to search his computer for evidence of other, similar, interactions, with actual children. Then he can be prosecuted for the cases where there was a victim. That he interacts with a virtual child in an inappropriate way is strongly suggestive that has engaged in that behavior at other times, with other, real children. The issues that cause people to act on their pedophilia tend not to result in isolated incidents, and this has been repeatedly demonstrated by years and years of study of hundreds, if not thousands, of individuals. If the police find no evidence that he's done this before — whether because he actually hasn't (vanishingly unlikely), or because he's too good at hiding his aberrance — then we may or may not be able to prosecute him, depending on the jurisdiction. But, for my money, Sweetie isn't per se about prosecution. It's about helping surface individuals that warrant further scrutiny, subject to due process, and then quite possibly prosecution.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- JasonFruit 12y agoIt's probably the same principle as offering to kill someone for a cop; even though they didn't really have you kill someone, it still is enough to put you in jail. Here, the perverts thought they were trying to get a little girl to take her clothes off, even though there wasn't a real little girl. Now, if they knew it was just a computer-generated image, I think you might have a point; they'd still be perverts, but maybe (IANAL) not criminals.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoCan you be charged with anything further than "Conspiracy to do X" if all they have is intent?
- johnchristopher 12y agoAnd yet no crime were actually committed. There are no victims.
- dragonwriter 12y agoWhether or not you believe a victim other than society in general (or the sovereign) ought to be required for a crime, that's not an actual requirement.
- johnchristopher 12y agoFair point.
- rosser 12y agoThere are no victims. In the specific instance involving "Sweetie", sure. Please don't tell me you think that Bob, aged 51, had never before in his life propositioned a child — a child who is in all likelihood an actual slave — to perform sex acts over the internet, until he happened innocently to be hanging out in #dirtylittlegirls, and propositioned Sweetie.
- gambiting 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ThomPete 12y agoI am a father of two. I am personally troubled by this approach for the simple reason it's very binary approach (no pun intended) to a very complex issue. The articles language alone (predators) a formulation which will ensure that no matter what these guys did it will be understood in the worst possible way and inform public opinion. I fact I believe that FastCoCreate is guilty of a form of sensationalism something we last saw during the Spanish inquisition. And yes if someone did something like this to my kids I would want to worst possible sentence to those people, which is why it's good that we have a system where I am not going to be the judge.
- digitalsushi 12y agoIf you try to pay a police officer costumed as a prostitute, do they let you go on the same technicality? Which then, if you never offer to pay, leaves such a costumed officer frustrated - what if these webcam viewers literally just wanted to chat? (Treat that as a statistical experiment) Where they disconnected? Or entrapped?
- delluminatus 12y agoI would argue that there is a difference between having an undercover officer posing as a prostitute, and having a virtual prostitute. In the former case, by paying the officer, you are -- in a sense -- engaging a prostitute. In the latter case, you are paying for what amounts to a virtual service.
- fixermark 12y ago... a virtual service that the perpetrator believed was real. Past sting operations in the narcotics space have involved fake drugs---flour in plastic bags. Perpetrators who either bought or attempted to steal the fake drugs were convicted. One can debate the morality of stings in general, but I think the question of intent vs. reality is a settled question regarding legal precedent.
- johnchristopher 12y agoI don't know much about the american legal system but where I live the question of intent and the act itself are separated.
- tseabrooks 12y agoI'm with you - But in the US I believe this depends on the state. The "To catch a predator" show was specifically done in areas where the law included "intent" as a crime, rather than the actual crime IIRC.
- dublinben 12y agoThe arrests on that show also usually result in dropped charges or even the suicide of an alleged predator. We shouldn't be condoning these kinds of tactics anywhere. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/To_Catch_a_Predator#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/To_Catch_a_Predator#Criticism
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoIf this group had openly advertised Sweetie as a computer-generated little girl avatar for sale, and then nailed anyone who responded, I would be a lot more conflicted. But all of these people believed that they were taking advantage of an actual child. Attempted murder is a crime. Trying and failing to steal a car is a crime. I see no reason why attempted child abuse shouldn't also be a crime.
- gambiting 12y ago>>Attempted murder is a crime. Trying and failing to steal a car is a crime. I see no reason why attempted child abuse shouldn't also be a crime. So should stabbing a mannequin should also be treated as murder, if the person doing the stabbing was 100% convinced that it was a real person? Or an attempt to break into a car made out of cardboard treated as an actual robbery,if the thief was 100% convinced it was a real thing before trying it? I want all child molesters to rot in prison forever. I really do. But there was no children present here.
- fixermark 12y agoYes, that's basically the legal argument being made (by, I assume, people who aren't lawyers). It's controversial, but it's definitely accepted in some jurisdictions. Police have, in fact, nabbed car thieves using honeypot "broken down cars" on the sides of freeways. Personal opinion: someone stabbing a mannequin with the intent to murder a real person should be charged with attempted homicide. IANAL. ;)
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoYes and yes. There should be nothing wrong with thinking about crime. Openly discussing and planning a crime...well, that depends on a lot of factors, but there's certainly situations where it should be fine, e.g. kids idly fantasizing about blowing away a school bully without any real means or intention to do so. But when someone honestly and to the best of their ability attempts to commit a serious crime like murder or child abuse, then yes, absolutely they should be prosecuted. If someone attempts to kill me but screws it up, I don't want them walking free to try again and again until they get it right. Also bear in mind that, at least in the US, "murder" and "attempted murder" are different crimes, and I'm okay with that.
- roeme 12y agoI think the generated avatar only serves as a 'honeypot', so to speak. A colleague of mine provided me with some interesting information in a discussion quite a while ago: His company a few years back provided text-only chatrooms for their customers. Being an ISP, and the fact that they also marketed it, led to quite a huge audience (also, the Internet 'rush' began). 'Predators', though not yet known under this moniker, became a problem quite soon. So what did they do? They set up automated bots, which had just enough logic to fool a human into thinking it's speaking to it's own kind. If someone engaged them in a conversation, and IIRC, asked for some sensitive information (though I'm not sure of the latter), they generated an alert and a real, human police officer took over the bot. But either an avatar or other human being - I'm still not sure about the legality of the whole thing; a long time ago I learned something along the lines that law enforcement is not allowed to 'bait' someone into doing something illegal; as the whole situation could be doctored to force somebody to do something they wouldn't have done otherwise. I think it's related to your question; but unfortunately I can't recall what the concept is called, or if I'm completely off-track here anyway. Though in the end; the person still did something illegal, and I can't think of this line of reasoning to work well in court.
- dllthomas 12y ago"I'm still not sure about the legality of the whole thing; a long time ago I learned something along the lines that law enforcement is not allowed to 'bait' someone into doing something illegal; as the whole situation could be doctored to force somebody to do something they wouldn't have done otherwise. I think it's related to your question; but unfortunately I can't recall what the concept is called, or if I'm completely off-track here anyway." The concept is "entrapment".
- anon4 12y agoIn this specific case, as I understand it, the persons were chatting with what they believed was a real child. I think it's ok to judge based on intent in this case. If there were a site where legally adult people posed as children using virtual avatars and voice-altering software selling sexual services and the site was advertised as such, then the issue becomes a lot more complex. My opinion is that as long as a person doesn't show clear intent (and this is a very slippery slope, I realise) to cause harm to a minor, they should not be persecuted for their actions. And if intent is clearly determined, but no harm was actually done, I'd prefer that the individual be not punished (including not having their communications monitored, though this might only be acceptable for first offenders), but asked to attend a form of therapy. On the other hand, if harm was done, the measures to be taken should depend on presence or absence of intent, as is in other cases.