3 ms·
>>For the air-battery operator it will mean swapping out the old battery for a new one every few months I don't know how much the author of this article drives
by gambiting 12y ago
>>For the air-battery operator it will mean swapping out the old battery for a new one every few months
I don't know how much the author of this article drives, but 1800km range would mean that I would have to swap the battery every month. And I imagine that the range depends heavily on how you drive, so I would like to see real-world usage test.
- mattlutze 12y agoThe use case here seems to be for city cars. If you only rarely need to go more than 20-40 miles in a day, the aluminum batter will last a very long time (as it'll almost never be used). Agreed, for commuters this wouldn't be a good answer to the "range anxiety" question. I'd definitely be curious in general to see what the total environmental impact of 1,000 miles of range produced with a gas motor is compared to the 1,000 miles of range with this battery. As in, from mining to fuel exhaustion.
- jcr 12y agoIt seems you're confusing the range of the vehicle at full charge with eventual need to replace the battery. The article is not particularly clear on that, but the ComputerWorld article I linked to gives a few more details.
- gambiting 12y agoFrom what I understand,the battery is non-rechargeable, so you can only drive 1800km until you have to replace it completely,no?
- jcr 12y agoThe Aluminum-Air batteries are rechargeable, but they wear out faster than lithium-ion batteries. Eventually, both Aluminum-Air and Lithium-Ion batteries will wear out and need to be replaced, but the Aluminum-Air batteries need to be replaced more often since they wear out faster. From the ComputerWorld article: > "The recharge of the aluminum-air [battery] is user-friendly and consists of refilling water and replacing aluminum when depleted," a spokesperson for Alcoa said in an email response to Computerworld. "The water refill is an easy task that can be performed by using tap water on average every one or two months according to mileage driven." The battery's aluminum replacement is also a "quick operation" that will be performed at periodic maintenance checks at a local service station on average once a year according to mileage driven, the spokesperson added.
- BugBrother 12y agoUh, Aluminium/air batteries are one time use (not "rechargeable", rather replaceable) or there is major new chemistry. See my other comment re Al smelting and energy/CO2. Edit: This is discussed in the previous thread, abalone posted a link to it.
- masklinn 12y agoAccording to http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9248966/Electric_car_battery_tech_lets_you_go_1_000_miles_between_charges http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9248966/Electric_car_..., recharging the battery is "just" replacing the aluminum plates and topping up the water. And note that there's a classical Li-Ion battery, so the usage scenario seems to be mostly urban users with short commutes (on the Li-Ion, possibly slightly longer on the metal-air battery) with the occasional long trip eating into the metal-air battery.
- AlisdairO 12y agoI think the general idea is that you have a lithium battery for the typically shorter day to day journeys (say 60 miles?), and the air battery is there for occasional long-range journeys. This amounts to a different solution for the problem that the Volt solves - with substantially lower weight/cost/maintenance overhead.
- chacham15 12y ago"The recharge of the aluminum-air [battery] is user-friendly and consists of refilling water and replacing aluminum when depleted," a spokesperson for Alcoa said in an email response to Computerworld. "The water refill is an easy task that can be performed by using tap water on average every one or two months according to mileage driven. The battery's aluminum replacement is also a "quick operation" that will be performed at periodic maintenance checks at a local service station on average once a year according to mileage driven, the spokesperson added"[1] [1] http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9248966/Electric_car_battery_tech_lets_you_go_1_000_miles_between_charges http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9248966/Electric_car_...
- gus_massa 12y agoYou can’t just dispose the old water into the sewer because it has a lot of aluminum salts. You must store it and send it back for recycling. Probably this task should be done in a gas station or a car repair shop and not at your home, so they have the tanks for the old liquids.