4 ms·
Temperature-pressure phase diagrams (example linked below) http://images.flatworldknowledge.com/averillfwk/averillfwk-fig11_022.jpg http://images.flatworldknow
by jjoonathan 12y ago
Temperature-pressure phase diagrams (example linked below)
http://images.flatworldknowledge.com/averillfwk/averillfwk-fig11_022.jpg http://images.flatworldknowledge.com/averillfwk/averillfwk-f...
have a line that separates gas from liquid, but this line has a finite length. One endpoint is on the triple point (solid, liquid, gas coexist at one P,T) and the other is on the critical point. That's where the distinction between gas and liquid vanishes -- the viscosity, index of refraction, etc of one phase approach those of the other until differences vanish altogether at the critical point. It's a little arbitrary to say that steam at a given temperature or pressure is supercritical (there IS a rigorous definition, T>T_criticalpoint&&P>P_criticalpoint, I'm just saying that it's a bit arbitrary), but the gist of it is that you're in the part of the phase diagram where movement in the phase plane is going to avoid the gas/liquid transition. Nothing physical happens in a liquid->supercritical or supercritical->gas transition and there are no phase transitions in the supercritical region.
This is exploited for the production of aerogel. Normally you can't dry out a gel and have it retain its shape because the liquid/gas interface during evaporation/boiling has enough surface tension to tear apart the microstructure of the gel. But if you scoot around the liquid/gas transition in phase space (e.g. by heating past T_criticalpoint, lowering pressure below T_criticalpoint, cooling below T_criticalpoint, and finally releasing any lingering pressure, or in other words liquid->supercritical->gas) then you can get rid of the liquid without ever boiling/evaporating it -> no nasty surface tension to tear apart the microstructure!
Here is a video of CO2 being heated past the critical point. Since there is a gas-liquid equilibrium, the system will move more or less exactly along the curve separating gas from liquid until it "slips off the end" into the supercritical region:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=FLAv56CgHL4P8vk6FDm9s1Zw&feature=player_detailpage&v=GEr3NxsPTOA#t=150 https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=FLAv56CgHL4P8vk6FDm9s1Zw&...
EDIT: || -> && in the formal definition
EDIT2: linked a phase diagram for those who don't stare at them all day :)
- jwheeler79 12y agoin layman's terms anyone?
- femto 12y agoIf you heat water under a high enough pressure, when you release the pressure it instantly becomes stream. Normally, when you boil water the vapourisation happens piecemeal. That's why you see bubbles rising to the surface. For supercritically heated water, the vapourisation is a runaway chain reaction, triggered by a reduction in pressure, so the whole body of water flashes into stream. --- Edit: added note about reduction in pressure being the trigger.
- jjoonathan 12y agoIf you release pressure slowly you never see boiling/evaporation either, but at the end of the process you have steam.
- neltnerb 12y agoApologies, I don't want to be pedantic, but this has nothing to do with being supercritical. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercritical_fluid#mediaviewer/File:Carbon_dioxide_pressure-temperature_phase_diagram.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercritical_fluid#mediaviewe... You can note in this diagram that what you are describing is true whether or not the system is supercritical, and can be seen in how water will boil into steam when the pressure is decreased from atmospheric as well. What you are describing is how higher pressures allow you to add energy to the water while it remains liquid, and how if you add enough energy it will overcome the enthalpy of vaporization and cause it to convert to steam as the pressure is reduced.
- femto 12y agoPoint taken! I'm not an expert. As I understand it, a container of boiling water will have liquid in the bottom half and steam in the top half. As the pressure and temperature rise, the steam/water goes supercritial, meaning the water/steam boundary disappears and the whole container becomes a homogenous mush of supercritical fluid. Am I right in thinking that this supercritical fluid can flash into steam faster than a combination of water and steam? My thinking is that for a water/steam combination to convert into steam, the water molecules have to take the time to break their bonds and separate into a gas. For a supercritical fluid it's faster because there are no bonds to be broken? I'd be grateful if you can correct the above, as I can learn something here.
- SAI_Peregrinus 12y agoActually, according to (http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/PT.3.1796 http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/PT.3.1796) the boundary between liquid/gas and supercritical fluid is inherently poorly defined, it's not a sharp boundary like the line of evaporation or fusion.
- jjoonathan 12y agoI'm guessing you were responding to an earlier version of my post where I kept mentioning that the liquid->supercritical and gas->supercritical boundary was poorly defined (in agreement with you) but then, in apparent contradiction to what I had just written, linked to a video of what happened at the transition, which I reconciled with my earlier claim of arbitrariness by emphasizing that the transition is well defined and physical you have a 2-phase system in equilibrium that you slide along the phase boundary until it "slips off." That's still true. You can see the evidence in the video :) But at every other point along the liquid->supercritical and gas->supercritical phase boundaries you are correct, the boundary is an arbitrary definition and not physical.
- neltnerb 12y agoTo be slightly more specific, it is not that it is poorly defined, it is that it doesn't exist. The boundary between liquid and gas is defined by a boundary at which it requires additional energy and an accompanying abrupt change in density to change between the states. In a supercritical state, there is no additional energy or change in density. In other words, you can smoothly transition from "liquid" to "gas" without needing to boil. The two states are a single phase.