5 ms·
As a non-American, I have no allegience to either party... but couldn't you be mixing up cause and effect here? Perhaps instead of one party creating the econom
by girvo 12y ago
As a non-American, I have no allegience to either party... but couldn't you be mixing up cause and effect here? Perhaps instead of one party creating the economic effects, perhaps that party is voted in when the country is doing economically well?
- srl 12y agoThis is a theory I've often heard, and personally suspect to have a good deal of validity (although obviously it's an oversimplification). In good economic times, people don't mind the government spending a lot - after all, the economy is doing well, what can go wrong? In bad economic times, people think the government ought to be more stingy. Of course, this is pretty much the opposite of what you really want. When the economy is doing well is the time to reel in spending and raise taxes. When the economy is doing badly is the time for stimulus spending and a larger deficit.
- ritchiea 12y agoThe mistake is associating one party or another with spending. While American conservatives speak of cutting spending rarely does this happen in practice. Think of the Iraq war under Bush, or my favorite, in 2003 Republicans extending Medicare's prescription drug coverage to essentially pander to elderly voters [1]. Not to mention most voters are poorly informed. Most elections are won by charismatic candidates and campaigns that can weave a coherent narrative rather than by the population's calculations on what spending policy is best for the country. I worked in politics for years, including for Obama for America in 2008 and wow undecided voters are scary. And those are the people who decide elections, people who are largely poorly informed & making gut decisions about who has the power to start wars for the next four years. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_Prescription_Drug,_Improvement,_and_Modernization_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_Prescription_Drug,_Imp...
- kghose 12y ago"As a non-American, I have no allegiance to either party." - this does not follow. Just because you are not the citizen of a country does not mean you do not have political biases that lead you to look on certain politicians/parties with favor. Or did you mean - "I have no knowledge of US politics and have no opinion of these politicians"
- randomdata 12y agoI take "political bias" to mean "how will this affect me". Even someone with some understanding of US politics will typically not be able to immediately understand the worldwide implications of a certain leader over another. For example, take a platform of cutting taxes: How is that going to affect a random guy who lives in Australia? I suppose some people can say "I'm a democrat and will always vote democrat", but don't I follow that kind of thinking. I think I've voted for almost every party in my country at one time or another, depending on who I feel is best suited for representation at that time.
- girvo 12y agoI have knowledge, and opinions, but like I said: no allegiance. I feel partisanship is pointless, and because I have zero influence on US politics, I remain on the sidelines observing rather than leaning one way or another.