4 ms·
After lurking on the discussions@password-hashing.net, the Password Hashing Competition's mailing list the last several months, I can say I am initially skeptic
by zaroth 12y ago
After lurking on the discussions@password-hashing.net, the Password Hashing Competition's mailing list the last several months, I can say I am initially skeptical of this.
One of the primary concerns for PHC was making an algorithm which is hard to speed up on custom hardware. Bill Cox, Solar Designer, et al. went at this very hard, and I think their approach will turn out to be favored.
I'm a little bit concerned that if the algorithm is now flexible enough, to not be implemented efficiently in a more generalized circuit, then is it flexible enough to behave possibly erratically?
But I'm not even sure if this GSHA type algorithm really would be all that difficult to implement in an ASIC.
Of course, the great thing is that an algorithm promising such benefits is in high demand, Proof-of-Work algorithms, and so anything which shows merit will probably be explored and tested.
- SAI_Peregrinus 12y agoIt certainly seems like he hasn't heard of a barrel shifter. That alone would make this pretty damn easy to implement in an ASIC. It's also assuming that the constants don't matter for the security of the hash function. They do.
- johnwhitech 12y agoAgreed, I'm not sure it's a good idea to change the # of shifts or any other constants. They are/should be optimized so Differential and Linear properties are minimal over the whole cipher, which is certainly a non-trivial optimization.