3 ms·
Wouldn't you look negatively at a job applicant who eschewed doing things he didn't particularly want to do? What about those that had no time to do? There are
by untog 12y ago
Wouldn't you look negatively at a job applicant who eschewed doing things he didn't particularly want to do?
What about those that had no time to do? There are very bright kids out there that have to cook dinner when they get home. Or babysit their younger siblings. Or any and all of the above. Basically, the system rewards those who have the opportunity to do more, not the desire to.
- WalterBright 12y agoThat's true. I'd like to hear a plan for accurately admitting those with certain attributes that exhibit no signs of them whatsoever, because I can't think of one.
- judk 12y agoIn the absence of quality evidence, randomness is better than prejudicial bias.
- xenadu02 12y agoIn a way, randomness would be preferable because those with ability (who otherwise wouldn't meet the criteria or pass the tests) would get a chance to succeed. The ones that flunk out would make room for some more random attempts. Eventually the system would settle into a steady-state of X% of previously-found high performers and Y% of ever-rotating randoms, where occasionally one of the randoms moves into the high-performers group. This stuff also continues to reinforce and highlight how arbitrary and capricious success often is; many people are successful as much for their family/money/connections/opportunities as for their actual talent.