2 ms·
The article splits into two streams on the "God Complex" subject and fails to address them separately, which would be the proper treatment. There's the god com
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
The article splits into two streams on the "God Complex" subject and fails to address them separately, which would be the proper treatment.
There's the god complex of thinking that your latest social-mobile-local disrupt-a-service-industry start-up is world-changingly important and entitles you to be a douchebag to everyone else around you. Yeah, that's just hubris; I say "just" hubris because if you go around thinking like that, the business cycle can and will punish you for your overly inflated view of yourself. It is a temporary inconvenience but an eventually self-correcting problem. The rest of us just have to keep our money in index funds long enough to remain solvent until the markets stop being irrational.
(Mind, so far the markets have actually behaved rationally, as technological innovation is cheaper when capital is cheaper, and when there's no place else for capital to go for high returns, it floods into low-impact consumer technology for socially suboptimal but economically rational reasons. Anyway!)
And then there's the god complex in which we are actually playing God. You know: genetic engineering, pervasive surveillance, greenhouse-gas emissions, automation destroying jobs, anything and everything to which the adjective "transhuman" can be attached, all that stuff. In an economically "ironic" way, most of these require both massively more capital investment to work than VCs are prepared to part with at once, but all stand to have utterly massive historical impacts. Also, these are real technologies, not consumerist gimmicks: the markets will not automatically punish us for spreading Roundup Ready genes across a continent's worth of crops or building a human-unfriendly artificial general intelligence. We will merely suffer the natural consequences of our own actions.
So in the first category, we in the tech industry are hubristic and irresponsible if we believe ourselves godlike, while in the second category we are hubristic and irresponsible if we believe ourselves mere mortals. We ought to remember that Oppenheimer, too, was a mere mortal.