5 ms·
Self-Discipline Outdoes IQ in Predicting Academic Performance of Adolescents
- btilly 17y agoNo surprise at all. I'm reminded of the famous marshmallow test: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/05/18/090518fa_fact_lehrer http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/05/18/090518fa_fact_... The executive summary is that children's ability to delay gratification at age 4 was one of the best predictors of future academic success decades later.
- krakensden 17y agoAnyone who's participated in academics /should/ know this intuitively- but people seem to really, really want to believe that academic performance and intelligence are the same thing. It would certainly make hiring easier.
- Dilpil 17y agoBut then again, would we rather hire people with extraordinary IQ or extraordinary self discipline?
- pchristensen 17y agoIs that a trick question?
- skolor 17y agoThen again, the question is also: Do you really want to hire people who do exceptionally in Academics? From my experience, you will very often see a very intelligent student blow off tests and homework, only to do average in the class, despite having easily picked up the concepts. On the other hand, you'll see someone with average intelligence (or slightly above average, but nothing remarkable) get straight A's because they spend hours every night studying. Personally, I would rather have the intelligent person who may get sidetracked easier, but is able to pick up new concepts easily than a extremely disciplined person who may take 3 times as long to learn new concepts. I like to think of the intelligent, non-disciplined person as someone whose time to complete a task has very high variance, but averages low, and a highly disciplined, average intelligence person as someone whose time to completion has very low variance, but a higher (possibly considerably higher) average.
- DannoHung 17y agoOnly takes one completely blown off task to ruin the brilliant ADHDer's average though.
- tokenadult 17y agoDo you really want to hire people who do exceptionally in Academics? I think that is a good question variant. I would definitely want to hire someone who is a) smart (as demonstrated by something I can observe) and b) self-disciplined (ditto). I might or might not care about a job applicant's school grades, depending on where the applicant went to school, what I'm hiring for, what the applicant's accomplishments outside of school are, and so on. In most real-world hiring situations, it is hard to find an applicant who is at the top of the heap in all hiring criteria, so one must make trade-offs. My own taste runs less to regarding school grades as a good sign than to giving applicants work-sample tests, but I tell my children that many hiring processes give very high regard to school grades, so that it is expedient to work to get good grades.
- tilly 17y agoThe answer depends entirely on the job role. For instance a QA person needs attention to detail which is far more likely to be found in the academically successful person. But a senior software developer needs flashes of brilliance that you're only going to find in the intelligent person. Best, of course, is someone who is good at both. But they tend to be rare.
- scott_s 17y agoAnd in my experience, "picking up the concepts" isn't enough. The learning that matters happens in the doing.
- puffythefish 17y agoBesides, a student blowing off tests and homework may not be less disciplined at all, they may just be working much harder on other things.
- bayleo 17y agoPut me down for a few of both, please.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- webwright 17y agoSo, to turn this around... Google hires primarily for self-discipline, not intelligence? I can certainly see why discipline would be important for the majority of your team-- but I've always wonder how many geniuses Google passes on because they don't fit this mold.
- pchristensen 17y agoThis is something that's painfully obvious now but would have been considered blasphemy if you told me when I was an adolescent.
- warwick 17y agoThey did tell me this when I was an teenager: "You're a smart kid, but you need to put in more effort". I tried putting effort towards school for a while. I figured if I had to play, I may as well win. The problem with treating high school as a game is that it's not fun. Learning the material doesn't get you anything, not even more advanced material to dig into. For me, digging my teeth into a difficult problem is it's own reward. In high school I wasn't asked to work on difficult problems. Instead I sat in the back of the class, ignored the lecture, worked on whatever I was doing at the time, and coasted through the tests well enough to pass. Plenty of effort. Plenty of work ethic. Plenty of smarts. Nothing I wanted to work on.
- sp332 17y agoIt's not about effort, it's about self-control. If you had been able to make yourself work on the class assignments, even if you didn't like them, you would have better grades.
- jibiki 17y agoIf you had been able to make yourself work on chess problems, even if you didn't like them, you would have been better at chess.
- radu_floricica 17y agoYeah, they told me too. I wish I'd have seen this paper... though I might not have taken it seriously enough. But still, it's probably better then some old guy who pesters you to work more without any obvious reason.
- GHFigs 17y agoIndeed. For those of us raised in the heyday of the tragicallly misguided self-esteem movement, studies like this are vindicating.
- aidenn0 17y agoI'm with everyone else in not being at all surprised. Maybe that's because of the fact that as an adolescent, I had a high-IQ, low self-discipline, and a low GPA.
- TheElder 17y agoI'm curious. How did you know your IQ? Did your parents have you tested?
- tokenadult 17y agoNoted for factual reference here is that almost no one gets the same IQ score twice, if tested more than once, so it can be a little bit better to say, "My IQ score when I was tested at [age] on [brand of test]" rather than to say "My IQ." That said, there is a known phenomenon in the literature on education of gifted students of high-IQ young people being bored with school because it is underchallenging and getting poor grades. That is inexpedient, but I definitely saw it happen in my generation and I have seen it happen in the current generation.
- scott_s 17y agoCuriously, I've heard the opposite. A friend who went through a Master's program in education relayed something his special education professor said: "I don't know what IQ tests measure, but they do it precisely."
- tokenadult 17y agoA friend who went through a Master's program in education relayed something his special education professor said: "I don't know what IQ tests measure, but they do it precisely." I haven't met the friend or his professor, but either something has been lost in relating the saying, or a different issue is being addressed. The best literature on IQ testing http://learninfreedom.org/iqbooks.html http://learninfreedom.org/iqbooks.html would make any practitioner aware that there is an error band around ANY mental test score from any brand of mental test, and also that IQ scores change over the course of life for most individuals, and anyway no IQ test has even perfect test-retest reliability, much less perfect correlation with any other IQ test.
- anonjon 17y agoduh.
- mmt 17y agoHear hear. The title is pretty much true by definition, since the traditional "factory" education system is so highly structured. Intelligence, OTOH, could be construed as an adaptation to an unstructured, real world.
- anonjon 17y agoIn fact, the paper proves itself recursively. People who have achieved a high level in academia putting a lot of effort into a study that proves that people who achieve highly in academia have a lot of self discipline (i.e. put in a lot of effort). Clearly they don't have a high level of intelligence as if they did, they would have figured out (having put in a bit more thought and a bit less effort), like you and I, that the educational system is obviously like this. Or maybe we just are differently efforted
- doki_pen 17y agoCome now. High School curriculum doesn't require much intelligence. Most of it is just completing brain dead assignments. It would be interesting to compare the results to something much more challenging.
- ssn 17y agoLet's see if you can spend a day without visiting HN... :->
- queensnake 17y agoChinese' success is an example: http://www.amazon.com/Asian-Americans-Achievement-Beyond-Iq/dp/0805811109 http://www.amazon.com/Asian-Americans-Achievement-Beyond-Iq/... Note that Flynn (yes, that one) is no racist.
- mattmcknight 17y ago"the only one among 32 measured personality variables (e.g., self-esteem, extraversion, energy level) that predicted college grade point average (GPA) more robustly than SAT scores did." Is college GPA really indicative of anything? Probably more so than high school GPA, but given the wide variance in difficulty, perhaps high GPA people are simply the people that choose to do things that are easy...
- TheElder 17y agoI think of myself as having average or even low IQ. Some background: I was partially raised in government housing as a child, had parents who were drug and alcohol abusers, and was never encouraged to do anything intellectually stimulating while growing up. I lived in a poor mixed raced city and attended a mostly nonwhite high school. Learning was never a concern of mine while in high school, not getting my face smashed in was (which happened). I was not in an environment for intellectual growth, nor was I in an environment that would have indicators of high IQ. Through pure luck, I had a high school teacher that somewhat set me on the right course. For half a day, two years long, I had this teacher for a CAD class. He told me attitude was everything and encouraged me to enroll in college. My first two years weren't great. I struggled in classes like algebra. I also didn't know how to study. After two years of getting nowhere, I moved to a large US city as a result of certain life circumstances. I finished up my undergraduate degree and took a year off. I didn't feel very happy though. I wanted to get a graduate degree. My company was willing to pay for it, as long as I worked 40 hours a week and made good grades. It was a complete change for me, kind of a fresh start. I decided I would take the university serious. Because my undergrad wasn't computer science, I had to complete all of the undergrad computer science courses. So I had at least four years ahead of me to get my masters. Only because I worked really hard and studied a lot, I would often be the top performer in my 3 calculus classes, discrete math, and so on (this wasn't always the case... but hey, I was working a full-time job too). I ended up with a masters in computer science, something I never thought was possible for me. Something that inspired me was that I'd see the international students (mostly east Asian and Indian) study very hard. They would study all day long in the library. They seemed like the very definition of self-discipline. I adapted to that the best I could while still working 40 hours per week doing .net programming. It seems like I fit the premise of this paper and can relate: Low to average IQ who often did better than my higher IQ classmates and friends.
- bokonist 17y agoI think of myself as having average or even low IQ. I'm curious. Did you actually know for sure that your IQ score was below average? ( or the score from similar type of test, like the SAT). It would be interesting counterpoint to the validity of IQ/SAT testing if you actually tested below average, and then ended up in a career that requires much greater than average cognitive skills.
- David 17y agoOh, irony. I'm at work, right now. Reading this instead of actually working. Think I can successfully rationalize this as a focus-enhancing short term break instead of a lack of self-discipline?
- pg 17y agoThough I'm a big fan of self-discipline, I worry this study tells us more about eighth grade than human nature.
- gwern 17y agoReading that, and the other article on grades, suddenly something clicked: what if the reason that getting rid of tracking (separate classes for high & low achievers) in schools hurts the upper end of students is because when they are competing against all the poor & mediocre students they no longer need to try very hard, and so they lose practice in self-discipline?
- icono 17y agoThe article should be renamed to Parental Guidance and Aptitude Outdoes IQ. There's are a lot of "smart" people out there who are the result of very fortunate parenting rather than actually possessing any intelligence.