3 ms·

It seems they copied AWS S3 too well, including its "feature" of going down every now and then and it's overall lack of reliability. Nice!

ollyculverhouse 12y ago
We have used S3 for over 3 years with no issues at all. Care to divulge?
leorocky 12y ago
I've never seen S3 go down, the availability is 5 9's. EC2 has had outages in the past.
- justinsb 12y ago
  S3 went down in 2008 for a few hours. Lots of coverage at the time. e.g. http://techcrunch.com/2008/02/15/amazon-web-services-goes-down-takes-many-startup-sites-with-it/ http://techcrunch.com/2008/02/15/amazon-web-services-goes-do...
  - acdha 12y ago
    A couple hours for one location in 6 years is hardly the routine occurrence which the original commenter was claiming
    - justinsb 12y ago
      I wasn't saying it was, merely reporting the facts! S3 targets four nines uptime; which is really good but not infallible. For most apps though, I think it's reasonable to accept that if S3 is offline, the app is offline also.
  - tedchs 12y ago
    All of AWS has changed significantly in the past 6 years. I think it's disingenuous to say that an outage from that era, for any provider, influences your thinking nowadays.
    - justinsb 12y ago
      I'm not sure S3 has changed nearly as much as the rest of AWS, which is probably why it is so stable. Regardless, the point is that outages can happen to S3 as well, and have; just because it hasn't happened for a few years doesn't mean than 99.99% = 100%.
      - noir_lord 12y ago
        In fairness high availability is usually measure per annum, on that metric S3 is 100% for the last 5 years. Also a few years doesn't really imply 6 years to me.
ytjohn 12y ago
That's true commitment.
thezach 12y ago
I've only had very minimal issues with S3... one of the things thats holding me back from switching to a cheaper provider from Amazon is if its not broke, don't fix it.
- zimbatm 12y ago
  Individual blob access is not very reliable on S3. In a previous company uploading big-ish (1-10000MB) files was part of the service. We would see failing uploads or slow writes all the time. Make sure to queue and wrap your upload script with retries.

ollyculverhouse 12y ago

We have used S3 for over 3 years with no issues at all. Care to divulge?

leorocky 12y ago

I've never seen S3 go down, the availability is 5 9's. EC2 has had outages in the past.

justinsb 12y ago
S3 went down in 2008 for a few hours. Lots of coverage at the time. e.g. http://techcrunch.com/2008/02/15/amazon-web-services-goes-down-takes-many-startup-sites-with-it/ http://techcrunch.com/2008/02/15/amazon-web-services-goes-do...
- acdha 12y ago
  A couple hours for one location in 6 years is hardly the routine occurrence which the original commenter was claiming
  - justinsb 12y ago
    I wasn't saying it was, merely reporting the facts! S3 targets four nines uptime; which is really good but not infallible. For most apps though, I think it's reasonable to accept that if S3 is offline, the app is offline also.
- tedchs 12y ago
  All of AWS has changed significantly in the past 6 years. I think it's disingenuous to say that an outage from that era, for any provider, influences your thinking nowadays.
  - justinsb 12y ago
    I'm not sure S3 has changed nearly as much as the rest of AWS, which is probably why it is so stable. Regardless, the point is that outages can happen to S3 as well, and have; just because it hasn't happened for a few years doesn't mean than 99.99% = 100%.
    - noir_lord 12y ago
      In fairness high availability is usually measure per annum, on that metric S3 is 100% for the last 5 years. Also a few years doesn't really imply 6 years to me.

ytjohn 12y ago

That's true commitment.

thezach 12y ago

I've only had very minimal issues with S3... one of the things thats holding me back from switching to a cheaper provider from Amazon is if its not broke, don't fix it.

zimbatm 12y ago
Individual blob access is not very reliable on S3. In a previous company uploading big-ish (1-10000MB) files was part of the service. We would see failing uploads or slow writes all the time. Make sure to queue and wrap your upload script with retries.