3 ms·
> The tragedy of the commons can only be avoided by changing the rules of the market through an external force (lawmaking) so participants must act altruistical
by pdonis 12y ago
> The tragedy of the commons can only be avoided by changing the rules of the market through an external force (lawmaking) so participants must act altruistically to act selfishly.
You're assuming that the external force will somehow make the "right" rules, the ones that actually fix the problems with the market and force participants to find Pareto optimal outcomes. Experience suggests that this is not the case; what actually happens is that the external force that makes the rules gets co-opted by some of the market participants, and you end up with worse outcomes (i.e., further from being Pareto optimal) because the concentration of power in the external force (the government) makes it easier to corrupt. Look up "regulatory capture".
> The concentration of resources is typically avoided through wealth redistribution, another mechanism of mandatory altruism.
Again, you're assuming that whoever redistributes the wealth will do so in a way that gets closer to a Pareto optimal outcome. Experience suggests that this is not the case; what actually happens is that the rules for redistribution get co-opted by some of the market participants, so you end up with a worse distribution of wealth. When the economy tanked in 2008, wealth got redistributed, by the government, to the banks that had caused the collapse, not to the people who lost their homes and their retirement savings.
- waps 12y agoWell add to that that you're assuming that "right" rules that are pareto efficient 1) exist 2) are significantly different from capitalism All non-trivial pareto efficient rulesets I've ever seen involve some form of revenue sharing between both parties. Given what pareto-efficiency is, I think this may be a general property. Obviously somehow both parties need to be bound together for pareto efficiency to happen. Money's one way to do it, and I don't know that many others.