3 ms·
> I've edited my OP to reflect that sentence, and I agree that it's a reasonable criterion. However, it's a much less stringent requirement than what's usually
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
> I've edited my OP to reflect that sentence, and I agree that it's a reasonable criterion. However, it's a much less stringent requirement than what's usually present in a cable company franchise agreement.
Certainly true, but that then raises the reasonable question of whether that requirement should exist. (Also, the more relevant agreements here seem like those applying to ISPs, not cable companies. Cable is not an essential service, and even if it were, universal coverage is better handled by an antenna.)
> Cable companies generally must serve every neighborhood above a certain density, whether or not there are enough interested subscribers.
Such a requirement would make more sense 1) if an area has no existing service provider, and people would otherwise have no option for service at all, which obviously doesn't apply here; and more importantly 2) if applied to an essential service like phone rather than an utterly optional one like television.
> And by law they are usually required to provide a minimum tier of service, usually at around $15-20 per month.
As others have pointed out, the cheapest plan is $25/month. Even if it weren't, the two requirements only make sense if coupled together: there's no sense in forcing deployment to neighborhoods where nobody can pay $70/month, so unless you're also restricting prices, a coverage requirement makes no sense.
On top of that, if trying to solve the problem of universal Internet connectivity, I half wonder if cell service might be the more viable alternative: rather than building an entire fiber network in a neighborhood so that a small fraction of households can get Internet access who otherwise wouldn't have, cell service (even subsidized) would cost far less, and would handle telephone as well.
Alternatively, open wifi networks (such as those discussed in the article) would serve much the same purpose.
> This is precisely what traditional franchise agreements prevent, and precisely why they have the effect of keeping out competition. Only the incumbent can commit to that sort of requirement profitably.
Exactly. If you're going from zero providers to one, your biggest problem might be how to get coverage to everyone. Right now, however, we have a huge problem with lack of competition, which gives the one viable provider in an area an effective monopoly, and all the problems that go along with it. Thus, we need to stop imposing restrictions that preserve that monopoly.
- rayiner 12y agoI think you're misunderstanding the posture of my post. I don't think we should hold fiber deployment hostage in the name of universal service. All of the points that you're making, that "there's no sense in forcing deployment to neighborhoods where nobody can pay $70/month" are absolutely correct. To the extent that universal service is important, I agree with you that cellular is the answer. BUT: the fact remains, that these requirements are almost universally a part of cable franchise agreements. Municipal governance in American cities is a state of constant class warfare, and the idea that a high-end internet provider should only expand to neighborhoods where people can afford the service is politically toxic: http://www.speedmatters.org/blog/archive/philadelphia-and-nj-to-verizon-build-out-fios http://www.speedmatters.org/blog/archive/philadelphia-and-nj... ("As Philadelphia councilman Jim Kenney told local TV, 'We were happy to have competition with our current major cable provider, Comcast. But we want to make sure that every neighborhood in the city is getting built out with the FiOS, and not just neighborhoods that can afford to pay the fees.'") Google, by setting a precedent of refusing to agree to such requirements, is doing everyone a huge favor.