4 ms·
The author makes some big statements about what Elon is doing and then wonders why everyone isn't guzzling the kool-aid like the author. It has nothing to do wi
by hueving 12y ago
The author makes some big statements about what Elon is doing and then wonders why everyone isn't guzzling the kool-aid like the author. It has nothing to do with the prisoners dilemma.
First, there is a large portion of the population that doesn't believe global warming is an issue.
Second, there is another large population that doesn't believe global warming can be stopped by a slow transition to electric cars.
Third, there is a large majority of the population that can't afford a 90k luxury car so they fail to see how Tesla will revolutionize the world. This is compacted by the fact that the batteries will need to be replaced in 6-10 years and it will likely cost 20k+. These cars are out of reach for the majority of Americans it's not really going to reduce CO2 output by anything significant enough in time to matter.
Fourth, Elon made a fat stack of cash selling PayPal to Ebay. With that being his primary historical success story, it doesn't make it sound like he is doing just what is optimal for humanity. SpaceX is great for space exploration, but that's not really optimal for humanity considering our current problems.
The article had a nice write up on pareto optimal solutions and the prisoner's dilemma but they are completely irrelevant to the skepticism observed here.
- avz 12y agoYou've alluded to "things which are optimal for humanity" and "our current problems". Could you elaborate? What do you think is optimal for humanity? Which current problems are more significant than planetary-level challenges like global warming and confinement of our specifies to a single planet? These put the existence of our civilization at risk. I would really love to hear which other problems are more significant than those.
- hueving 12y agoCut the melodrama. Your post reeks of first-world privilege. Confinement of our species to a single planet is much lower priority than the suffering caused by violent governments, starvation, diseases, and drug problems. Colonizing another planet might be optimal for spreading of our species, but it does little to reduce the suffering here. Global warming is a problem. However, making luxury electric cars is a drop in the bucket compared to convincing China and India to crack down on things like unfiltered coal power plants.
- avz 12y agoIt'd be great if we could first make everyone on this planet happy and then move on to the next one, but it's just not going to work that way. Long tail of human unhappiness will be very hard to eliminate. Your mix of problems is highly heterogeneous. Starvation and diseases are serious challenges we have in fact been making a lot of progress on. However, they pose more limited and localized danger than global warming or planetary confinement and so must be given a lower priority. Violent governments and drug problems are political and so out of scope. Gating space exploration on all politician playing nice and all people staying clean and sober is the best way to doom the project. Making electric, environment friendly cars be perceived as luxury and something one can aspire to is a small step in the right direction. Also, they're luxury because the technology is expensive. Cells phone began as luxury product, too. Eventually, they'll become mainstream.
- hueving 12y agoViolence and starvation are not a 'long tail' of human happiness. The market that can afford Teslas is much further down the tail than people subject to these problems.
- jacquesm 12y agoI really don't think that Elon selling his paypal stake to Ebay is his primary success story. SpaceX and Tesla are much bigger stories, and they are an ongoing affair. The only reason you can make the statement you made is because you added 'historical', but what use is that if it is only used to eliminate the present which is by far the more interesting portion.
- hueving 12y ago"historical success story". I meant one that has played out.
- jacquesm 12y agoElons success story will play out when he's dead. Until then it does not look like he will stop. The only reason why PayPal is no longer a concern of his and which allows us to call it 'history' is because as far as he was concerned it brought what it could so it was time to move on. And move on he did. The only two ways the others can 'play out' is by failing or succeeding. For SpaceX to succeed means a totally different thing to Elon musk than to you or I, for him success is not to make money but to put foot on Mars. Tesla is a sideshow (but an important one at that), with much more impact than PayPal or Ebay. If Tesla 'succeeds' that will likely mean that it will own a substantial portion of the car market at some point (imagine a budget tesla within 5 to 10 years), if it fails the only thing that I can imagine would be a total shut-down or being bought out to stop it from folding. Effectively the whole patent thing is a very interesting approach to this problem, it says 'we will not be bought at any point'. I'm not one of the 'gushing fanboys', I just look on in total amazement at what one guy with sufficient drive can accomplish and I'm just as amazed at how many people are ready to trip him up. The least the naysayers could do is shut up and wait it out, in the meantime, Musk is going places and PayPal appears to have been (with our present knowledge) but a small step on the way. One thing is already fairly sure at this point, Elon Musk's name will be one that will very likely be part of the history books, whether as business tycoon, first man to set foot on Mars (or die on Mars) or as the man who tried to change the world for the better but failed remains to be seen. Regardless, it will likely be in a very positive light, all creativity with no destruction is a worthwhile attitude.
- Shivetya 12y agoExactly, it not within the expectations we have with Musk. Hence why would people not question the motive or gesture?
- prawn 12y ago"These cars are out of reach for the majority of Americans" - I don't think these are the last, cheapest, most efficient and advanced cars that Tesla plan to build...
- abruzzi 12y agoPerhaps, but I fear that even if you build a $18k electric car, you will still have a hard time getting a lot of people on board due to the limited lifespan and high replacement cost of batteries (at the moment at least). I've never paid more than $5k for a car, and I see a lot of people in my (pretty poor) state driving $1k clunkers. My current car is 18 years old, meaning if electric it would be nearing the end of the useful life of the second set of batteries. ICEs well maintained, can have a very long lifespan. I'm not saying that these issues can't be overcome, but I think it will be a much longer time before these types of vehicles trickle down to the lower 50% of the US customers, let alone, poorer nations, given that the current state of electric cars doesn't even begin to meet the needs of many people in the less dense parts of flyover country (yes range!)