3 ms·
These coins should be removed from the blockchain in a protocol update agreed upon by everyone. No government should be making money this way.
by sschueller 12y ago
These coins should be removed from the blockchain in a protocol update agreed upon by everyone.
No government should be making money this way.
- baq 12y agoso it's perfectly fair to profit from selling drugs that kill people, but when the profits from illegal activity are seized, the public shouldn't be able to reuse them?
- rplnt 12y agoPlease entertain me how drugs sold on SR kill people.
- scrollaway 12y agoPretty sure OP meant tobacco and alcohol. The government doesn't tax SR.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 12y agoBrilliant precendent you're trying to set here Einstein.
- sschueller 12y agoWhat's with the hostile response and name calling? If you don't agree with me you can write a constructive response.
- scrollaway 12y agoI can see how you would take it as hostile but it was not meant to be. However, trying to set a precedent on "Let's agree that this money should vanish because we all don't like where it currently is" turns into "I'm a core developer and my wife just left me so I'm just going to ruin her" in relatively few steps. What you are suggesting would be a centralized backdoor in a decentralized protocol.
- thesimpsons1022 12y agohonestly, that would make me lose all trust in bitcoin as well. if they can just retroactively delete coins that certain people have. (not to mention for political reasons). imagine the implications of a government gaining tang type of power.
- pron 12y agoHere's a constructive response: We come together as a society and agree on some rules. Some people break the rules, (and they also withhold money that rightly belong to the community), so the rules say that in that event we take their money and dispense it for the greater good.
- artursapek 12y ago// TODO: remove after FBI auction
- steven777400 12y agoThis has been proposed before in other situations. For example, the Mt. Gox coins were proposed to either be "destroyed" or sent back to their purchasers with a blockchain update. This introduces serious problems with the question of "who is everyone" (when you say, agreed upon by everyone). In other words, is the community going to set up a centralized board to hear complaints and reverse transactions? Does this turn into "I bought a trinket on ebay and the guy didn't send me the thing, reverse the transaction"? Part of the strength of bitcoin is a permanent historical record. There's been some suggestion that the true long-term benefit of bitcoin is not in the "money" part, but the blockchain itself. As soon as the blockchain becomes mutable, then this value becomes suspect, and the line for "how bad does it have to be before we edit the blockchain" might get weaker and weaker.