3 ms·
"Given the very few fossils of the australopith face, I am not optimistic that evidence of…" That is the primary reason you shouldn't put much faith in anythin
by Someone 12y ago
"Given the very few fossils of the australopith face, I am not optimistic that evidence of…"
That is the primary reason you shouldn't put much faith in anything you read about most early humanoids, especially not the parts that reach general audiences. We simply cannot know much from the samples we have. Yet, scientists feel the pressure of having to publish, and cannot just publish new measurements, so they hypothise away.
This, like many in the field, mostly is a "we cannot rule out that" paper; all evidence is circumstantial. It may be truly insightful or it may not be, but we simply cannot know at the moment.
Can we blame the scientists? No, but I wished we educated fewer in this field and/or told those working in the field "feel free to think, study and experiment for a few decades and publish something when you are certain you have a convincing argument"
On the other hand, it is intriguing to read about the latest ideas in the field, just like it is to read about our new thinking about dinosaurs, even if experience tells us our ideas about both will swing heavily (in a few decades, what color will dinosaurs be? Will they be warm-blooded? Will all of them have feathers?)
- gohrt 12y agoThere's nothing wrong with publishing new theoretically plausible ideas. They just need to be properly qualified.