4 ms·
It would be funnier if the bitcoin exchanges blocked those blockchains as having been permanently compromised. It would prevent the feds from having an incenti
by bsder 12y ago
It would be funnier if the bitcoin exchanges blocked those blockchains as having been permanently compromised.
It would prevent the feds from having an incentive to seize bitcoins.
- leorocky 12y ago> It would prevent the feds from having an incentive to seize bitcoins. No it wouldn't. Law enforcement seizes to deprive criminals of gain from illicit activities, not to make a profit. They sell because they can. It also wouldn't be funny. The US Marshall's service is doing what it is supposed to. If you have problems with federal law enforcement try a country that lacks a professional police force.
- ansimionescu 12y agoI find it hilarious that someone had to explain this.
- saraid216 12y agoIt's Hacker News and the government is involved. Of course it needed to be explained.
- mfisher87 12y ago> If you have problem with federal law enforcement try a country that lacks a professional police force. Genius statements like these are why I read HN!
- qq66 12y agoPlenty of law enforcement organizations seize money to make a profit, with very little regard to whether the owners are criminals or whether the money is the fruit of illicit activities: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2013/08/12/130812fa_fact_stillman http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2013/08/12/130812fa_fact_...
- praxeologist 12y agoDoubt it, but I would love for it to happen. I see this as criminal theft by the USMS.
- dylz 12y agoIt is not theft, it is sale of abandoned property as they offered for people to claim their BTC and no one did.
- praxeologist 12y agoWasn't the bulk of this money from drug dealers/buyers and not DPR? "Hello, US Marshals I would like the bitcoins I got from moving tons of drugs." Downvote all you want but you don't seem that sharp.
- VMG 12y agoThat's a sword that cuts both ways. If you infrastructure for that kind of filtering became pervasive, you can be sure that government would be dictating which coins (transaction outputs) are compromised and which are clean. Luckily a fork of Bitcoin that included these filter mechanism is unlikely to succeed. Let's keep law enforcement on a separate layer, we didn't put it into TCP either.
- drdeca 12y agoWouldn't this just be the particular exchange making the decision though? Just, the exchange voluntarily deciding whether or not to accept the trade? Or did they mean that if the coins were tracked regardless of who they were passed to or through how many people? I don't see how a person deciding not to trade with a given address(govt), or any address that traded directly with that address(person who bought from govt), is creating any sort of infrastructure. It could be worked around with by additional transfers of course, or just used directly to purchase things, But in at least one similar type of thing I don't think it would inherently cause or require any harmful infrastructure/modification to infrastructure, even if it would be pointless.