3 ms·
> Boxing was developed specifically to get around the many problems with punching: protecting the hands from being broken, and developing defensive strategies t
by baddox 12y ago
> Boxing was developed specifically to get around the many problems with punching: protecting the hands from being broken, and developing defensive strategies to avoid blows from even padded fists.
Perhaps that's true, but isn't it also true that fisticuffs were a "natural" way for impromptu humans fights? I highly doubt that boxing was the first invention of fighting by standing up and punching the other person. It seems more likely that human already tended to fight that way when genuinely angry at each other, and as people began to be interested in fighting prowess, the protective rules of boxing were developed to allow experts to fight for longer.
And, like in any discussion regarding evolution, it's important to point out that phrases like "if hands were for punching" are dangerously close to being deceptive because of the implied attribution of purpose to the evolutionary process.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoYes, fisticuffs were common for impromptu human fights. But the stuff with evolutionary implications usually resulted from ambushes: People hiding in the bushes with sticks and stones, waiting for one and his buddies to walk by. Or just hitting him over the head with a rock while he slept. Forager societies more closely resemble middle school than modern life. In modern life, you can get in a fight at the bar and not see the person you lost to for weeks - if ever. In middle school, you lose a fight and you have to see that person every day for the rest of your life - unless you skip town (leave the tribe) - which appears to have been somewhat common. Thus any fisticuffs victory will be hollow, as the loser can simply murder you one day when you least expect it.
- aResponder52 12y agoYou guys know that the type of fight that goes like "guys get angry, guys punch each other a few times" aren't always the same as "guys get angry, one guy kills the other"? I'm not one for hypothesizing based on hunches that look evolutionarily plausible, but, given that for a long time humans lived to 20, 25 years old, consider the types of fights teenagers and kids get into these days. A few punches, somebody (or both people) loses with some bruises, nobody dies, nobody gets seriously hurt. We're comparing those types of fights with murders here. Apples to oranges.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoWhich type of fight has greater implications for the evolution of human facial bone structure?
- svachalek 12y agoIn my school years, there were quite a few "impromptu" fights. For whatever reasons my school system was pretty ineffective at stopping them. I ended up in dozens if not hundreds. They pretty much always go the same way -- punch thrown, usually dodged or blocked but sometimes connecting for quite a bit of pain. Followed by lots of wrestling.