5 ms·
Not at all. Occupy was political. Individual police departments cracking down on political dissent is problematic. But when the federal government does it, fede
by wpietri 12y ago
Not at all. Occupy was political. Individual police departments cracking down on political dissent is problematic. But when the federal government does it, federal powers make it much more significant. And when you see those folks all working with private security to suppress political dissent, it's deeply problematic.
That's especially true given that the feds have a history of illegal surveillance of (and even interference with) political activity that powerful people happened to find uncomfortable: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO
- mseebach 12y ago> Not at all. Occupy was political. Individual police departments cracking down on political dissent is problematic. The fact that your motivation is political does not provide a license to break the law, and you must expect a response from law enforcement if you do so.
- sp332 12y agoThe FBI offering offering to kill protestors for banks is not a response from law enforcement I would expect.
- wpietri 12y agoI agree that political protest doesn't provide a license to do absolutely anything. But when laws are selectively enforced against people with particular political views because of their views, that's a big deal to me regardless of the views. Because of that, I believe that political activity should be given relatively wide latitude for anything that is basically related to freedom of speech or freedom of assembly. For example, here in San Francisco, a person blocking traffic for the hell of it might get ticketed for jaywalking. But if a group of protestors takes to the streets, the police will just direct traffic around it and keep an eye on it as long as it stays peaceful. And I think that's about right.
- GHFigs 12y ago"Cracking down" is a gross exaggeration of what the documents actually describe. Naomi Wolf's column is essentially blogspam of a press release by the "Partnership for Civil Justice Fund", which cherry-picks and sexes-up excerpts from the pretty dull documents they got through a FOIA request. It's nowhere near COINTELPRO. It's documentation of exactly the kind of mundane police work you would expect to be associated with a nation-wide protest movement.
- tedks 12y ago...why would I expect police work to be associated with protests? That is something I would expect, as the grandparent indicates, in the USSR. I don't expect it in the United States.
- GHFigs 12y agoThat's bullshit, though. Mass gatherings of any kind are a public safety issue, and an organized nation-wide protest with anarchist overtones is hardly the least likely to result in violence and property damage. For police to not gather and share information on what to expect would be stupid. You may get tons of warm fuzzies thinking about OWS, but it still involved thousands of angry people gathering in one place, which is not something any reasonable person expects the police to be wholly ignorant of. See Also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupy_Oakland#Protestor_conduct_and_controversies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupy_Oakland#Protestor_conduc...
- tedks 12y agoSimilarily, Westboro Baptist Church protests are public safety issues, because they provoke large angry gatherings. How does the FBI handle that? Do they collaborate with corporations and local police departments to systematically discredit, propagandize against, and wage psychological warfare against the WBC? Or do they do striaghtforward police work, provide a detail of officers at protests and counterprotests just in case anything gets out of hand, and generally behave reasonably? There is a very far divide between "wholly ignorant" and "actively subverting." There is also a far divide between that and "sharing information on what to expect." See also: undercover police excesses in the UK and US, including having children with activists to maintain cover.