4 ms·
Do HNers have an opinion about Qi versus PowerMat?
by jessriedel 12y ago
Do HNers have an opinion about Qi versus PowerMat?
- crashandburn4 12y agoI have nothing other than personal lock-in (nexus 5) to Qi. that being said, I don't know if there are any phones that have powermat integrated, does anyone know of any?
- nodata 12y agoI know a fair few Qi users, I don't know any PowerMat users (I thought it was abandoned actually).
- theg2 12y agoAs someone with a Windows Phone, I was excited to hear my local Starbucks had installed wireless charging last year and went to try it. Unfortunately it is PowerMat, something I've never seen anyone have. Seems like Duracell (they are the primary backer) is trying to make another push against the market.
- maxsilver 12y agoQi is well supported in almost every wi-power device. Nearly every phone that supports wireless power today, already uses Qi, including already released devices from Samsung, LG, Nokia, BlackBerry, Motorola, and many others over the last two years. PMA / PowerMat is the odd man out. The only time I see it used is when Duracell pays for it (either in their own Powermat line, or their agreements with folks AT&T requiring companies to make Powermat devices like http://bit.ly/UwhZ2R http://bit.ly/UwhZ2R ) I was really hoping that this wouldn't end up being another drawn out compatibility war, and since 99% of the momentum and device support is behind Qi already, it seems efficient to let Qi win. Of course, if Apple releases PMA in the next iPhone, PMA will win by default, no matter how late they choose to release it.
- gdilla 12y agoPowerMat's resonance charging supports multiple devices on one charging matt, whereas Qi uses inductive charging which require more precise placement to charge. I think Qi may have resonant charging solutions coming up or out now, but you can see the better experience in a place like Startbucks would be resonance charging. It's much closer to don't-make-me-think.
- chimeracoder 12y ago> PowerMat's resonance charging supports multiple devices on one charging matt, whereas Qi uses inductive charging which require more precise placement to charge. Both PowerMat and Qi use inductive charging[0][1]. There are some technical differences, but the two are separated more by licensing and legal/political reasons than by actual underlying functionality and technology. [0] http://www.dvice.com/2013-11-15/opinion-unnecessary-smartphone-wireless-charging-war http://www.dvice.com/2013-11-15/opinion-unnecessary-smartpho... [1] https://www.andrewmunsell.com/blog/fight-for-wireless-power https://www.andrewmunsell.com/blog/fight-for-wireless-power
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoQi is everywhere. The problem is that Starbucks announced this project back in 2012 when Powermat was more well known. Google, and others, shifted from supporting pm to qi shortly after, I believe due to licensing costs, and now the market is full of android phones that use qi. I've been using it for my last 2 phones. Works fine with a cheap Energizer charging pad. Its simple and it works. I'm now at the point where I'm annoyed with fiddling with little connectors, especially if its late at night and I'm tired and keyed it the wrong way. Less damaged cables as well. While I'm skeptical it'll be used in public spots due to the potential of theft, its really nice to have at home. From a tech perspective they both use induction. The A4WP product uses magnetic resonance, but I don't think they have a sellable product yet, but in theory they could charge your phone from across the room. I think demos have only shown it work from a few inches away. This solution is very non-green considering the inverse sq law. I have a feeling that there will be pushback if people are wasting 2x or 5x the energy to charge their devices, as well as larger electricity bills. Not to mentionn, Joe User asking about "radiation." The war isn't over because Apple hasn't picked a side. I imagine they'll go with pm to be difficult and to hurt Android's qi based phones. "Oh, you can't charge here, its iPhone only," seems to be a narrative that helps sell the "exclusivity" of their devices. I also find it a little hard to believe that Starbucks would invest in all this technology without some kind of nod from Apple that this will be in their next phone. A4WP signed some agreement with PMA recently, so who knows whats going to happen here. It sounded like a desperate move to me, but now I'm not so sure with the starbucks roll-out and the Apple wildcard at play. http://www.theverge.com/2014/2/11/5398066/a4wp-and-pma-merge-tech-to-win-wireless-charging-war http://www.theverge.com/2014/2/11/5398066/a4wp-and-pma-merge...
- chimeracoder 12y agoI was very excited by this title and incredibly disappointed when I read the actual article and saw that they're using Powermat. Given Starbucks's historical relationship with Apple, I'm fairly convinced now that this means that the next iPhone will have wireless charging through Powermat. Format and standardization wars benefit literally nobody (look at VHS vs. Betamax and Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD). In this case, it's even worse because it'd be fragmentation for the sake of fragmentation - from an end-user perspective, there's essentially no difference between the two[0], and the main issue is really patent royalties more than anything else[1]. [0] This was not the case with VHS and Betamax - there were clear differences between the two formats [1] http://www.dvice.com/2013-11-15/opinion-unnecessary-smartphone-wireless-charging-war http://www.dvice.com/2013-11-15/opinion-unnecessary-smartpho...