4 ms·
It's a shame you would compare a Developed country, supposedly one of the best, with one that's knows to be not so good. It's like comparing your sports team t
by grecy 12y ago
It's a shame you would compare a Developed country, supposedly one of the best, with one that's knows to be not so good.
It's like comparing your sports team to one that consistently finishes low on the ladder - your team will always look good, even when they are far from the top.
If you want a comparison that will lead to improvement, compare your country to those known to have excellent human rights and freedom of information track records.
- ZenPro 12y agoPlease name some countries with excellent human rights and freedom of information track records. The OP compared one member of the UN Security Council with another. There are five permanent members. Are any of the UNSC on your list?
- mrpopo 12y agoThere would be France and the UK. Why do you consider the UNSC as an interesting subset when comparing governmental abuses? This is a genuine question.
- anExcitedBeast 12y agoThe UK does everything the US does and more, just without the pretense of a concern for freedom. France is a cesspool of corruption and systemic bigotry, particularly towards Islamic people. The Security Council are the most powerful countries in the most widely recognized international decision making body. I think it's a fair way to identify US "peers".
- eitland 12y ago> France is a cesspool of corruption and systemic bigotry, particularly towards Islamic people. ?
- ZenPro 12y agoExactly this. Well written.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoThe permanent members of the UNSC are the countries that were the most powerful at the end of World War II, not the countries that are most significant in the present day.
- ZenPro 12y ago...and? What does that have to do with the current discussion? You are partially correct but by and large the UNSC members are the key levers globally. Regardless, the UNSC comment was to indicate that Russia is very much considered a peer of the USA. If they are not to be compared/contrasted then the debate is meaningless.
- pizza234 12y agoThe problem here is that it's hard, if not impossible, to judge the two countries in such single-dimensional way. For example if we would take into account the incarceration rate, USA has a higher one than Russia. On a more subtle analysis, it's unfortunately possible that there is actually a (undergoing) way to silence dissidence, which is "just" different from directly killing people, for example legal rape, or manufacturing of doubt, just to mention a few. Essentially, I think that there's no such direct comparison, and constructive analysis should take into account many many factors and contexts.
- swombat 12y agoI'd argue that the US lost its reputation as "one of the best" quite some time ago. Communist Russia is probably still an overly contrasting comparison point - the US is not as bad as that - but compared to countries that are actually among "the best", the US has been quite low down the rankings for some time now. So actually the OP's comparison seems fair. "The US may be bad these days, but at least it's not (yet) as bad as some of the worst in history!"
- grecy 12y ago> So actually the OP's comparison seems fair. "The US may be bad these days, but at least it's not (yet) as bad as some of the worst in history!" Pondering how bad things could get is not going to make things better. Surely the comparison should be "It's not as good as it used to be, let's make it better!"
- logfromblammo 12y agoLet's just go with Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Denmark for now, with New Zealand and Singapore thrown in to prove that you don't have to be Scandinavian to have an uncorrupted government.
- ZenPro 12y agoSweden? The country trying to illegally force EU countries to extradite Julian Assange in clear violation of EU law?[1] That Sweden? [1]http://cjicl.org.uk/2012/06/20/assange-v-swedish-prosecution-authority-the-misapplication-of-european-and-international-law-by-the-uk-supreme-court-part-i-2/ http://cjicl.org.uk/2012/06/20/assange-v-swedish-prosecution... I assume you are ignoring the corruption detailed in http://www.business-anti-corruption.com/media/3831417/TI-Sverige_ENIS_studie-2.pdf http://www.business-anti-corruption.com/media/3831417/TI-Sve...
- logfromblammo 12y agoI do not claim that those governments are not in any way corrupt. They are simply the least corrupt of an inherently corruptible tradition. The point is that we should be following our hopes rather than fleeing from our fears. Comparing yourself to the worst of your peers and patting yourself on the back because you are still somewhat better is blinding yourself to the absolutely unacceptable backsliding that has been occurring. Even comparing yourself to the best of your peers and dreaming about surpassing them is not enough. The ultimate, unattainable goal is zero corruption and perfect transparency. Effort required increases asymptotically as we approach that limit. So it would seem that the only way to avoid having corruption in your government is to not have one at all.
- grecy 12y agoThank you for saying that better than I can.
- gdewilde 12y agoWe could have made the participatory government 20 years ago. I always explain it like this (try to): Our ancestors did not have Internet, direct participation was not possible. We therefore cant expect those ancestors of ours to have seriously considered it - at any stage. Arguably, before the Internet, everyone did his best to participate as much as they could. The new ingredient our generation introduced is for voters not to have influence on par with the technical possibilities. If we would be overly modest we could allow that single vote to be changed when the voter wants to change it. If the voter cant change his vote the election program is not legally binding. One can say whatever he likes to get elected and enjoy 4 whole years without any consequences. Technically we should be participating in the debate about specific issues at hand. Our officials would have little to do beyond the organization of that information (a feat easily automated) If we can do social networks and we can do flash trading then we need very little beyond a tech team and a few symbolic figure heads to make a kick ass democracy. We can do considerably more than vote 1 time, ideas from citizens are a type of resource, value waiting to be extracted. Extraction will help it grow faster. Clearly we are missing out on incalculable riches, just sitting there, expiring while waiting for exploitation.