5 ms·
Yes, either linear memory devices like C/L, or creating digital memory cells out of positive feed back hysteresis. Running out of battery is just one of the lim
by mindslight 12y ago
Yes, either linear memory devices like C/L, or creating digital memory cells out of positive feed back hysteresis. Running out of battery is just one of the limits of the abstraction. I mean it as a mental exercise in demonstrating that one can easily build a circuit that fulfills the equation of a memristor - does its mere emulated existence make it interesting? Why aren't these "emulated memristors" (obviously with a third terminal for a power supply, a different abstraction limit) a standard building block of modern circuits, even in just hobbyist discrete form?
I'm sure there are specific devices being worked on that have exciting applications to memory, and I'm certainly not putting down the researchers involved with them or their work. But it seems like the "memristor" narrative is a bit of a hype train that has taken on a life of it's own. Let's say one team of researchers were to develop a miniature device with a similar but decidedly non-linear effect. Would this make it any less important?
(And if my judgment is wrong and we end up with an entirely new family of passives based on the same fundamental physics with usual differentiation based on power handling/size/etc, I'll be happy to eat my words).
- jacquesm 12y ago> And if my judgment is wrong and we end up with an entirely new family of passives based on the same fundamental physics with usual differentiation based on power handling/size/etc, I'll be happy to eat my words That will be the best case ever of being happy to be wrong. If true the implications are on par with some pretty advanced SF in terms of computing power and storage. Content addressable memory anybody?
- XorNot 12y agoEvery effect is linear if you constraint your domain enough. But you are right - the real news is more that we've got a new way to manufacture some type of memory storage element (that's also conveniently fundamentally tiny). It is definitely not the only way though: IBMs been working on magnetic racetrack memory for some time which would have many of the same advantages.
- jacquesm 12y agoMagnetic racetrack sounds like bubble memory warmed over with associated feelings. The good news is that 'bubbles' are real, they just never broke through commercially. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bubble_memory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bubble_memory vs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racetrack_memory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racetrack_memory So many common elements.