3 ms·
It's actually a centuries old industry: taxis were already regulated in 1636[1]. I think the point is, though, not whether they can do it better (they are certa
by pron 12y ago
It's actually a centuries old industry: taxis were already regulated in 1636[1]. I think the point is, though, not whether they can do it better (they are certainly a driver for innovation in the space), but how successful that particular company is going to be.
Given that in most cities you could pick up a phone and get a taxi for over a century, or hit some buttons on your mobile phone and order one for the last 20 years, this becomes a question regarding two aspects of Uber: deregulation and brokerage, which are Uber's two differentiating factors. The author claims that deregulation has been tried numerous times -- and failed pretty much everywhere (although, maybe this time it's different) -- and that brokerage of a commodity is not too profitable[2].
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom#...
[2]: http://www.quora.com/Uber-1/How-big-of-a-deal-is-Uber/answer/Justin-Singer http://www.quora.com/Uber-1/How-big-of-a-deal-is-Uber/answer...
- paul 12y agoI've ordered taxies by phone, and I've used Uber, and I can tell you that I have no doubt as to which is the future. As for network effects, is it really that hard to see that a larger network of vehicles will have inherent advantages over a smaller network? (think about distance to the nearest available vehicle, especially as the network expands outside of dense urban areas)
- pron 12y agoEverything you say is true, but none of it predicts tremendous success for Uber. It may well be that there's little advantage to being the first mover brokering commodities. We might soon see meta-Uber apps, or Uber aggregators, that optimize the selection of car across several providers. Uber will probably just be a big, successful, taxi company, but not one that is worth billions.