4 ms·
Though the title of the paper was shortened by yours truly to fit on HN, the paper is actually about tech rather than politics. Hypothesis 1: Global news med
by jcr 12y ago
Though the title of the paper was shortened by yours truly to fit on HN,
the paper is actually about tech rather than politics.
Hypothesis 1: Global news media attention will be heavily concentrated
on a few NGOs.
Hypothesis 2: The distribution of global news media attention among
NGOs will correlate closely with the distribution of organizational
resources among NGOs.
Hypotheses Three and Four make the same predictions but with respect
to getting the attention of individual citizens via the Web and social
media:
Hypothesis 3: Global public attention on the Web and in social media
will be heavily concentrated on a few NGOs.
Hypothesis 4: The distribution of global public attention will
correlate closely with the distribution of organizational resources
among NGOs.
Hypotheses Three and Four lie at the crux of the current debate.
Though many observers would acknowledge that Hypotheses One and Two
are likely to be true, the premise recent enthusiasm about the Web and
social media is the supposed democratization of communications. If the
Internet is indeed democratizing NGO communications, then Hypotheses
Three and Four must be false. If they are true, on the other hand,
then the promise of the Web and social media to provide improved
access to the global public for all groups especially the less wealthy
and powerful in society may turn out to have been an appealing
illusion.
Abstract
"Historically, NGOs have relied on mainstream news media to expose
human rights violations and encourage governments to pressure the per-
petrators. Thanks to the Internet, NGOs are crafting new strategies for
conducting information politics. Despite the obvious democratization of
access to the means of communication, however, the new media may in
fact represent a more challenging environment in which to be heard for
some groups seeking global attention. We draw on agenda setting research
to develop a theory of global attention competition and use it to explain
the success of 257 transnational human rights groups at generating at-
tention in both international mainstream news media and social media
outlets. We conclude that most NGOs lack the organizational resources
to compete effectively for either traditional news coverage or for public
attention and that the Internet is unlikely to resolve the problem of global
communication."