5 ms·
It's really clever, and I enjoyed the process involved immensely. The whole project is a work of art IMHO. I'm looking forward to watching the documentary of it
by bane 12y ago
It's really clever, and I enjoyed the process involved immensely. The whole project is a work of art IMHO. I'm looking forward to watching the documentary of it all.
I also like this conclusion.
> My experiment doesn't prove that Vermeer worked this way, but it proves that he COULD have worked this way.
I do take issue with the hypothesis.
>The way Vermeer painted this wall is consistent with a photograph. It is not consistent with human vision. If you were standing in the room that Vermeer painted, you would see that wall as a pretty even shade of off-white. The retina in your eyeball does some image processing to minimize the effect of light and shadow. To your eye, the wall appears to have far less contrast than it actually has. And if you can't see it, you can't paint it.
Then you can't see it through this device either.
I'm not an artist, but I've taken a few art classes, and one of the transformative things that happens during formal art training is that you learn to look at things in non-intuitive ways. For example, when most people are told to "draw a dog", even if they're looking at one, they reach back into their semantic memory, look up the mental function for "draw dog" and reproduce that.
The same thing is true for colors, brightness values, etc. A great deal of formal art education is learning to detach your visual stimulus from the semantic association you would otherwise naturally make...and perhaps reattach it to new semantic associations like "negative space" and "comparative brightness" and "relative white value". When you get really good you can even start reprocessing a scene or a model, deconstructing it in your mind and then reconstructing it via some other technique. You can go from photorealistic reproduction to complete abstraction.
http://www.etsycreative.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/vince-low-portraits-550x660.jpg http://www.etsycreative.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/vince...
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/_94URbVj_t8A/SZ7v2Iw28qI/AAAAAAAAAs0/KtyBdLmQohg/s320/tina+marker+on+canvas.jpg https://3.bp.blogspot.com/_94URbVj_t8A/SZ7v2Iw28qI/AAAAAAAAA...
http://uploads2.wikiart.org/images/vincent-van-gogh/the-starry-night-1889(1).jpg http://uploads2.wikiart.org/images/vincent-van-gogh/the-star...
https://gs1.wac.edgecastcdn.net/8019B6/data.tumblr.com/e8b9914990f75a949b1dbb9b1724ab6b/tumblr_mie7raQqj91ql98k2o1_1280.jpg https://gs1.wac.edgecastcdn.net/8019B6/data.tumblr.com/e8b99...
http://www.mde-art.com/art-blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/abstract-portrait-face-lines-color.jpg http://www.mde-art.com/art-blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/02/a...
I think a better hypothesis might have been "techniques at the time weren't suited to such exact reproduction of scenes, even great artists slightly distort objects and subjects in their work. Yet these paintings don't appear to suffer from such distortion, the shape and color reproduction is as exact as a tracing or photograph. There must have been a technique or tool used to assist the artist in not only tracing the shape, but reproducing the colors."
- yincrash 12y agoI believe the device is meant to focus on certain locations so you can perceive the colors accurately without the brain doing image processing based on surrounding context.
- nardi 12y agoIn particular, the edge of the mirror is the key. By optically putting the subject of your painting directly next to the painting itself, you can directly compare shapes and tones. And moving your head back and forth, you can "scan" the edge of the mirror across the painting to find inconsistencies.
- jnbiche 12y agoI was wondering how in the world this device works, but this explains it well. I understand now how an untrained artist can make such an amazing painting.
- murbard2 12y agoThere is neurological evidence for your thesis:http://www.nytimes.com/2003/06/22/magazine/22SAVANT.html http://www.nytimes.com/2003/06/22/magazine/22SAVANT.html Savant like drawing skills can be induced in ordinary people by selectively disabling the part of their brain responsible for semantic interpretation. See the shape of the cat, not the cat. Perhaps Vermeer was a savant.
- stan_rogers 12y agoNot likely. There is a reason why the rather nasty Supper at Emmaus van Meegeren forgery was able to fools the experts, and that's that Vermeer wasn't a particularly good draughtsman early on. Good colourist for the most part, yes, but not much cop at getting things straight or in proportion. His early works show distinct signs of painting things iconically; that is, he was drawing and painting what he "knew" things looked like rather than what they actually looked like. So he learned something in mid-career to change everything, and an optical device is a likely aid. I'm not convinced that a lucie was necessary. It's easy enough to create contour lines for tone using a camera obscura while you're tracing edges; it's something you can accomplish in a few minutes' work, and it's much less likely to be remarked upon by your sitting clients. (Let's remember that Vermeer took commissions; not everything could have been kept "in the family".)