5 ms·
It's not like they're selecting for poor black males. Remember, if this treatment works, it's not going to be primarily applied to rich whites; it's going to be
by vacri 12y ago
It's not like they're selecting for poor black males. Remember, if this treatment works, it's not going to be primarily applied to rich whites; it's going to be applied to the exact same demographic as the guinea pigs.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> Remember, if this treatment works, it's not going to be primarily applied to rich whites; it's going to be applied to the exact same demographic as the guinea pigs. What are you basing this on? Chances are this is absurdly expensive (ICU stays can cost millions) and may be unlikely to see wide use in poor areas - the hospitals'd be eating the cost most of the time.
- afarrell 12y agoDo US hospitals ever turn away people from the ICU because of cost? If so, how do they verify the ability of an unconscious person to pay before treatment? I was under the impression that they already ate those costs.
- prutschman 12y agoMy brief googling turns up the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act, and an accompanying FAQ: http://www.emtala.com/faq.htm http://www.emtala.com/faq.htm > 13. Can the hospital inquire about the patient's ability to pay? > Yes, but timing is everything. The statute does not prohibit an inquiry into availability of medical insurance; it does provide that neither examination nor treatment may be delayed to make the inquiry. > Prior to 2003, some knowledgeable commentators had suggested that no discussion of any payment issues should take place before the medical screening examination and any needed stabilizing treatment are provided. CMS has even recommended that hospital personnel not answer any questions initiated by the patient, apparently on the theory that some patients may be dissuaded from staying if they learn that they will be financially responsible for the treatment, even if they are assured that they will be seen without consideration of payment issues. Such recommendations, however, do not arise to the level of a definitive statement of what is required. I don't know if the Affordable Care Act changed any of this.
- ghkbrew 12y agoYou're right. Legally ERs can't turn away patients. They have to "stabilize" them before discharge. However not all ERs are equal. It's entirely possible that procedures like this wouldn't be available in a less well funded (read: poorer) hospitals. At least until it becomes what's known as the "standard of care", where the healthcare provider can be culpable for not providing the treatment. Though, honestly, I don't really see that happening. If this is successful, I would expect to primarily see first adoption in hospitals which already have high trauma rates. Which, typically, are hospitals serving poorer areas.
- robotresearcher 12y agoIf it works, it'll also be used for soldiers. These are not usually rich people, and not predominantly white.
- VLM 12y agoAlso science does not stand still. If this improves outcomes for stabbed black men (of which we have a vast supply compared to other subjects), there are a zillion logical next research steps none of which necessarily involve stabbed black men. So... if "generic major surgery" goes horribly wrong, they'll chill you and fix it rather than letting your brain die. I wonder if you could come up with a cancer chemotherapy treatment that has such severe effects that the patient literally can't live thru it, but if you chill them first and then reboot them with a clean blood supply... imagine something that successfully kills tumors but coincidentally liquifies brain tissue. Well, just shut off the brain for awhile by shutting off its flow of blood. Can't poison something if no poison ever gets there. Do the treatment and kill the cancer, then flush out the circulatory system with saline, replace with fresh blood, reconnect the brain to the circulatory system (note to self; don't forget this step) and then reboot them. I would have to think if there's anything else interesting you can do with a complete "flush -n- fill" of the circulatory system. Maybe treat horrific industrial or research lab accidental poisonings. Sure maybe its less risky to just pour in and drain out 100x your blood capacity to flush it, but what if the industrial accident affected 50 people, that's 5000 people's worth of blood, lots will have to die untreated unless you find a more scalable treatment.