3 ms·
It's not just her family. She was applying for government assistance. People try to defraud government programs so countermeasures are developed. One is ensurin
by Jtsummers 12y ago
It's not just her family. She was applying for government assistance. People try to defraud government programs so countermeasures are developed. One is ensuring that the children people claim as dependents (and thus will get money for) are, in fact, their children. If someone turns up with 3 kids and falsified documents, DNA tests would reveal the attempted fraud (assuming the kids aren't their identical twin's or a very genetically close sibling's).
In this case the bureaucrats, as you call them, were faced with someone who appeared to be attempting to defraud the government. She insisted (rightly) that they were her children, but initially the DNA evidence pointed to that being a lie. They asked about them being her sister's children (suggesting she was the aunt), she denied this. They inquired about surrogacy, in vitro, etc. She insisted that the children were conceived normally and delivered by her. Once the latter was proven, the DNA still didn't match which left the surrogacy angle (which presented a risk that she'd defrauded someone else). She'd likely get assistance if it had been surrogacy (but she kept the kids legitimately) or in vitro with donated eggs and above board, but she kept insisting (because she was right) that it wasn't, which left the investigators in a bind. The facts didn't match the claims.
It's unfortunate that she happened to get caught up in all of this when she was totally innocent of any wrongdoing or attempted fraud, but given the odds of chimerism the bureaucrats were not wrong to investigate further. Now that the condition is known and understood hopefully this will be resolved more quickly for future chimeras.
- ensignavenger 12y agoRight, they were not wrong to investigate further. They were wrong to take such extreme action, pending the results of further investigation.
- jessaustin 12y agoAttempts to defraud the government are punished by losing one's children? Can you point to a particular law that establishes this? I'll certainly think twice before grabbing extra maps at highway rest stops from now on... In the absence of any complaint from any interested party, the default action should not be "break up this family and parcel out the kids to foster homes where they're more likely to be abused and will definitely cost the government more." We should have less empathy for powerful and stupid bureaucrats and more empathy for their victims. This is especially so now that they have total surveillance powers over us, so our every private expression can be misconstrued by cretins to justify any action they'd like to take.
- Jtsummers 12y agoIn this case, the fraud is that they aren't her children (that was the accusation, not the reality). They'd be removed because she had either borrowed them from someone to conduct the fraud or "borrowed" them (read: potential for kidnapping) them from someone and committed a crime in addition to attempting fraud. Was this not clear in the article? They didn't believe the children were hers. That was the entire premise of the government's involvement after the initial exams.
- jessaustin 12y agoThey weren't taking the children to give them to someone deemed more likely to be a parent, or indeed to someone who even claimed to be a parent. They were just taking them. If you think this makes any sense at all, you've got the burden of proof reversed. Yay totalitarianism!
- Jtsummers 12y agoThey did not (unless I missed it again after a third read of the article) take the children away. They threatened to because they were not (per the DNA) her children. That's the crux of the issue. They appeared to be someone else's children, she had no paperwork for adoptions. She denied that in vitro was used for conception. She had, if these results were correct and she were not a chimera, no apparent legal claim to these children. That meant they came from somewhere else, which is what the state would've been left trying to determine if the chimerism hadn't been discovered. If someone comes to you with a story that completely contradicts all evidence ("I didn't do it, I just look exactly like the guy that did and happen to have the same name and live in the same house.") you wouldn't believe them. The story contradicted the physical evidence. Her pregnancy and delivery only confused it because it indicated that, rather than the children being abducted, in vitro was probably being used (again, there was no reason to suspect chimerism given its rarity and extreme obscurity at the time). Labs repeatedly showed that the children were not hers. In 999,999 cases out of a million they would have been correct, that she was conducting some sort of fraud. This isn't totalitarianism. That'd be, they found the DNA didn't match and took the kids from her and the father that instant, locked her up and even after the discovery of chimerism kept her imprisoned for fraud and refused to allow visitation with her children. This was an unfortunate case that ended well (though stressful throughout).