4 ms·
No, it's not "a person murdering other person." Definitely and absolutely not "a woman murdering the twin." The small set of cells is still not a person. The ce
by acqq 12y ago
No, it's not "a person murdering other person." Definitely and absolutely not "a woman murdering the twin." The small set of cells is still not a person. The cells just started to grow (multiply) together instead of separately.
If you believe that the "person" starts as soon as the chromosomes of the two parents mix, you probably have some strong religious views, but then try to inform yourself how much such "persons" become destructed all the time and question who made the world to be so:
http://www.pregnancyloss.info/info-howcommon.htm http://www.pregnancyloss.info/info-howcommon.htm
During the first week: "It is estimated that 3 out of 4 eggs that are fertilized (..) either do not attempt to implant or fail at implantation."
Do you call those "murders" too? If you do, by whom? If not, why do you call that other cell behavior, where the two sets continue to grow together (note: both sets continue to live!) a murder?
- afarrell 12y agoWell it seems to me that it would be an considered accidental death. Of course, if 75% of egg fertilizations result in the death of a person, then having unprotected sex shows a callous disregard for human life.
- acqq 12y agoStill in the article case, there's certainly no "death" of the genetic information of both "twins." They both still live inside of the same body: one in some organs, another in the rest of the organs of the same body. If the "person" exist as soon as the egg and sperm mix, both of the mixes exist and live in the same body, that is, both "persons" according to that (in my opinion, just constructed out of the suspicious religious premises) definition are alive. And under different definition of the person (which I prefer, as something that has to have "a personality" to be considered as a person) there was always only one person: the woman that has different DNA in different organs of her. The joining of the different cells happened before a functional organism existed, and since then, it's only one.