4 ms·
> What are the arts but products of the human mind which resonate with our aesthetic and emotional faculties? Ah, the old "mental equivalent of cheesecake" arg
by vanderZwan 12y ago
> What are the arts but products of the human mind which resonate with our aesthetic and emotional faculties?
Ah, the old "mental equivalent of cheesecake" argument - Pinker explicitly used that one for music IIRC, which supposedly hijacked our love of language. The latter goes against fairly overwhelming evidence that music is a much older "faculty" than language. Then again, Pinker is a philosopher (don't get me wrong, a wonderful one), and philosophers tend to fetishize language. When you look at the topic of the article that obviously applies to Pinker too. But to give a specific example, look this quote:
> The medium by which we share complex ideas, namely language
THE medium? While extremely powerful, vocal or written language is a linear, monotone string of abstract symbols, which has some severe limitations in certain situations (but for comparison, check out sign language; three spatial dimensions to play with, oh my!). We don't say "a picture says more than a thousand words" because it isn't true. Similarly, music often mediates emotions in a much clearer and directer way than words ever do. In turn, pictures and music have their ambiguities in places where language shines of course.
Anyway, so we supposedly have these "faculties" somewhere in the brain for aesthetics and emotions, distinct functions evolved that way for some purpose, and then these get hijacked by things that trigger it (art), like some supernormal stimulus[0].
While it sure can be helpful to analyze things in these terms, and is consistent within its own framework, I think saying art is "nothing but" this is a bit too reductionist, greatly oversimplifying things. You simply won't see the bigger picture with this approach. For example, Petran Kockelkoren has argued that art is part of the process of "domesticating" new technologies, societal changes, etc[1]. That is, the way in which we take something "strange" and "unnatural" and make it "normal" and "natural" to us.
Having said all that, I love Steve Pinker, his writing and his clear thinking and think it's a great article. Just this itty bitty point always ruffles my feathers a bit.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supernormal_stimulus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supernormal_stimulus
[1] http://doc.utwente.nl/79298/1/Kockelkoren05art.pdf http://doc.utwente.nl/79298/1/Kockelkoren05art.pdf
- jmcqk6 12y ago>. Then again, Pinker is a philosopher (don't get me wrong, a wonderful one), He is a bit of a philosopher, but his ph.d. is in experimental psychology. In other words, he's not just thinking here, but probably has a basis for what he's saying in empirical tests. He is very much an empiricist.
- vanderZwan 12y agoFair enough, but that is perfectly compatible with my claim that he can be a bit overly reductionist at times (I'm not denying that reductionism is a useful tool of course - far from it). He seems to be either unaware or ignoring indications that music is way older than language. * We acquire language through prosodic or "singsong" language - you know, the way people tend to go up and down and exaggerate in their intonation when talking to babies. * Conversely, it stays with us much longer than language does, and capable of "reviving" someone in a way language can't: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fyZQf0p73QM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fyZQf0p73QM * Based on nerve size we know our muscle control of our vocal apparatus was at our "modern" quality long before we acquired the capacity for symbolic manipulation that is required for language - in the order of hundreds of thousands of years versus tens of thousands or years. We couldn't have used it for language, but we already were a social species so it stands to reason that we were using it for communication. So what other options do we have aside from language that still require such refined control of our vocal output but some singsong form of uttering "intentions" towards each other?