6 ms·
Waiver of a right != denial of a right If someone takes your apples, it makes a huge difference whether you agreed to trade them for the taker's oranges. A ri
by SilasX 12y ago
Waiver of a right != denial of a right
If someone takes your apples, it makes a huge difference whether you agreed to trade them for the taker's oranges.
A right that you cannot waive is not a right; it is an obligation.
- lukifer 12y agoIn that case: am I allowed to voluntarily pledge every minute of my life to you for the next 7 years in exchange for an all-expenses trip to the other side of the world? If I change my mind, are you allowed to imprison and torture me until I comply to the terms of the agreement? While this is textbook ad absurdum, there is some point at which a line is drawn on which rights may be voluntarily surrendered, especially as regards selling one's future self. (Or if you believe that all rights can be voluntarily sold/surrendered: Can I voluntarily surrender my right to surrender rights? Can I sign a contract that says I may no longer sign contracts?)
- SilasX 12y agoIndeed, there is a line; the existence of a right to free choice of labor ain't it though.
- lukifer 12y agoYou tell me where you think the line should be drawn: (a) You agree not to leave Apple* for Google, for 3 years. (b) You agree not work for Google, ever. (c) You agree not to develop software for anyone besides Apple for 3 years. (d) You agree not to develop software for anyone besides Apple, ever. (e) You agree not to do any kind of work for anyone besides Apple for 3 years. (f) You agree not to do any kind of work for anyone besides Apple, forever. Personally, I don't think any of those contracts should be enforceable by law, regardless of what people foolishly choose to sign. * (the choice of Apple being entirely arbitrary)
- SilasX 12y agoHowever I draw the line, it would not be grounded in appeal to the existence of a right to choice in labor, as you attempted to justify it. There are good arguments for prohibiting certain arrangements; the one you gave wasn't one of them. That's all I was trying to say.
- nitrogen 12y agoFor philosophical reasons, I like using the idea of fundamental human rights to justify things more than simple pragmatism. It makes it easier to build a solid foundation of things that can be taken for granted in a human existence, making more cognitive effort available for other matters.
- SilasX 12y agoPeople also have a universal, fundamental right to some level of property ownership. But if you equate that with the obligation never to waive it in exchange for something else (e.g. sell or give their stuff), as the GGGP was doing, then "you're doing it wrong". There are good reasons to oppose the specific exchange of rights involved in these non-compete agreements. Pointing out the existence of the rights is not one of them, because the entire dispute is about why it should not be waive-able.
- dredmorbius 12y agoYou're making shit up. There's nothing in the legal definition of "right" that implies it must be waiveable. From Black's Law Dictionary: "An interest or expectation guaranteed by law". There are inalienable (or inherent rights) which cannot be transferred or surrendered (though they might be terminated): life, liberty. And there are rights which cannot be waived. The right to sue, for example, though you might lose your right to trial by jury if you agree to arbitration.
- SilasX 12y ago>There's nothing in the legal definition of "right" that implies it must be waiveable. From Black's Law Dictionary: "An interest or expectation guaranteed by law". I wasn't speaking of legal definitions, just making the uninteresting observation that, if I can't trade a right for something more valuable to me, then it is functionally an obligation, and not the bundle of goodness typically associated with rights. Again, consider the difference between a property right in your apples when you can vs can't sell/give them. >There are inalienable (or inherent rights) which cannot be transferred ... >And there are rights which cannot be waived. The right to sue, for example, though you might lose your right to trial by jury if you agree to arbitration. ... You're assuming exactly what's under dispute. I don't accept that such rights should exist, so asserting that they do tells me nothing more than that you agree with the (IMHO misguided) legal classification certain rights have. I certainly agree that some rights need a higher standard of proof, waiting period, etc before giving up, to establish that it's valid consent and the person is thinking clearly and so on. (We definitely dont do this right when it comes to police searches.) But that's miles away from certain rights being unconditionally inalienable by the holder. Have you ever thought about why others should always be able to veto my sale of a right altogether? Edit: I'd appreciate a more constructive response than downvoting.
- dredmorbius 12y agoI'm not among the downvoters (it's not possible for responses to ones' own posts), but you're continuing to argue for something that's not at all supported under legal doctrine, as well as highly disfunctional in reality, though you're at least doing so under the cloak of personal belief, rather than trying to claim some sort of authority. Your definitions continue to be fabrications without foundations in broader legal or political theory.