3 ms·
> If you are an engineer in a niche field, in particular, being barred from that field for a year or more is tantamount to rendering your professional knowledge
by tzs 12y ago
> If you are an engineer in a niche field, in particular, being barred from that field for a year or more is tantamount to rendering your professional knowledge obsolete.
What if it was the employer that taught you the niche field? They hired you, and then sent you through six months of training to learn the field. During this time, you are producing very little of value, but you are being paid.
Then, when you finish the training and are ready to be productive with your new niche knowledge, you get poached by their competitor--a competitor who can pay higher wages because it isn't spending tens of thousands of dollars on training for new employees.
It seems to me that there should be some way for the employer to protect against the above scenario. What would be acceptable instead of a noncompete?
Some ideas:
1. A noncompete that runs from the START of employment instead of from the END of employment. If training takes six months, the noncompete would say you cannot work for a competitor for 18 months after start of employment.
2. Charge for training, with payment due in monthly installments starting at the end of training. The company waives payment for each month that the employee continues working for them. The employee can leave for a competitor at any time, but will then be responsible for making the remaining payments for his training.
- _delirium 12y agoI'd be okay with provisions restricting (or penalizing) quitting early in those kinds of situations if they are approximately symmetric. For example a 2-year minimum employment period in which there are penalties for either side abrogating the contract early (the employee leaving before two years, or the company laying the employee off before two years, maybe with exceptions for serious misconduct on either side).
- tptacek 12y agoIt's not clear to me why the employer investing in training has somehow shouldered some additional obligation to the employee.
- _delirium 12y agoIt's the employer modifying the at-will employment arrangement and attempting to restrict the employee's freedom to choose jobs at will, which should result in a symmetric obligation. The default situation in most U.S. states is at-will employment: either side may terminate the employment relationship at any time, for any or no reason, with any notice they choose to give or none. If a more durable arrangement is desired, so the employee cannot leave tomorrow with no notice (thereby giving up the normal freedom to work only willingly for employers, and leave when it is no longer willing), then IMO it should be set out in advance and honored by both sides, e.g. by using a fixed-term or minimum-term contract, with penalties for early termination by either side. That way both sides can plan on the stability of the relationship (barring serious misconduct). For example in my current job, either my employer or myself can terminate the employment with four months notice, after the first six months. This gives us both some guarantee that we will be able to plan for major changes— they will have time to find a replacement if I give notice, and I'll have time to find another job if they give notice.
- tptacek 12y agoThe employer is not "modifying the at-will arrangement". The employer is doing the same thing employers do with signing bonuses: "here is a benefit you can have, but if you leave before 12 months is up, you have to give it back". Obviously, training benefits can be abused. "Here is a 'benefit' that is not really a 'benefit' but instead a job requirement for which we have assigned a nearly arbitrary value; if you leave within 12 months, you must pay us this random number back." But as long as "training" has some value assigned by the market with a reference price not controlled by the employer, what's the problem?
- tehwebguy 12y agoOf course, it is all about consideration. I just can't think of an example where training would be enough consideration for a non-compete. Employers always have to pay for experience. You either pay more for an experienced employee or pay for training. With an experienced employee you can include actual benefits, like you mentioned, or you can pay to train someone who will take a lower salary.