3 ms·
I recently signed a contract with a sort of non-compete clause in it, so i'm quite interested in how enforceable they are under English law. Some lawyers recko
by twic 12y ago
I recently signed a contract with a sort of non-compete clause in it, so i'm quite interested in how enforceable they are under English law.
Some lawyers reckon [0]:
"When considering restrictions the general rule is that they are void as they are in illegal restraint of trade and therefore against public policy. However, the courts recognise that some legitimate interests can be protected by reasonable clauses. [...] Although the types of business interests capable of protection are not fixed the usual ones that are protected are customer connection and goodwill, trade secrets and confidential information and the maintenance of a stable workforce (no poaching). Preventing competition is not really a legitimate interest on its own but a non-compete clause may be upheld if it may be the employer's only means of protecting the business."
So, under English law, it's quite likely that there would have been no Fairchild Semiconductor. I believe the crucial test would have been whether the Traitorous Eight were basing their new business on trade secrets they had learned at the Shockley Semiconductor Laboratory, or on know-how they had acquired there. The distinction between those is probably a topic for another day.
[0] http://www.steenandco.co.uk/thomas-v-farr-plc---important-court-case-on-non-compete-clauses-_60/ http://www.steenandco.co.uk/thomas-v-farr-plc---important-co...
- ggreer 12y agoIt sounds like Shockley would have had a decent chance of winning in the UK. In that case, he would have tied things up in court for years to drain resources. Even if he didn't win, Fairchild (and the rest of us) would lose.