3 ms·
There's a flip side to this. Being less trackable means that any passive advertising or active marketing you do see is less tailored to your situation and need
by rahimnathwani 12y ago
There's a flip side to this. Being less trackable means that any passive advertising or active marketing you do see is less tailored to your situation and needs.
When I walk around I see many billboards advertising products for which I have no use (e.g. female hair care products). If tracking technology could replace those with things I actually might buy (even if male hair care products) then I would be a touch happier.
- akira2501 12y agoSerious question: are you sure you'd actually be happier? I like efficiency as much as the next guy, but that doesn't mean that I'm looking forward to companies more efficiently marketing to me. Especially if it's going to be constant.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoNo, I'm not sure. However, I suspect we have some way to go before ad tech gets good enough to creep me out.
- sliverstorm 12y agoI have already started to notice ads targeted at me. Ads for niche outdoor gear companies that I patronize. I can report that it has indeed made me happier, as compared to when the ads were "Click here, Millionth visitor, and win a prize!". The dragnet advertising is a constant assault on your intelligence. It also helps that the targeted ads I am seeing are tasteful & well designed. I adblock 90%+ of the time, but I let ads through on some websites.
- akira2501 12y agoIt can go both ways. When I was researching for the next car I was going to buy, I started getting a _ton_ of car advertisements; however, most of them were useless. What their simple algorithm failed to notice is that I was looking at a very specific class of cars, and I spent more than 1 hour on several manufacturers websites doing research and had mostly narrowed in on my choice. The proper move would be to see that and advertise different dealerships to me, but I only got ads for other cars that I already decided I _didn't_ want. Also, I like to research, in general. Which means I can often come across and get deeply into some very odd subjects and it seems there are some odd correlations out there in society. For example, after doing a bunch of research on different world religions and their origin stories, I started getting ads for the Mormon church, and strangely, for all types of gambling websites, destinations and attractions. None of this advertising was of any use.
- xrjn 12y agoI guess it comes down to a difference in acceptability of intrusive advertising. Personally, I am absolutely disgusted when adverts are tailored towards me (especially since I don't see them most of the time with Adblock). Seeing tailored advertisements brings me a feeling of despair, in the sense that your personal privacy is being exchanged for money. It only serves as a sad reminder that you must actively fight to protect it, and that we, as consumers, are failing at it right now.
- ajslater 12y agoJust opt in. Explicitly.
- User9812 12y agoDo you know what companies never do? They never ask. I see dating ads, cars advertisements, feminine healthcare products, insurance ads, etc. What do I want to see? Travel accessories, computers, hardware, games, tech gadgets, etc. I never see these ads. Why doesn't Google say, hey, you're going to see Adsense all over the internet, advertisements before videos on YouTube, etc. Would you like to select a few categories so that time is spent seeing some cool products that are relevant to you? I've been on the internet for 15+ years, and no one stopped to ask just once. I could select categories in about 20 seconds that would be more accurate than all this data collection and profiling that happens every day. Instead, I just block ads, and install ad block on every computer I come across. I make my living off ad revenue, but ads are absolutely awful, irrelevant and too often malicious. If they gave me the option to select some categories in the past, I probably would have discovered some decent products to buy, and keep them turned on. But nope, I can't recall clicking an ad in the past decade.
- robkeane 12y agoYou can set your interests for ads (and see what Google thinks you like) here: https://www.google.com/settings/u/0/ads https://www.google.com/settings/u/0/ads
- lucaspiller 12y agoGoogle thinks I am 15 years older than I am and I like cats.
- pjc50 12y agoBut if they asked, you could lie to them. Lots of people would. There's a total presumptive lack of trust, which is part of why the whole business is so corrosive.
- paulrov 12y ago> I make my living off ad revenue, but ads are absolutely awful, irrelevant and too often malicious. Sorry but that makes you the worst kind of person. You have no right to complain about the system at all when you're one of the organs keeping it alive.
- MichaelGG 12y agoIs it not easier to tune ads out if they're not targeted? If I want to buy something, I'll go look for it.
- paulrov 12y agoI don't look at them in the first place. By making them more targeted I'm more likely to notice them then be creeped out by the targeting thus making my life worse.