16 ms·
MIT at center of political power play over campus fusion reactor
- jostmey 12y agoAs an aspiring scientist and postdoctoral candidate, few things dishearten me more than when political agendas creep into the scientific process. Research is hard enough not having to worry about political competition. I fear the mixing of science and politics could erode the objectivity of the community.
- soup10 12y agoThis fear is part of why we have the absurdly opaque and inefficient grant writing process, in which funds are allocated by the government without so much as interviewing the recipients.
- DaniFong 12y ago+100 Absolutely this is a key factor in why scientific grants have terrible yield vs private funding. As a former fusion scientist, I saw this coming, and left the field to make my own fortune and direct it towards what I believed the best energy research was.
- afarrell 12y agoName me one field of human endeavor that is not impacted by the fact that groups of humans need a process to decide which things to allocate resources to. Name me one field of human endeavor which is not impacted by the fact that this process is operated by humans and therefore occasionally exhibits pettiness, favoritism, dysfunction and short-sightedness. Name me one field of human endeavor without politics.
- nitrogen 12y agoName me one field of human endeavor that should be more removed from politics than the search for fundamental knowledge about the workings of the universe. "Is" does not imply "ought". We deserve better.
- rando289 12y ago> Name me one field of human endeavor Tons of stuff. I'd rather politics axe "workings of the universe" than vaccinations and disease control.
- maaku 12y agoVaccinations (medical science) and disease control / pandemic response are not as divorced from "workings of the universe" as I think you think they are...
- nitrogen 12y agoI'd rather fund all of those things a thousand times over just by cutting a small fraction of funding to the world's militaries.
- rtpg 12y agoYou seem to underestimate the cost of a lot of science (not to mention that more money doesn't necessarily mean we'll get more results, maybe just the same result duplicated). The ISS is the most expensive structure ever built, after all.
- tobinfricke 12y agoThe ISS is perhaps "the exception that proves the rule": its political value is vastly greater than its scientific value.
- wdr1 12y agoThat's absurd. The majority of budget isn't the military.
- Retric 12y agoWriting fanfiction? Your prohibited from making money from it so it's rather insular.
- pizza 12y agoAccording to the article, this was an issue of MIT's reactor being a waste of money compared to the other reactors the administration backed and continued to increase funding for.
- pdonis 12y agoYes, and I'm not sure that's a fair description. As far as I can tell, MIT's reactor has been producing as much useful data as the other ones; and I don't think the other US projects, or ITER, have a significantly better chance than MIT's of achieving ignition, which is supposed to be the goal that makes all this worth the taxpayer's money. See my response to nitrogen 51 upthread.
- neltnerb 12y agoI think people here are overestimating how well we understand plasma science. I don't have a PhD in that field, but my friends who do seem to think there is still an awful lot of basic science that is just... not there yet.
- pdonis 12y agoThis may be true if by "basic science" you mean being able to rigorously derive the behavior of a complex system like a plasma from first principles. I don't have a PhD, but I have a Master's in Nuclear Engineering, and a lot of the plasma physics I studied while getting it was full of heuristics and phenomenological laws rather than rigorous or at least semi-rigorous derivations from first principles. However, it's not clear that we need to know all that to achieve controlled fusion, and the fusion reactors that are being pushed for global funding are not being pushed as improving our basic science about plasma physics. They are being pushed as engineering efforts that will achieve ignition. As I said in another post upthread, we know what conditions we need to achieve for ignition; we just don't know how to engineer a device to achieve them. That's what ITER and these other devices are supposed to help us figure out.
- neltnerb 12y ago
- wallflower 12y ago> few things dishearten me more than when political agendas creep into the scientific process. "Because of science - not religion or politics - even people like you and me can have possessions that only a hundred years ago kings would have gone to war to own. Scientific method should not be take lightly. The walls of the ivory tower of science collapsed when bureaucrats realized that there were jobs to be had and money to be made in the administration and promotion of science. Governments began making big investments just prior to World War II... Science was going to determine the balance of power in the postwar world. Governments went into the science business big time. Scientists became administrators of programs that had a mission. Probably the most important scientific development of the twentieth century is that economics replaced curiosity as the driving force behind research... James Buchanan noted thirty years ago - and he is still correct - that as a rule, there is no vested interest in seeing a fair evaluation of a public scientific issue.." -From Kary Mullis, the Nobel Prize in Chemistry winner (and the genius inventor of PCR) in an excellent essay in his book "Dancing Naked in the Mind Field".
- kourt 12y agoMIT's next best use of its political power would be to bring Massachusetts laws regarding innovation to parity with California's circa 1980. Specifically, adopting the "Minnesota Model" employee IP protection, making noncompete agreements unenforcable, and protecting moonlighting.
- afarrell 12y agoWe're are working on the noncompete thing: https://malegislature.gov/Bills/188/House/H1715/History https://malegislature.gov/Bills/188/House/H1715/History
- dalek2point3 12y agoAnd backed by solid research by MIT academics: http://mitsloanexperts.mit.edu/matthew-marx-non-compete-agreements-and-their-impact-on-employees/ http://mitsloanexperts.mit.edu/matthew-marx-non-compete-agre...
- VLM 12y agoApparently something useful is being produced, lots of research papers. http://www.psfc.mit.edu/research/alcator/pubs/index.htm http://www.psfc.mit.edu/research/alcator/pubs/index.htm There is a sunk cost effect where it must cost a billion to build another, but only a couple million to keep it running, so once you throw it out, you better be sure you'll never find it useful again because another experiment would have a capital cost of about a century of labor/maintenance cost. Something that big and cool would seem quite capable of generating enough "stuff" to be worthwhile.
- pdonis 12y agoI agree the reactor is useful and shouldn't simply be shut down; but the capital cost could just as easily be recovered for the taxpayers by selling the reactor to a private company that could focus on using the thing productively instead of seeking government grants.
- ufmace 12y agoI've gotta disagree with that. I'm all for private enterprise over government control in general, but I don't believe that there are any private enterprises capable of or willing to do the type of long-term engineering research that we'll need to get a working fusion reactor. The article I linked upthread quotes the MIT researchers as saying that we're about $80 billion in research away from a fusion reactor that can put watts on the grid. What private company in the world has ever invested that level of money on something not likely to pay off for decades?
- pdonis 12y ago> I don't believe that there are any private enterprises capable of or willing to do the type of long-term engineering research that we'll need to get a working fusion reactor. Considering that there are private companies willing to invest in a project to mine asteroids, I think this is too pessimistic. Also, you are implicitly assuming that governments are better at long time horizon projects than private companies. I've gotta disagree with that. A government's time horizon is the next election cycle. Yes, projects like MIT's fusion reactor can continue to be funded for decades, but in order to keep that funding coming, the people working on the project have to spend a significant amount of time every year or two convincing the government that the project is worth continuing to fund. We're only hearing about it now because they weren't able to do that this time around. A private company that is willing to make a long time horizon investment is not going to have the same overhead required to keep the funding going, simply because there are fewer masters to answer to.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ufmace 12y agoHere's a great old Slashdot post with lots of info about what they're doing there: http://beta.slashdot.org/story/167399 http://beta.slashdot.org/story/167399 I'm not sure exactly when it was published, since their new Beta thing hides dates older than 2y ago, but it's great for showing why the MIT project, and all of the other fusion projects, deserve to get a lot more money than they're getting now.
- DennisP 12y agoThat interview makes it pretty clear that the MIT project is not the obsolete boondoggle that the NYTimes portrays it as. They've made significant recent advances. Something I don't think they mentioned: the Alcator C-Mod has the strongest magnetic field of any tokamak in the world, several times stronger than ITER will have. Aside from that, comparing it to ITER is a bit silly since ITER won't be operating for another eight years. We shouldn't just shut down research while we wait.
- DennisP 12y agoA note on Focus Fusion, mentioned in one of the questions: in 2012 they published a paper in Physics of Plasmas, the leading fusion journal, showing they'd reached the temperature and confinement time necessary for boron fusion. Right now they're on the front page of Indiegogo (in the "trending now" section, hit the right arrow) with a $200K campaign for the next piece of equipment they need, a beryllium electrode that they think will improve the plasma density.
- rory096 12y agohttps://www.indiegogo.com/projects/focus-fusion-empowertheworld--3 https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/focus-fusion-empowerthewo...
- pasbesoin 12y ago> Soulskill posted more than 2 years ago | from the and-are-awesome dept. I see that you noted this, as well. I hope Slashdot will reverse this. Some older posts are still very useful and relevant; however, knowing their context including timing is an important part of this. Slashdot used to cater to "technical people", i.e. people who can cope with dated material that is older than e.g. "last week", and that is still specific -- some of us still remember calendars more than a year old and what was happening at specific times of those years. I hope that is not changing. Such a change is not the kind of "social" that I want... -- P.S. From the non-beta version of the site: > Posted by Soulskill on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @10:52AM
- yeukhon 12y agoIs it truly mixing politics or rather about money? If the project is not funded, many will be unemployed. To me, that's the center of the issue. People want to keep their jobs.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoHow do you separate human endeavour from politics and money? They seem to be inextricably. Or rather, they are one and the same thing and we use the terms 'politics', 'money', 'human endeavour', and whatever other terms are fashionable in the social sciences this week, as a convenient way to communicate about specific aspects of the human condition.
- yeukhon 12y agoI don't disagree with you. In fact, I agree with you. My comment is directed at the title of the article, suggesting this has something to do with government and politics. But reading a few paragraphs the whole problem to me is just people don't want to lose their jobs, which is part of reality. I think the journalist who wrote the article is trying to make the money part less, so no one gets hurt by people who are against mass public funding program.
- cjslep 12y agoI had the privilege of touring and getting to see the reactor directly for an ANS student conference. Even without the politics about keeping the reactor active, the way the graduate students use the reactor seems to already be mired in bureaucracy. If I recall correctly, they have to wait on the order of a year (or more) to get one full day with the reactor to conduct their experiment. I can only imagine how horrifying it is to have your thesis work mired in these political struggles.
- DennisP 12y agoI got to see it too, and got an informal tour by one of the grad students. He showed us a steel tie about a meter long, and said they'd calculated that two of them could hold down the Space Shuttle while it was trying to launch. To hold the machine together while it operates, they need 38 of them. It's not surprising they they have so much trouble getting time on the machine. They barely have the funding to run it. During the budget problems last year they went a whole year without running it at all.
- pavement 12y agoThen again, the experiment involves controlling the hot plasma of nuclear reactions using little more than a vacuum and magnets. Nothing like some miserable bureaucracy to separate the responsible adults from the children looking for new toys. I'll take one individual's disillusionment over a nuclear accident any day of the week. Not to mention that one year in college goes by so fast that it's pretty much over before it started.
- noname123 12y agoTangential, but anyone ever been to Paradise the bar or Flour the cafe right across the street from the nuclear power plant? Cool places to go but I've always been afraid there because of the radiation exposure if there's a meltdown.
- mvarner 12y agoI visited Flour a year or so ago and it was absolutely delicious! Lovely atmosphere as well. Totally recommend, regardless of potential nuclear meltdowns :)
- neltnerb 12y agoParadise has cheap, strong drinks, if you're cool with the not fantastic gay porn.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoYou do realise nuclear power is safer than any other base-load generation technology currently employed? Nuclear kills fewer people per kilowatt-hour electricity generated than even roof-top solar, including the deaths from Chernobyl and Fukushima. [1] 1. http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...
- angersock 12y agoThe first nuclear pile of note was under the University of Chicago's stadium, if memory serves. I wouldn't sweat it.
- theplaz 12y agoI lived (in a MIT dorm) in that area for 4 years.
- mathattack 12y agoI'm a big fan of MIT, and consider it a national treasure. My question - will this type of political play create enemies? I can't imagine that the politicians who were overruled were happy, and they can make MIT pay with 1000 small cuts.