3 ms·
That we don't understand how to define intelligence is exactly the point. That's why the Turing test is interesting. The problem with "looking behind the curta
by mcguire 12y ago
That we don't understand how to define intelligence is exactly the point. That's why the Turing test is interesting.
The problem with "looking behind the curtain" is that it traditionally boils down to what I like to think of as the subtle fluid model of intelligence. If you know what is behind the curtain, then obviously it can't be intelligent, because it is not running on the right hardware, for gooey definitions of hardware, or because it doesn't have some Homunculus of Definite Understanding (Hi, Serle!), or because we can see behind the curtain and know what it is doing. Obviously, if we know what it is doing, it is not intelligent, right?
- cLeEOGPw 12y agoIf you look what's behind the curtain of working brain chances are you no longer think of human brain as intelligent either. Seems that for many people though, especially in CS, intelligence gonna be something that works in a way that is complex enough for them to not understand how it works.
- gtremper 12y agoI was fortunate enough to take a philosophy of mind class from Searle during my Computer Science undergrad. Very interesting experience.
- mcguire 12y agoIt has been a while since I read him, and I don't think I ever got a satisfactory answer: how does he get around the unbounded recursion of the Chinese room argument?
- gtremper 12y agoI never agreed with him completely on his views in this regard, but his main point is if you have a system that's governed by rules on input (Like someone looking up the answer in the Chinese room), there's no subjective understanding. So even if you had such a device(room) that behaved flawlessly, there's nothing in there that actually "understands" what's going on. The paper that the Chinese characters are written on doesn't understand, they're paper. And the person carrying out the instructions doesn't understand either, they're just following orders. So what's having the subjective experience/understanding? The main point I took away is that he feels that consciences is an ordinary biological process, and a simulation of that process is not the same as the process. In the same way that a computer simulation of a stomach digesting food isn't the same as an actually stomach digesting food. No matter how good the simulation is, it doesn't actually digest food. So a simulation of consciences, isn't actually consciences, and doesn't have a personal subjective experience.